Odd conversation, Why should anyone care?

Posted by $ AJAshinoff 13 years, 3 months ago to Culture
19 comments | Share | Best of... | Flag

In Goodreads someone started a discussion about the novel Enders Game by Orson Scott Card. Oddly enough, the topic of discussion was centered around the authors anti-homosexual outspokenness and touched very little on his book. Because I can't stand idiocy I chimed in to explain that homophobia (a word they were throwing around liberally toward anyone who dared defend Cards right to his view) was a contrived word that did not have a clinical psychological ailment to support its definition. Not only didn't I know anyone who was afraid of homosexuals, I never heard of anyone who saw a psychiatrist for fear of encountering homosexuals - the word was strictly manufactured to target people, shut down conversation and tag them as haters.

Naturally, my post ignited a string of insults toward me claiming that I was a homophobe and a hater in denial. I replied that I could care less what a person does in their own lives. Ones sexual proclivity in no way effect their ability to provide service to me in exchange for money. Why would i care if my mechanic, bus driver, sales clerk, landscaper, or mailman is gay? Why should anyone wear their sexuality on their sleeve or seek specific rights based on a sexual preference? Their answer: Homophobe.

I can make a solid argument on two different levels why homosexuals make absolutely no sense. But the reality is there are homosexuals in this world, they have as much right to exist as I do and shouldn't be hindered in anyway from life, liberty and pursuit happiness. Caveat: provided they do not step on or make mockery of anyone else or their beliefs to obtain theirs.

I thought it was an interesting discussion and brought it here. I suspect houghtful discussion would prove interesting rather than flaming from activists with their own myopic agendas.

I see this debate as just another divisive tool to tear this country down.


Add Comment

FORMATTING HELP

All Comments Hide marked as read Mark all as read

  • Posted by $ MikeMarotta 13 years, 3 months ago
    Only 8% of people are left-handed. Are they unnatural? Mensa famously sought the top 1%, and now allow the top 2%. Is genius unnatural? Homosexuality is known in the animal kingdom. At the lower levels, fishes and amphibians change their gender to meet population pressures. If you were an asexual prokaryote, conjugation would seem really weird.

    As for marriage, I do not get the lovey-dovey part of asking the government for permission, but marriage is really all about property. Nothing else is consequential. And "property" includes personhood, such as the decision to withhold medical treatment.

    Most of the places on Earth I know of, even backward places, allow persons of any, all, or no gender to enter into such agreements with each other: wills, testaments, living wills, etc.,

    One problem that remains is the set of third-party agreements such as group healthcare and retirement fund disbursements. If you are hetero and unmarried, you are ineligible, but you do have the option of marrying -- and that automatically qualifies you by contract. Those contracts could be amended, could be negotiated, in THEORY. The reality is that such institutions tend to set the terms. If you look at the numbers, then male gays bring a risk of AIDS that females do not, so a market response would be to accept the women, but not the men ... which would be problematic in our legal environment.

    The problems there, of course, originate with the collectivist nature of such programs. At root, the theory is that the (male) wage earner must "provide" for the (female) domestic servant and all the children they have in common. The reality of life here and now is much different than that.

    It's a mess, all right. And it originates in the fact that some people care about something that no one really needs to care about.

    One note: Marriage is real It really exists as an institution in every society. Working toward my bachelor's in criminology (2008), I read a paper about Post Traumatic Stress Syndrome (or Disorder) in Mass Casualty Events. The authors concluded that a 25% PTSD casualty rate was normal: about one-fourth of the people will be deeply affected and need some counseling. Of those, they found that people in their mid-30s who live together BUT ARE NOT MARRIED are at the greatest risk for PTSD.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by $ 13 years, 3 months ago
      Just to play devils advocate, being left-handed or being particularly intelligent (genius) has nothing to do with the prime directive sewn in to mankind: to procreate. Whether its scientific or religious, procreation is at the core of binding social unions (raise offspring, provide food, etc..) and the reason for constructing societies. The PTSD statistic related to marriage is pretty telling...having been married for around 23 years (don't tell my wife I really have fixed idea) I can honestly attest that I am more ready to handle the stresses of prolonged combat than those who are single. :)
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
      • Posted by $ MikeMarotta 13 years, 3 months ago
        Right. And I appreciate your opening statement, of course. My problem is that despite the fact that homosexuality seems to violate the Darwinian Imperative, it never goes away. I don't know why. It is not just some special sin that people invented. Hard to say how it gets passed on from generation to generation, species after species.
        Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
        • Posted by $ 13 years, 3 months ago
          While the jury is still out I suspect we will eventually find that homosexuality is a genetic or chemical difference which encourages attraction to the same sex. The small numbers of homosexuals suggests some type of deviation in the genetic code or chemical balance somewhere along the way. Over all though, it doesn't really matter. People are people and we should be treating them accordingly.
          Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Lucky 13 years, 3 months ago
    Enders Game: a story I find quite fascinating.
    I've read it twice (or more) and do not recall any pro or con about homosexuality in it. Card, the author, may have been against from his religion tho' it is not apparent in the book.
    About some things I am tolerant, about others I am indifferent. What I am against is over the line intolerance by vicious condemnation of opponents, advocacy at taxpayer cost and forced acceptance. Yes, as you say, this seems to be the situation with the left/gay movement.
    All is permitted. But on a lot of it- ' include me out.'
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Rozar 13 years, 3 months ago
    It is a major distraction for the country, with the saddest part being that the largest hot topic is whether they can get married which seems like such a trivial issue.

    Also I would like to hear your argument as to why it doesn't make sense.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by $ 13 years, 3 months ago
      Its pretty easy.

      1) Scientific - Homosexuality is an abnormality in the species. I do not say this as an insult just a point of fact. In science you have a sample group and the common factors become the norm the uncommon factors become abnormal. Homosexuals by high estimates make a very small fraction the population globally (high estimates are only 2-3%).

      2) Darwinian - a species cannot survive if it does not reproduce. Left to themselves homosexuals cannot reproduce.

      3) Religious - "go forth an multiply", enough said there. "Abomination", enough said there.

      As for marriage I personally think homosexuals should be able to marry. However, I think their marriages should be conducted only by those institutions who permit it. Its not a government issue. Nor is a sexual preference/proclivity a need to define rights aside from that which is naturally born to every man and woman. Any religion which condemns homosexuals should not suffer any wrath for following the tenants of their belief structure.

      I wrote this article a while back. I still wonder what would happen.

      http://amchron.soundenterprises.net/arti...
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
      • Posted by Rozar 13 years, 3 months ago
        I'll read your article soon but I have to say I applaud your ability to allow individual rights for people whose lifestyle you disagree with.
        Your point one is very factual, and honestly everything you've said is completely true from what I can reckon. However if the points your giving are backing your premise that homosexuality makes no sense at all, there may be some holes. As in there are plenty of abnormalities in humans besides being gay, but you wouldn't say any of them don't make sense. Every abnormality has a cause. I don't know whether you side with the "born that way" or "free will" side of the argument, but both of those are reason enough for it to make sense. After all most humans don't have sex simply to reproduce, and some humans strive to be abnormal for the sheer satisfaction of it. Doing something because you enjoy it is common sense.

        I don't have a comment on the religious side.

        As a side note though I completely agree with your view on them marrying. They obviously shouldn't be able to force a priest or anyone else to hold the ceremony. A few months ago I asked my gay friend what exactly a civil Union was, and he explained it was just like a marriage in all the legal sense. I then asked him why do many cared that it wasn't called by the same name as traditional marriage and he replied because it pisses off religious people. I was extremely annoyed by this answer. You can honestly call anything just about any word you want to, the only problem is no one will understand what you're talking about.
        Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
        • Posted by $ 13 years, 3 months ago
          At this point no one can say with certainty why people are homosexual. Honestly, I don't really think it matters. Being born into this world, every person has the right to exist. Being born into this country, every person has a right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. I've got enough on my plate (wife, kids, work, etc..) to worry about others AS LONG AS they aren't pushing themselves into my life, how I care to do things, and how I'm raising my family. When people do that they get both barrels (metaphorically).
          Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  

FORMATTING HELP

  • Comment hidden. Undo