Rough Men
"We sleep soundly in our beds because rough men stand ready in the night to visit violence on those who would do us harm" -- Winston Churchill
With the hatred of police, and police murders in the news I wonder how Gulchers feel about cops? I knw several and I found them to be exceedingly brave men, and dedicated to their jobs. But they are not usually mild-mannered Clark Kents. These are mostly men willing to confront and stand up to the bad guys, and being nice doesn't usually help. Sometimes they overstep their authority. But the bad cops in terms of those whose records are full of complaints are vastly in the minority. So...my fellow Gulchers, what is your take on the police. Haroes? Miscreants? Something in between?
With the hatred of police, and police murders in the news I wonder how Gulchers feel about cops? I knw several and I found them to be exceedingly brave men, and dedicated to their jobs. But they are not usually mild-mannered Clark Kents. These are mostly men willing to confront and stand up to the bad guys, and being nice doesn't usually help. Sometimes they overstep their authority. But the bad cops in terms of those whose records are full of complaints are vastly in the minority. So...my fellow Gulchers, what is your take on the police. Haroes? Miscreants? Something in between?
Previous comments... You are currently on page 3.
The cops of our age (mostly retired) didn't think of themselves as heroes, operators, and always facing combat. And most importantly, they knew what and how important good and respectable manners were, other than the 'few' that we seem to reference today. I was trying to remember the first arrest killing, other than Bonnie and Clyde, that I heard about growing up. Weren't many.
My "shouting" was specifically and only at the multitude of laws we have on the books, by the enforcement of which our government so often requires otherwise good men and women to violate the lives and property of their fellows - at home and abroad.
I am also former military, for what it is worth.
Do you take issue with either of the above
Van Horne, Patrick; Riley, Jason. Left of Bang: How the Marine Corps' Combat Hunter Program Can Save Your Life (p. 25). Black Irish Entertainment LLC. Kindle Edition. Following are some quotes from the 1st couple of chapters. It gets much worse as one goes through the rest. With this level of understanding of the training our police receive, one can begin to see how the relationships between our police and citizens has changed so drastically, from our old 'friends on the police force' to our 'combat police.' Combine these with such things as the 'War on Drugs' as an euphemism for War on Drug Users, and 'War on Terror' as an euphemism for 'War on Dissenters and Disobeyers' and one should see that our problem is not so much with the police, trained and incentivized to act as they do, as it is with the policymakers and politicians wanting a compliant population.
"The Combat Hunter program has proven again and again that it is. Marines and other members of the Armed Forces, law enforcement officers and other security personnel, and even the average person cannot wait for dangerous people to do bad things to them. Nor are contemporary environments of peril confined to foreign lands. The streets of Los Angeles, like the alleys of Kandahar, are complex and chaotic environments in which it is not always easy to tell the good guys from the bad guys. The military, law enforcement, security personnel, and even civilians can use the principles of Combat Hunter to identify the three types of people in any public arena— the “shepherds” (good guys), “sheep” (regular guys), and “wolves in sheep’s clothing” (bad guys)....
We’ve trained numerous people from outside of the military. When law enforcement agents go through our course, especially senior agents, they are consistently amazed that they were never taught these things before. Naturally, most of the senior agents tacitly know this stuff. They have years of practice of observing human behavior and, if pressed, could probably articulate most of this stuff in one way or another. However, these agents also say that what Combat Hunter, especially combat profiling, provides is a lifetime’s worth of experience in a few weeks. It gives Marines and law enforcement agents explicit knowledge that would have taken years to learn on the job. Now that I’ve been trained in the skills, have developed courses, and have trained other people, I believe that anyone who is concerned for their safety and the safety of others would do well to learn what we teach....
No police officer or security guard should have to go on patrol without knowing how to identify a criminal before he commits his crime. No person should have to wait until they see a gun to know that there is threat present....
. Warfighting Laboratory chose three experts to lead the development, expansion, and initial instruction of each of these specialties, the three pillars of Combat Hunter. Ivan Carter, a big-game hunter from Africa, developed the observation portion of Combat Hunter. He recognized the foundation of every hunter is the ability to see his prey. He influenced the development of classes to teach effective observation techniques and how to better use both day and night optics. David Scott Donelan, a former Rhodesian special forces operator, designed the combat tracking portion of Combat Hunter. Combat tracking teaches Marines how to read and understand the physical terrain and identify the physical evidence individuals leave behind as they move through an environment. This skill allows Marines to pursue an armed enemy while gathering information to determine their future actions and intent. Greg Williams, a former law enforcement officer, designed the combat profiling pillar of Combat Hunter. While combat tracking is focused on the physical terrain, profiling teaches Marines how to read the human terrain through an increased understanding of human behavior. This allows Marines to recognize the subtle aspects of human behavior to find the enemy hiding in plain clothes. The integration of these three skills and concepts into military operations, whether in an insurgency or in a full-scale war, creates a more intelligent warrior capable of out thinking and outmaneuvering an enemy who seeks to blend in with his environment."
Although the book is written, centered on Marine Corps training, it is noteworthy that the program was developed by civilians (some with less than heroic experience) and the authors note the extensive training given to civilian police dept's in the US and emphasis is placed on the concept of being Left of Bang., reacting before Bang. It's an eye opener when considered from the perspective of community policing in the US.
Like Reagan said that we are the last of freedom and if the USA falls, there is no other to take its place.
I love this country passionately. Like Teddy R. said, "There's more to see and nothing better to see than this country." But it has been mismanaged to the point where there are so many things that no longer work or reflect its original intent.
Compared to much of the world now and most of the history of humankind, IMHO, US is an amazing and wonderful place. If modern US is below par, where/when are the really great places?
Having fewer laws but consistently enforced would go a long way toward improving the things Ed75 mentions. Govt having its fingers in so many areas makes it easier for the average person to be criminal by accident. Good people develop informal systems to circumnavigate the law, and that leads to what Ed75 is talking about.
I agree there's no answer to get to utopia, but things could improve.
That number as a percentage held fairly even in all categories of crime.
I maintained then and now while the nowhere near wild figures posed in most media 1 percent is still unacceptable and some common statistical factors should be available.
Just off the top of my own, from experience, list is stress factors coupled with lack of sleep leads to making mistakes. One thing in an office figures can be corrected but another in the street where lives cannot be recovered as if a reset button was available.
Determining such factors and using them as a guide in settingdepartment policies on overtime, off duty time, mandatory vacation time and physicals should be an easy first step.
Second example. US Forest Service Smoke jumpers for a long time did not accept former paratroopers from the military. Because they training was engrained and the two types of jumping were entirely different. Might not that be the same between a 20 year veteran of infantry with 2-3 years combat time and a police officer. Or vice versa.
Again drawing on two professions in my own life.
Other and perhaps not so readily seen reasons probably exist and using stress levels did you know one of the stress causers is not only divorce but marriage, not only over work but badly planned vacations, even buying a house counts in the mix.
Add a number of those together causes extra or ultra stress levels;
But that aside as Cato poitned out ss than one percent of the general population are criminals and less than one percent of police the same.
http://www.policemisconduct.net/argui...
That may be scoffed here as mysticism but it is the truth.
Me dino am who I am and I come to the Gulch for other reasons.
In the case of driving, if the roads were private, the road owner could set the rules for obtaining the right to use those roads. The penalty for not adhering to the rules could be that you lost your ability to use those roads. As to fines, I am not keen on them because of the issue of who gets the money and who assesses the fines. conflict of interest.
In the case you cite, the criminal is the pimp.There are always extenuating circumstances. If a husband brutalizes a wife, should you make marriage illegal? I can assure you that happens more often than pimps beating prostitutes. You cannot cover all contingescies when determining what should be a law and what shouldn't be. However, our law books are stuffed full of unneeded laws and not just a few. Literally thousands of them.
Load more comments...