Why do Hanks hold on to Lillians?
Why do Hanks hold onto Lillians?
I have searched my entire life for my Hank, and have yet to find him. Well, at least not available. I do see Hanks around and they seem to always have a Lillian hanging on. Why? I see this as a contradiction. How can someone live a happy, fulfilling life with a contradiction like this? I will not compromise or sacrifice myself, and don't don't want anyone to compromise or sacrifice for me.
Lillian has no respect for Hank, his work or his business as demonstrated when he gives her a bracelet made from the 1st heat of his new metal, mockingly saying: “You mean,”...”it's fully as valuable as a piece of railroad rails?” She jingled the bracelet, making it sparkle under the light. “Henry it's perfectly wonderful! What originality! I shall be the sensation of New York, wearing jewelry made of the same stuff as bridge girders, truck motors, kitchen stoves, typewriters, and – what was it you were saying about it the other day, darling? - soup kettles?”
Lillian is not particularly interested in Hanks money, of course until she has none, but she is very interested in her position and image. Hank has no other value to her. She uses him as a pawn to gain position and pull as demonstrated when attending James Taggart's wedding.
Then there are family members.
Hank's mother: “The intention's plain selfishness, if you ask me,” said Reardens mother. “another man would bring a diamond bracelet, if he want to give his wife a present, because it's her pleasure he'd think of not his own. But Henry thinks that just because he's made a new kind of tin, why, it's got to be more precious than diamonds to everybody, just because it's he that's made it. That's the way he's been since he was five years old – the most conceited brat you ever saw – and I knew he'd grow up to be the most selfish creature on God's earth.”
Philip: “By the way, Henry,” Philip added, “do you mind if I ask you to have Miss Ives give me the money in cash?” …...”You see, Friends of Global Progress are a very progressive group and they have always maintained that you represent the blackest element of social retrogression in the country, so it would embarrass us, you know, to have your name on our list of contributors, because somebody might accuse us of being in the pay of Hank Rearden.”
Here is AR on Contradiction (From The Virtue of Selfishness): The Law of Identity (A is A) is a rational man’s paramount consideration in the process of determining his interests. He knows that the contradictory is the impossible, that a contradiction cannot be achieved in reality and that the attempt to achieve it can lead only to disaster and destruction. Therefore, he does not permit himself to hold contradictory values, to pursue contradictory goals, or to imagine that the pursuit of a contradiction can ever be to his interest.
Does your significant other respect and value you and your philosophy of life? If not, why are you still there?
I have searched my entire life for my Hank, and have yet to find him. Well, at least not available. I do see Hanks around and they seem to always have a Lillian hanging on. Why? I see this as a contradiction. How can someone live a happy, fulfilling life with a contradiction like this? I will not compromise or sacrifice myself, and don't don't want anyone to compromise or sacrifice for me.
Lillian has no respect for Hank, his work or his business as demonstrated when he gives her a bracelet made from the 1st heat of his new metal, mockingly saying: “You mean,”...”it's fully as valuable as a piece of railroad rails?” She jingled the bracelet, making it sparkle under the light. “Henry it's perfectly wonderful! What originality! I shall be the sensation of New York, wearing jewelry made of the same stuff as bridge girders, truck motors, kitchen stoves, typewriters, and – what was it you were saying about it the other day, darling? - soup kettles?”
Lillian is not particularly interested in Hanks money, of course until she has none, but she is very interested in her position and image. Hank has no other value to her. She uses him as a pawn to gain position and pull as demonstrated when attending James Taggart's wedding.
Then there are family members.
Hank's mother: “The intention's plain selfishness, if you ask me,” said Reardens mother. “another man would bring a diamond bracelet, if he want to give his wife a present, because it's her pleasure he'd think of not his own. But Henry thinks that just because he's made a new kind of tin, why, it's got to be more precious than diamonds to everybody, just because it's he that's made it. That's the way he's been since he was five years old – the most conceited brat you ever saw – and I knew he'd grow up to be the most selfish creature on God's earth.”
Philip: “By the way, Henry,” Philip added, “do you mind if I ask you to have Miss Ives give me the money in cash?” …...”You see, Friends of Global Progress are a very progressive group and they have always maintained that you represent the blackest element of social retrogression in the country, so it would embarrass us, you know, to have your name on our list of contributors, because somebody might accuse us of being in the pay of Hank Rearden.”
Here is AR on Contradiction (From The Virtue of Selfishness): The Law of Identity (A is A) is a rational man’s paramount consideration in the process of determining his interests. He knows that the contradictory is the impossible, that a contradiction cannot be achieved in reality and that the attempt to achieve it can lead only to disaster and destruction. Therefore, he does not permit himself to hold contradictory values, to pursue contradictory goals, or to imagine that the pursuit of a contradiction can ever be to his interest.
Does your significant other respect and value you and your philosophy of life? If not, why are you still there?
Previous comments... You are currently on page 3.
What she brought to the table earlier in the game, while he was still building his business, was her social networking abilities.
Also, imagine what his home and life would be like if running the household were up to him, while he was busy building his empire.
Bottom line: choose well and recognize that it isn't a one-time line of "I do", but the daily practice.
Yup. We're in it together. Going on eighteen years with the plan to never part.
To me, the key for a successful relationship is to #1 have a mutual goal, #2, realize that you aren't there yet, and #3 work together to get it. This is one of the reasons why Hollywood marriages (the butt of many jokes) never last - because they aren't in it for anything more than the photo shoot or the fleeting sex. The marriages which start on a foundation of communication, mutual respect, and long-term goals are the ones most likely to last simply because then the life-changing moments that come along don't necessarily derail us from our path. They become temporary exits or bumps in the road rather than termini.
Cheryl Brooks Taggart does develop, all right. But that development ends in death.
But you're right about the thoroughness of Hank Rearden's development.
I always figured Hank ended up marrying his secretary, Gwen Ives. She understood him almost as well as did Dagny.
But in literature, a hero either develops as a character or else changes his or her perspective in a striking way. A villain does neither of these. He looks at life with single-minded striving toward his goal. Nothing short of death or overwhelming defeat will stop him.
Well, if an anti-hero is a character who develops and ends up serving an evil cause, an anti-villain is a single-minded striver for a just cause.
A lot of 'learning' may start with imitation, but when the lessons are internalized and owned by the student, they're operating independently and on a higher level.
Which is ok with me. I've done that with more than a few 'lessons' in my life.
Including a second marriage; this time to a woman who's willing to support my dreams and goals and whose dreams and goals I'm willing to support, too.
And 'support' doesn't mean 'provide funding,' necessarily... sometimes just some encouragement and positive words will do.
Took me two tries to find her; took her three at-bats to find me. 24th anniversary was in July of this year. Big :)
I suppose Cheryl Brooks/Taggart develops too, but I don't count her as a main character.
I don't view Dagny's realization that she can't reach society as development, merely an acknowledgement that her more-skilled opponent (Galt) has won. They're like two great athletes playing tennis with the fate of America throughout the book. Galt keeps striking balls towards her that are harder and harder to return, until she realizes she's not going to win this game, but like the badass she is, go down fighting.
Also, it sounds like you and your wife had almost nine wonderful years together. Sorry it couldn't have been more.
How many of us have been there? Many in the Gulch I'm sure.
Load more comments...