WHY ???
Posted by upston 6 years, 9 months ago to Philosophy
What makes smart and outwardly normal people progressives , statists , sociologists, or worse Democrats ????
I understand the leadership who crave power and the low information voters but what about the others. I have family that are accomplished , educated, wealthy and total lefties. I have been struggling with this for 40 years. I have given away many copies of A S but to little affect, I argue, present facts, joke bitch but nothing gets through. Help me please.
I understand the leadership who crave power and the low information voters but what about the others. I have family that are accomplished , educated, wealthy and total lefties. I have been struggling with this for 40 years. I have given away many copies of A S but to little affect, I argue, present facts, joke bitch but nothing gets through. Help me please.
George Carlin — 'Never argue with an idiot. They will only bring you down to their level and beat you with experience.'
Respectfully,
OA
The next one?...Conscience, those that have and those that have not. The only true division in society...will take another year.
NYT's here I come...laughing
It happens to be my work and permeates my writings. My first book didn't go that deep but the next one, (in progress) will.
My journey started out to understand what we have missed during our life times and how history and knowledge in general has been confounded.
My only objective was to get it right...although many of my points can be observed, they can't be proven to be causation. Psychologist and some quantum physicist would agree but pure science would be hesitant. Much of that would be ideological un-intergrated programing. (they refuse to look at the observation).
My brother in law has a PhD in a highly technical area, and is a dyed-in-the-wool progressive. My discovery of his actual limited intellectual capacity came not from a political discussion, but from a technical one. He asked me about a space activity that he didn't understand, and I proceeded to make the link between what puzzled him and the general physics principles involved that connected to his area of expertise. To my shock, he said he never paid much attention to principles, so long as the numbers in his equations gave the right answer.
My conclusion from this exchange was that he, like many leftists, eagerly clings to what "sounds right" rather than what makes sense. He stopped having political discussions with me because he said my use of facts and logic was "unfair."
Recently on Fox News, they had a journalist questioning college students and then people on the street they seem completely oblivious to current events or spew socialist ideology.
Consciousness soars on the wings of metaphors is my summation of the works of Julian Jaynes. He points out that the left brain alone is amazing, the right brain is a phenomenal addition but...in the folks you describe they are disconnected...they may be Bicameral as opposed to unicameral which produces consciousness, a real conscience, identity and the ability to self introspect, not to mention integrate information into the form of wisdom.
You might try using metaphors they might be familiar with to describe reality as we know it in a non-(leftest)-offensive way.
Make it personal but not obvious so they can use their emotions to re-awaken a connection to their minds.
And also, not everyone wants to know the truth. Have you read Leonard Peikoff"s The Ominous Parallels? It is a sort of history of philosophy. It explains how bad philosophy fosters (if not originates) irrationality, causing the wrong epistemology, the wrong metaphysics (view of the earth), which causes evil politics.
Good for you. I taught my daughter similar things. It's parents job to prepare their children.
Lazy parents let the schools take over... And we see what happened.
If you want to change your relatives, then change social expectations. Not only will they probably switch, but they will also probably claim that 'this is what they thought all along'. Because the did: what they thought is what Society expected.
Jan
I think that she persisits in being a liberal because her job is now threatened by the reforms being made by President Trump. Her employer had mostly government contracts, which are now in jeopardy.
So she refuses to even talk to me any more about philosophical issues. I have to bite my tongue in order not to say anything to upset her, or the conversation is over.
Load more comments...