Carbon Dating Question
I'm highly skeptical when it comes to carbon dating. I'm hoping that some of the folks here can lessen or remove some of my skepticism.
My contention: Carbon dating is a measurement tool that has a flawed foundation and cannot be reliably counted on to accurately determine age.
Fact: All elements in existence come from stars, expelled at various stages in a stars death throes.
If the "birth" of elements being measured with carbon dating are unknown how can anyone determine half-life or set anything more than a best guess based on other equally flawed readings?
Even if we were to actually destroy an element in its entirety and conclusive establish its death, we still could not determine its half-life or its birth-date.
I know that there are scientists and science types here. What am I missing?
** this is not a faith or religious oriented discussion, lets not make it one.
My contention: Carbon dating is a measurement tool that has a flawed foundation and cannot be reliably counted on to accurately determine age.
Fact: All elements in existence come from stars, expelled at various stages in a stars death throes.
If the "birth" of elements being measured with carbon dating are unknown how can anyone determine half-life or set anything more than a best guess based on other equally flawed readings?
Even if we were to actually destroy an element in its entirety and conclusive establish its death, we still could not determine its half-life or its birth-date.
I know that there are scientists and science types here. What am I missing?
** this is not a faith or religious oriented discussion, lets not make it one.
Previous comments... You are currently on page 2.
I just like any new knowledge. I used to consider myself a nexialist: "here is the formal definition, coined by science fiction author A. E. Van Vogt. Nexialist: One skilled in the science of joining together in an orderly fashion the knowledge of one field of learning with that of other fields." The nexialist character in one of his novels would find causes of deep mysteries in the star travel novels. Trouble was that they had an A is not-A flavor from general semantics.
Jan
(Mal'ta is in Siberia; not the Malta in the Med.)
Jan
Jan, wallowing
I can foresee much turmoil in the next 4 years with the inflated currency and regulations under a Hillary administration that will just make it very difficult for older folks like me to survive.
Very interesting.
enjoy
http://www.theepochtimes.com/n3/10218...
I sure would like to see that reference to the planets. All planet, including Earth's, rotational rates change for various reasons, such as mass distribution, arrangement of other system bodies, and even being clobbered by large masses.
That grand solar minimum possibility is at present an educated guess by some solar scientists.
Example: a tribe of Indians would not release a skull to archeologists for examination. The feared - correctly - that when the archeologists did genetic testing on the bones they would determine that the Indians were not the 'original settlers' of their land, but had replaced an earlier group of different genetic heritage. This impacts the sense that we 'owe' American Indians for the land we took from them by force...the truth turns out to be that the current Indians occupying the land took it from someone else by force as well.
So, if you are looking only at a practical use for such knowledge, knowing these things can effect our modern lives. Aside from that, though, intellectual pursuits are worthwhile for their own sake.
Jan
And this subject isn't nonsense. You'll make yourself crazy focusing on whats happening to and in this country today.
So the the middle of a 100,000 year glaciation which was one of the longer series glaciations which followed the series of 40,000 year glaciations which may give evidence for more such glaciations is not important enough to study? That last glaciation was responsible for the demise of the Neanderthal and the large mammals like the mastodon, etc.
http://www.coolmath.com/algebra/17-ex...
Yes there is use for high school algebra. Just plug in what you know and solve for what you want. Financial calculations use somewhat similar methods, especially in continuously accrued interest calculations.
Like rings on a tree, earth ice core samples have layers and rings that can actually be counted. Based on the counting of rings. "And the counting shall be three, not two...not one....but three...", could not help that, but counting them can take you back hundreds of thousands of years.
Based on physical counting of layers, and the empirical measurements of frozen compounds, they can determine temperatures. Tthe APICA graphs http://www.daviesand.com/Choices/Prec... , generated by such core samples proves out eath goes through 100,000 cooling and warming cycles, and today we are on the peak of one of those cooling cycles.
Knowing with reasonable certainty some things dating back hundreds of thousands of years can, if applied help us understand what to expect in the future.
Load more comments...