Right... banning alcohol didn't work... in part because people instinctively didn't like a federal government interfering in well-established... well... established... cultural mores.
So, honestly and openly making alcohol illegal didn't work... but brainwashing the public against tobacco over the course of 50 years *did* work.
Okay, you can't have it both ways. If minimal regulation of drugs made things "ok"... then why not minimal regulation on business? Minimal regulation on healthcare? Glad to see you're on board for minimal government; welcome to the Tea Party.
Prior to the 20th century, you didn't have the plethora of drugs out there, and you didn't have a culture that celebrated drug use. Alcohol was "regulated" by culture. You like to ignore that back in the day, drunks were spit on as being of low character, or laughed at as being jokes, they were not pampered as being victims of a "disease".
Hey, I might actually favor the legalization of drugs... if the culture allowed us to persecute drug users. If, when I saw some pink-eyed, slack-jawed moron stinking of marijuana staggering down the frozen aisles debating between grabbing a burrito or a burrito, I were allowed to grab him by the collar and seat of his pants, frog-march him through the unopened doors of the store, and toss him into the parking lot in front of oncoming traffic, I might consider supporting legalization. But, until we're culturally allowed as individuals to persecute recreational drug users, at least to the degree we persecute tobacco users, I won't favor its legalization.
I agree with you completely-- point out the specific claims. Attack the ideas, not the person.
I don't agree with Maph on racial issues, but I like hearing the other perspectives. Sometimes it sounds like Maph's failing to explain, but I always try to stay open to the idea I might be missing something.
I say "paint into a corner" because we have this argument regularly. Different individuals try to approach a particular argument different ways only for Maph to deflect, obfuscate and plain ignore. Eventually people get frustrated and down vote. Oh-and not to mention the fact he's called a few people racist who are respected producers on this site. I personally do not find it productive to down vote reasonable comments or posts. What would be the point? and it doesn't further the mission of the site. I am outspoken about this when I see it occurring.
There are two elements to this: a) collectivist and b) non-reasoning. You can mix and match them. In other words you can have valid collectivist reasoning if you start from axioms I reject.
I don't know what to do with true non-reasoning. I just try to point out the fallacy, and if the other person doesn't accept it as a logical error there's nowhere to go from there.
I think of collectivist as meaning you should do things only for the sake of others, even things you don't want, because that makes you a good person. I obviously reject that for all the reasons from AS and Fountainhead.
If we must adopt a package of opinions about unrelated issues, though, this seems like a form of collectivism. When you say paint into a corner it almost sounds like that. There are ideas on policing, taxation, strict interpretation of the Bill of Rights and Constitution, gov't social programs, maintaining/using a standing army, etc. You don't use reason, the theory goes, to develop your own ideas but rather you pick a package of ideas set up by your in-group. The in-group positions are based on reason, the out-group ones are based on evil.
I think you may be talking about the reason or axioms, not this in-group/out-group thing I described. If you know someone starts from different axioms or consistently fails to use good reason, you're prejudiced for good reason and suspect what they're saying probably won't be meaningful to you.
Maph says very rational things. Then he reverts to his emotions on others. Prog is the word I use for progressive. This site tolerates very little collectivist non-reasoning
I hear what you're saying. If we decriminalize drugs JUST to eliminate cartels, we're letting criminals dictate policy. But as you point out later, there are other valid reasons to decriminalize.
Drug prohibition attempts to keep willing producers from producing and distributing a product to willing customers.
I think with tobacco some people to stay addicted so there can be tax revenue and anti-smoking campaigns but they don't want things like vaping that have almost no secondhand smoke and possibly less risk to the user. They want it to stay dangerous and addictive but still have some people do it. That's messed up.
There's no evil gov't official planning all this. There are just gov'ts that depend on the tax revenue and non-profits that depend on smoking being dangerous but still happening.
I was just a lowly 1Lt maintenance officer for the D model Bufs and the KCs at U Tapao Royal Thai Naval Airfield, next to Pattaya and Sattahip, '72-3, including the Christmas flights to Hanoi ... welcome home to you, sir, and congratulations for surviving!!! -- j
Maph: It may have something to do with including such comments as the following: "without having to engage in white nationalist bans on immigration or resort to extreme totalitarian police state measures like border control and racial profiling"
Your message on the positives of drug legalization and the negatives of prohibition kind of got buried.
I would agree with you, with the additional caveat that I never have to have anyone "high" on drugs around me... put 'em in a leper colony. (Not fair to the lepers; they couldn't help catching the disease...)
Letting drug addicts hobble around me sooner or later is going to violate the hell out of their rights, when I get fed up with it and decide to let the taxpayers feed and house me for the rest of my life in a 6 x 12 cell.
If one wants to blow one's mind out on drugs, stop wasting time, space and other people's resources and put a gun barrel in one's mouth and blow one's brains out directly.
We do still have moonshiners. It says something about our current culture that we actually have a reality show dedicated to them that airs... that airs for more than one episode (after which you'd think the cops would have shut them down...)
That's very astute. I hadn't thought of likening the sanctuaries of Cambodia and Laos to Mexico, but it IS effectively the same. I remember while the traitors in the U.S. whined every time we tried to "expand the war" into areas the enemy was using for sanctuary.
The Viet Cong and NVA never referred to it as the Vietnam War, but as the Indochinese War...
Treat them just like Osama Bin Laden. That is who they are, terrorists. I'm ok with legalizing drugs, as long as I don't ever have to pay for someone else's bad decisions.
It's not working because we're not fighting it. The war on tobacco worked. Use those tactics on drugs and it'll work on them, as well... except the progressives will never... ever... let that happen.
They WANT a society of lotus eaters with their minds blown out on borloi all the time.
That's not the media; that was the government during the Reagan/Bush administrations.
Why is it you and Maph can't distinguish between inept government propaganda, and the horrifyingly effective propaganda spewed out by hollyweird every second of every day?
Wow, one half-arsed commercial over what... 40 years? Did it show somebody being a bad person, a fool, whom all right-thinking people belittle and ostracize, like they did with tobacco? Did they hyperbolize and exaggerate, and blame every ill of the world on drugs, like they did tobacco? No, of course not.
I especially liked the part at the end of the video portion where they broadly suggested that it might be American anti immigration activists. Yes those nasty anti immigration activist....no doubt it is them...They are so evil wanting border controls and all!!! Those nice cartel guys would never really do something like that after all they are all downtrodden minorities' seeking a better life. Those anti immigration people are likely gun toting 6 fingered cousin marrying NRA/Tea party members. The real threat to America! The same people who showed up at the Bundy ranch that the Senate Majority leader pointed out as domestic terrorists.
Right... banning alcohol didn't work... in part because people instinctively didn't like a federal government interfering in well-established... well... established... cultural mores.
So, honestly and openly making alcohol illegal didn't work... but brainwashing the public against tobacco over the course of 50 years *did* work.
Okay, you can't have it both ways. If minimal regulation of drugs made things "ok"... then why not minimal regulation on business? Minimal regulation on healthcare? Glad to see you're on board for minimal government; welcome to the Tea Party.
Prior to the 20th century, you didn't have the plethora of drugs out there, and you didn't have a culture that celebrated drug use. Alcohol was "regulated" by culture. You like to ignore that back in the day, drunks were spit on as being of low character, or laughed at as being jokes, they were not pampered as being victims of a "disease".
Hey, I might actually favor the legalization of drugs... if the culture allowed us to persecute drug users. If, when I saw some pink-eyed, slack-jawed moron stinking of marijuana staggering down the frozen aisles debating between grabbing a burrito or a burrito, I were allowed to grab him by the collar and seat of his pants, frog-march him through the unopened doors of the store, and toss him into the parking lot in front of oncoming traffic, I might consider supporting legalization. But, until we're culturally allowed as individuals to persecute recreational drug users, at least to the degree we persecute tobacco users, I won't favor its legalization.
I don't agree with Maph on racial issues, but I like hearing the other perspectives. Sometimes it sounds like Maph's failing to explain, but I always try to stay open to the idea I might be missing something.
I personally do not find it productive to down vote reasonable comments or posts. What would be the point? and it doesn't further the mission of the site. I am outspoken about this when I see it occurring.
I don't know what to do with true non-reasoning. I just try to point out the fallacy, and if the other person doesn't accept it as a logical error there's nowhere to go from there.
I think of collectivist as meaning you should do things only for the sake of others, even things you don't want, because that makes you a good person. I obviously reject that for all the reasons from AS and Fountainhead.
If we must adopt a package of opinions about unrelated issues, though, this seems like a form of collectivism. When you say paint into a corner it almost sounds like that. There are ideas on policing, taxation, strict interpretation of the Bill of Rights and Constitution, gov't social programs, maintaining/using a standing army, etc. You don't use reason, the theory goes, to develop your own ideas but rather you pick a package of ideas set up by your in-group. The in-group positions are based on reason, the out-group ones are based on evil.
I think you may be talking about the reason or axioms, not this in-group/out-group thing I described. If you know someone starts from different axioms or consistently fails to use good reason, you're prejudiced for good reason and suspect what they're saying probably won't be meaningful to you.
Drug prohibition attempts to keep willing producers from producing and distributing a product to willing customers.
There's no evil gov't official planning all this. There are just gov'ts that depend on the tax revenue and non-profits that depend on smoking being dangerous but still happening.
This might be the future for marijuana.
Your message on the positives of drug legalization and the negatives of prohibition kind of got buried.
(Not fair to the lepers; they couldn't help catching the disease...)
If one wants to blow one's mind out on drugs, stop wasting time, space and other people's resources and put a gun barrel in one's mouth and blow one's brains out directly.
The Viet Cong and NVA never referred to it as the Vietnam War, but as the Indochinese War...
I'm ok with legalizing drugs, as long as I don't ever have to pay for someone else's bad decisions.
They WANT a society of lotus eaters with their minds blown out on borloi all the time.
Why is it you and Maph can't distinguish between inept government propaganda, and the horrifyingly effective propaganda spewed out by hollyweird every second of every day?
Wow, one half-arsed commercial over what... 40 years? Did it show somebody being a bad person, a fool, whom all right-thinking people belittle and ostracize, like they did with tobacco? Did they hyperbolize and exaggerate, and blame every ill of the world on drugs, like they did tobacco? No, of course not.
Load more comments...