Why do humans have to be owned?
Posted by j_IR1776wg 9 years, 9 months ago to Philosophy
A recurring post here in the Gulch for the past several years asks whether the government owns you of if you own you.
Why do humans have to be owned at all?
My whole life I've been told that:
1) god own me.
2) my parents own me.
3) government owns me.
4) I own me.
But I've never read any proof or justification of why exactly is ownership of humans necessary?
In logic, the offering of a limited number of choices as if they were the only choices is a fallacy known as bifurcation. Is this what we are being offered?
Is ownership of humans necessary?
Why do humans have to be owned at all?
My whole life I've been told that:
1) god own me.
2) my parents own me.
3) government owns me.
4) I own me.
But I've never read any proof or justification of why exactly is ownership of humans necessary?
In logic, the offering of a limited number of choices as if they were the only choices is a fallacy known as bifurcation. Is this what we are being offered?
Is ownership of humans necessary?
Previous comments... You are currently on page 3.
http://www.conservapedia.com/Dagny_Ta...
Was she being immoral for not wanting to be a slave driver?
Also the Great And Powerful O on top of his bloated Candy Mountain.
Emperors are always the rulers on top of even kings Such was Imperial Germany before The Great War (To--giggle--End All Wars).
The Kaiser also had a phone to go with his pen, even back then.
b. No
c. Maybe
d. Opinions vary
e. I plead the Fifth
f. All of the above
* https://facebook.com/piphd/videos/vb....
https://libertarianalliance.wordpress...
http://www.lawsociety.bc.ca/page.cfm?...
http://www.openureyes.org.nz/blog/?q=...
However, I don't endorse "Free Man On The Land" tactics. I've seen a lot of people end up in horrible deep trouble from it.
What I was referring to was the tendency of students, as they rise higher in the ranks of the educated, to lean ever further to the left, fueled by "smarter, better than you" delusions. I personally witnessed this recently while speaking at length to peers of my son, who just earned a science PhD at age 25.
Jan
Any of these statements evidences a type of person I could get along with, though the lastmentioned is pretty far from my personal stance.
I guess what I am saying is that how someone phrases lack of ownership is less important than that they behave as if they are not owned.
Jan
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Committ...
Also the slaves were not to be treated badly...
It seems to me these people arguing that it is not possible to own oneself are sophists attempting to reap a living from nonsensical, inflammatory or bizarre assertions.
It is amazing to me that it keeps coming up.
Load more comments...