Pixar's "Inside Out": Not for children and not for anyone who values reason

Posted by cranedragon 8 years, 8 months ago to Movies
1 comments | Share | Best of... | Flag

As someone who enjoys animation movies immensely, I found myself disappointed and then enraged by "Inside Out". Although marketed as a children's movie, there is little for children to understand, much less enjoy -- scary clowns, imaginary friends sacrificing themselves and allowing the memories of themselves to vanish, long stretches about things moving into long term memory -- really? But then I started reflecting on what the movie was communicating and I found it very disturbing. The story, for those of you fortunate enough to have missed it so far, is that only child Riley and her parents, so happy living in Minnesota, are at first miserable when the father's job forces a move to San Francisco.

Children are being told that their lives are controlled by their emotions, and the emotions are portrayed as a disorganized group, constantly jostling for the opportunity to color the event of the moment.

Emotions just happen and there is no order to which one of them is dominant at any time.

Reason has no place in this world, and the concept of self-esteem is completely missing. Similarly, there is no mention of work or achievement except as a barrier to happiness. The father's job, which causes the move from Minnesota to San Francisco, is a burden, and when he is called out early to a meeting with investors, it is taken as proof that he doesn't love his daughter.

"Emotions" cause the girl to fumble a pass in ice hockey and as a result she gives up on her try-out. Persistence, resilience, effort -- all missing, as well as the self-respect of doing one's best even in new or difficult situations.

The father's dominant emotion is anger, and the mother's dominant emotion is sadness [enlivened by random memories of a Brazilian pilot].

Abstract thought is dangerous and must be avoided. To escape from abstract thought, the emotions fall on their face and crawl out of the abstract realm.

Pixar has done so many clever things [Barbie torturing Ken by threatening to destroy a Nehru jacket? priceless; the determined little clown fish with the deformed fin in Finding Nemo; "no capes!" from The Incredibles; Ratatouille, end to end] that it is disappointing to see their brand on such an anti-child, anti-mind screed, even with 3-D and glorious color.


Add Comment

FORMATTING HELP

All Comments Hide marked as read Mark all as read

  • Posted by Winston_Smith1 8 years, 8 months ago
    The examples you point to are, sadly, only the tip of the iceberg. For the first time in history, though man has easy access to almost unlimited information, though the average Joe has never been dumber and less curious. I met some young couples and families recently and during one conversation I realized they had no idea what I was talking about. They seem to have no curiosity, no general knowledge of history or politics and few social graces. And their children cause the hair to stand on the back of my neck: all reaction, no indication of thought and no empathy. Sociopaths in the making, truly.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  

FORMATTING HELP

  • Comment hidden. Undo