Interesting discussion with my son I thought to share.
I went to the movies yesterday to see Lone Surivor, a story based on the true life experience of Navy Seal Marcus Luttrell in Afghanistan. This movie provoked a very relvant discussion between myself and my libertarian-minded son which has left the matter even more conveluted in my mind that what I knew it had to be. This said, I bring this topic here.
I use the below Franklin quote, "Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety," as a standard to size-up quite a few things our government attempts to do. Like almost all here, I greedily value myself, my time, my ingenuity and the dividends that my ingenuity offers over all things. I loath the government reaching its hand into my life to take whats mine to suit its own bloated excessive appetite and wasteful nature. I cringe knowing that there is a slipknot around our necks and that eventually my outspoken defiance of this totalitarian thugocrasy will eventually lead to my demise and/or create hardshop for those I love. Now that the tone is set, I'll present the slippery slope:
Islam in America.
The nature of Islam is that Allah is the provider of all things good and bad. The Quran and the law it provides ALL lslamic people everywhere with religious doctrine, governing doctrine, social doctrine and civil law. Unlike Christianity, Islamic people place their faith over whatever the national law of whatever country they are living in: including the United States. The kettle of the Islamic religion reliablely foments suicide bombers (children, women, the elderly, the mentally disturbed wearning bomb belts to earn a place for the family in islamic heaven), bold self-sacrificing murderers (honor killings in US citiies) and public murders - like Theo Van Gogh), and militants bent on toppling any opposition to their beliefs.
I contend, much to the chagrin of my son, and I do realize that its fantasy at this point, that neither Islamic people nor their "religion" has any place in the United States. Further, due to the nature of the "racical" element we should be racially and religiously profiling, we should be looking into emails of those we suspect, monitoring their religious services (since they seem to be the incubator for hatred against the US and advocating/encouraging violence toward the US) and listening to their conversations.
My son, in his own words, rightly reminded me of the quote, "In Germany, they first came for the gypsies, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a gypsy. Then they came for the Bolsheviks, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Bolshevik. Then they came for the Jews, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Jew. Then they came for the trade unionists and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a trade unionist. Then they came for the Catholics. I didn't speak up then because I was a Protestant. Then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak up." - Martin Niemoller, A Lutheran Pastor arrested by the Gestapo in 1937.
Yes, as I told him, I do understand that is the trampling of the Bill of Rights as it relates to this segment of the population. Yet, I do not see another way to defend our homes from this alien mentality that is lurking in places among us. We are too wide-open, too free-moving, and too-carefree within our own borders - and I wouldn't have it any other way - to trust that those we are letting in are here to assimilate into our culture and not cause us harm.
Slippery slope.
I use the below Franklin quote, "Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety," as a standard to size-up quite a few things our government attempts to do. Like almost all here, I greedily value myself, my time, my ingenuity and the dividends that my ingenuity offers over all things. I loath the government reaching its hand into my life to take whats mine to suit its own bloated excessive appetite and wasteful nature. I cringe knowing that there is a slipknot around our necks and that eventually my outspoken defiance of this totalitarian thugocrasy will eventually lead to my demise and/or create hardshop for those I love. Now that the tone is set, I'll present the slippery slope:
Islam in America.
The nature of Islam is that Allah is the provider of all things good and bad. The Quran and the law it provides ALL lslamic people everywhere with religious doctrine, governing doctrine, social doctrine and civil law. Unlike Christianity, Islamic people place their faith over whatever the national law of whatever country they are living in: including the United States. The kettle of the Islamic religion reliablely foments suicide bombers (children, women, the elderly, the mentally disturbed wearning bomb belts to earn a place for the family in islamic heaven), bold self-sacrificing murderers (honor killings in US citiies) and public murders - like Theo Van Gogh), and militants bent on toppling any opposition to their beliefs.
I contend, much to the chagrin of my son, and I do realize that its fantasy at this point, that neither Islamic people nor their "religion" has any place in the United States. Further, due to the nature of the "racical" element we should be racially and religiously profiling, we should be looking into emails of those we suspect, monitoring their religious services (since they seem to be the incubator for hatred against the US and advocating/encouraging violence toward the US) and listening to their conversations.
My son, in his own words, rightly reminded me of the quote, "In Germany, they first came for the gypsies, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a gypsy. Then they came for the Bolsheviks, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Bolshevik. Then they came for the Jews, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Jew. Then they came for the trade unionists and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a trade unionist. Then they came for the Catholics. I didn't speak up then because I was a Protestant. Then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak up." - Martin Niemoller, A Lutheran Pastor arrested by the Gestapo in 1937.
Yes, as I told him, I do understand that is the trampling of the Bill of Rights as it relates to this segment of the population. Yet, I do not see another way to defend our homes from this alien mentality that is lurking in places among us. We are too wide-open, too free-moving, and too-carefree within our own borders - and I wouldn't have it any other way - to trust that those we are letting in are here to assimilate into our culture and not cause us harm.
Slippery slope.
this is a good topic and conversation. Also, I am agreeing with cg completely.
I am learning more and more about Islam and am starting to publicly condemn the religion as anti-freedom and anti individual rights and pro violence.
"Yet, I do not see another way to defend our homes from this alien mentality that is lurking in places among us. We are too wide-open, too free-moving, and too-carefree within our own borders - and I wouldn't have it any other way - to trust that those we are letting in are here to assimilate into our culture and not cause us harm. "
Why advocate this solution and ignore ending the welfare state? the welfare state is what allows these pockets of terrorists to thrive on our soil. the Islamist who must make his own way in our country will likely see the benefits of capitalism and pursue that moral trade than the destruction of human life, no?
I do think about the atrocities in the name of Catholicism that were committed in the country I live in in the 1700s. Genocide for non-believers and non-cooperators.
It's what turned me to Christianity. It's the only religion I know of that says the creator of all things loves His creation; as a would-be creator, I can relate to that.
An Obama executive order should cover it </snark>
I'd favor an amendment declaring Islam a philosophy, not a religion. Whether it's true or not... don't care.
" Is not speaking out, as morally reprehensible as that is, qualify them to be banned from their own country?"
Yes. Being Moslem is reason enough to be banned. Unlike being gay (/snark), you really do CHOOSE to be Moslem.
natural rights? Natural rights allow for self defense.
a) True Islam is as vile as you paint it. Innocent people will die if the true believer practices this religion.
b) Islam in the USA has, I think, varying levels of 'commitment to the cause'. The zealot would say they're practicing 'watered down' Islam and might kill them if they were in the Middle East. I personally knew someone who considered himself Muslim that was happy to be in the USA because he got away from the radical nutjobs in Egypt and Kuwait.
If we have cause to investigate an individual or an organization based on some suspected "conspiracy to commit a crime", we definitely should do it because of (A). I don't think merely wearing the label Muslim is enough cause because of (B).
Check out this link, and particularly the section titled "Religious freedom". Our founders debated religious freedom, aware of what Islam was (at that time, anyway).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_th...
I think if we hold true to our values, we're going to get sucker-punched now and then. I don't think there's any way to avoid that and keep true to our values.
Survival > values.
Most people who die in the wilderness die because they will not do what they have to do to survive. I heard that on one of those nature/survivalist shows. This makes me think of that.
I think this issue is a lot like the right to bear arms. We let anyone go buy a gun and we consider it a violation of rights if the government were to spy on firearm-owning individuals with the rationale that they might go shooting people with them one day. Even if that individual were, say, a member of some neo-nazi group, I think we have to accept the risk that freedom carries. Otherwise we grant the government the power to turn totalitarian to preserve itself.
We could exercise the war on tobacco, only this time targeting Islam. That should work every effectively.
" I personally knew someone who considered himself Muslim that was happy to be in the USA because he got away from the radical nutjobs in Egypt and Kuwait."
So he's okay with being around the radical nutjobs, it's just a bonus on top of making money off of America... I got it...
You're going to have to clarify how the "war on tobacco" tactics would be effective against Islam. You mean like passing laws saying "No Islam can be practiced in a public building?" Or onerously taxing people that practice Islam? The war on tobacco strikes me more as a hypocritical revenue generation policy rather than a serious effort to rid the country of tobacco. I'm not connecting the dots about how these tactics would do any good against Islam, given how tobacco is still quite available.
I'd much rather prevent he importation of muslims for 10 to 20 years. This would allow those in this country to assimilate. I'd also deny Al Jezerra a license to operate in the US, its hate TV.
There's always a temptation to do that. If there weren't we wouldn't need a Bill of Rights. It's there for times when someone shoots up a school, and people feel the need to do *something* in response.
Regarding theistic religion, as an atheist I always struggle to understand disagreements between religions. I try not to be offensive, but it always comes off as you're arguing whose imaginary friend is the best. Since we cannot scientifically verify communications with god(s), this seems pointless. If we go by the actual religious texts and formally accepted exegesis, religion looks even worse. Even if one religion has more extremists than the other, wouldn't it make sense to oppose the extremism itself rather than the religion that has a higher rate of extremism?
My church (UU) draws from many sources including the Judeo / Christian / Islamic tradition, so we should be on the list to be watched. We had people like Thomas Jefferson who actually engaged in overthrowing a gov't. (Well, he said in a letter he _would_ be a member if there were a Unitarian congregation nearby, so we adopt him.) I would not be at all surprised the FBI a recent file on us.
We really should leave people alone until they break a law.
Christianity is a religion. Islam is a religion. Therefore, Christianity equals Islam.
Except it doesn't. Let's try this one:
Socialism is a philosophy; capitalism is a philosophy. Therefore, socialism equals capitalism.
How can you have a church and be an atheist?
Ask the boys serving on the front lines how they feel about having to give up some of their freedom in order to save it.
Like it or not, America has a culture and a philosophical tradition, one that stems from our anglo-saxon origins. There are cultures and philosophies which are entirely incompatible with it, philosophies and cultures which either have decayed into rot, or always been rotten.
If you can't see the blinding difference between "fear God!" and "God loves you"... go be an atheist in a Moslem country awhile.
You can find a congregation at uua.org. We have sermons on the sources that inform modern society, but we don't ask anyone to pretend they believe in the supernatural. Some people are deists and some people probably believe in supernatural elements of religion, but that's not what UU services are about. We don't tell anyone what to believe b/c people are going to believe what their mind tells them is true. We can't make them.
I've lived my life supporting an defending the Constitution. I do not seek to dilute it in any way. As I said, I just can't see how you can defend against this kind of mentality we're allowed to develop within our borders.
No number of laws on the books can prevent people from doing that which they intend to do, to the point of death.
How to prevent what they do? You have to give them the Truth, but since no one in this forum believes in ultimate Truth outside themselves, then no answers will be found here.
Millions of people have perished due to your "Truth" in the past. Which truth then? The truth of natural rights is far more consistent than Christianity has been.
Your "natural rights" is the only philosophy I know of that has *succeeded* in genocide.
We don't have limits because of evolutionary and restrictive processes we have simply yet to overcome, but by the fact that God has limited us to what is essential to respond to Him or not.
Please give me the address of any universes you've created lately?
Oh, btw... if you created your own universe, how come you're slumming here?
I don't have a problem with that - and don't see it as a violation of the 4th amendment, as these groups, as you rightly point out, have shown a tendency to perform these atrocities.
It's costly and time consuming, and some will be discovered and pay the price for what will be deemed "treachery", but that is the price we must pay as an open and free society.
Just my humble opinion.
It really disturbs me that Shadows Live Under Seashells has manifest itself so quickly in reality. Is it inevitable? I hope not. But I do think that things are going to get much worse before they get better (if they can get better). And yes, I too can see that what I'm proposing could easily be a stepping stone toward that kind of environment. I'm just not sure its preventable.
One father's day my brother's wife picked a fight with my mother.
The cow was about twice the size of my mother, who was tiny, but all Irish. In the course of the argument, which rambled out front, finally, the cow struck my mother. I didn't see this, and only learned of it days later; which is why the cow's alive today. When my mother went to strike her back, the cow grabbed up her two-year old child and hid behind her "motherhood".
THIS is the tactic of the enemy, be it collectivist, like she, or Islamic. Harm us, but whenever we attempt to retaliate, hide behind our mores and our laws, playing the victim, waiting to strike again.
When you can point to the Moslem who signed the Declaration of Independence and/or the Constitution, I'll reconsider my position with regards to Islam.
- Prince of Sparta, Pournelle &amp; Stirling
The issue would have been very very simple and easy for the pre-WWII generations to figure out. But, not you intellectually superior moderns, oh no. You've become like Kritias, loose of the bonds of dogma and custom that braced this nation on its climb to greatness, and you're lost when that bracing crumbles under the twin onslaught of socialism and Islam.
"Well, that's right, and if that's what you're waiting for, you'll never get it," Whitlock said. "Son, a long time ago a man named Burke said that for evil to win
all that's got to happen is that good men do nothin'. That's happening here. You're in a war, and you got to fight it like a war."
"And if we get like the enemy what's the point of winning?"
"That's what King David's always sayin'," Whitlock said. "Your father, too, sometimes, not so much now. Lysander, let me tell you something, you couldn't in a
million years be like them even if you was to work at it."
Whitlock studied papers on his desk for a moment- "You better think about it. I'll go on plannin' the politics for you, and Pete Owensford will go on fightin' the enemy for you, good men will go on dyin' for you, and hell, it may be enough. Prince Lysander, it just may be enough, and maybe you got a point. You've got a decent government, and Lord knows I'd hate to see it turn mean, but you better think. Your Highness. Just how many of your people are you willing to see killed
just so Citizen Dion Croser can have his legal rights?""
- "Prince of Sparta", Pournelle & Stirling