Atlas Stands (Movie review)

Posted by Solver 11 years, 7 months ago to Movies
8 comments | Share | Flag

"Good news and bad news about the movie Atlas Shrugged II. The bad news first. Samantha Mathis is, alas, nowhere near as good a Dagny Taggart as Taylor Schilling was in part one of the movie saga. Mathis tries hard, but she just doesn’t come off as tough enough, as angular enough, as enough of a force of nature, as Dagny needs to be. Schilling, in the first flick, got it pretty darn well, although she wasn’t perfect. Jason Beghe is okay in the new one as Hank Rearden, although not quite as good as the very, very good Grant Bowler in the first one. And so on down the line, with all the actors in the second not quite living up to (or badly failing to live up to in a few cases) what were surprisingly decent performances in the first, and with the plot not moving anywhere near as insistently or smartly as the plot in the first. (One note: While the actor playing the evil Wesley Mouch in the second doesn’t quite fit the book’s version of Mouch the way the first actor did, he DOES add a useful dimension: Take away the gray, and he has looks remarkably similar to Tom Perez, the dishonesty and ill-motivated head of the civil rights division in the corrupt Obama/Holder Justice Department. He also is believable a bad, bad dude. It’s sort of creepy.)
..."

http://cfif.org/v/freedom_line_blog/1617...


All Comments

  • Posted by itisntluck 11 years, 7 months ago
    The author of this article is ignorant. Rand didn't reject philanthropy, she rejected the idea that charity is a moral duty and a primary virtue.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by freedomforall 11 years, 7 months ago in reply to this comment.
    Many years ago, i thought I would be a good Rearden, having many philosphical things in common, but then I realized I'd have never put up with Lillian.;^)

    I liked Grant Bowler well enough in AS I. I look forward to seeing Jason Beghe in AS II when it comes to the Antipodes.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ jmlesniewski 11 years, 7 months ago
    Jason Beghe is a far superior Hank Rearden. Hank is a self-made man who started from nothing and worked his way up. He'd be gruff and tough, not refined and poised.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by freedomforall 11 years, 7 months ago
    Finally a review that actually does what a review is intended to do; Answer the question "Is it worth seeing?" Specifically: "while the movie isn’t a thrill a minute, it does definitely hold one’s interest and does definitely provide decent entertainment value. Indeed, my wife and I both found it more entertaining, more worth seeing, than the vast majority of what Hollywood turns out these days."
    Reply | Permalink  

  • Comment hidden. Undo