Face to face with Common Core-Part II
Posted by Non_mooching_artist 10 years, 7 months ago to Education
Dear Representative -----
I am writing to you out of deep concern regarding the Common Core curriculum, specifically related to math that is being taught in my daughter's school.
At the parent/teacher conference I had with my daughter's 8th grade math teacher, he expressed to me the dismay he feels about something that he was being compelled to teach to prepare his students for an upcoming test this Friday, April 4, 2014. He said he is required to teach them about baseball, and the parts of a stadium, and positions. I asked if it was about the geometry of a baseball diamond, or statistics. He answered, no, that it was only about the elements of the stadium and positions. I asked him if this was Common Core curriculum, to which he answered yes, and then further said he was not allowed to discuss it. My head nearly spun! This is my daughter's education, he is her teacher, and as a parent, I want to know what is being taught in my daughter's classrooms.
Today, I have had the chance to ask my daughter about her math class, to follow up on what she was going to learn. The following is some of what she was "taught" in her math class today;
1. They had to learn what each section of seats is called, such as bleachers and box seats.
2. The bases, and then two photographs were presented of home plate, shown from above and then from the side. They had to identify if this was the same place on the field or not.
3. They had to learn each of the positions of the players, and the name of the part of the field their position is in.
4. On more than one question, the students were "led" to answer a certain way. One of the questions was, "What makes a good baseball player?". The instruction to the teacher was, "Make sure the students answer "Know what each part of the field is called", and, "He can throw the ball". Besides which, this is purely subjective.
5. The instructions to the teacher stated that only on some questions were students "permitted" to ask questions.
6. They had to learn about the "fundamentals of baseball', such as what a season ticket holder is, what are errors and home runs, the object of the game, and how you win.
7. Questions were repeated, but worded slightly differently. For example, "What are errors and home runs, and what do they do in a game?". The next question asked, "How do errors and home runs effect the game?".
I have been trying to unravel the mystery of Common Core for several years, and have come to the conclusion it is strictly a tool with which to control the population. The fact that creative writing and literature is going to be slashed to a mere 30% of High School English curriculum, in favor of argumentative writing and textbooks about HVAC is alarming. And that students are being guided to answer and think like lemmings, and not independently is an unacceptable direction in which public schools are headed.
I am a concerned parent who feels that the time for silence has passed, and these laws which are getting passed with no discourse must come to light. The stifling of parental involvement, and open dialogue with teachers is unacceptable.
Thank you for your time, and I truly hope to hear from you regarding this important issue.
I am writing to you out of deep concern regarding the Common Core curriculum, specifically related to math that is being taught in my daughter's school.
At the parent/teacher conference I had with my daughter's 8th grade math teacher, he expressed to me the dismay he feels about something that he was being compelled to teach to prepare his students for an upcoming test this Friday, April 4, 2014. He said he is required to teach them about baseball, and the parts of a stadium, and positions. I asked if it was about the geometry of a baseball diamond, or statistics. He answered, no, that it was only about the elements of the stadium and positions. I asked him if this was Common Core curriculum, to which he answered yes, and then further said he was not allowed to discuss it. My head nearly spun! This is my daughter's education, he is her teacher, and as a parent, I want to know what is being taught in my daughter's classrooms.
Today, I have had the chance to ask my daughter about her math class, to follow up on what she was going to learn. The following is some of what she was "taught" in her math class today;
1. They had to learn what each section of seats is called, such as bleachers and box seats.
2. The bases, and then two photographs were presented of home plate, shown from above and then from the side. They had to identify if this was the same place on the field or not.
3. They had to learn each of the positions of the players, and the name of the part of the field their position is in.
4. On more than one question, the students were "led" to answer a certain way. One of the questions was, "What makes a good baseball player?". The instruction to the teacher was, "Make sure the students answer "Know what each part of the field is called", and, "He can throw the ball". Besides which, this is purely subjective.
5. The instructions to the teacher stated that only on some questions were students "permitted" to ask questions.
6. They had to learn about the "fundamentals of baseball', such as what a season ticket holder is, what are errors and home runs, the object of the game, and how you win.
7. Questions were repeated, but worded slightly differently. For example, "What are errors and home runs, and what do they do in a game?". The next question asked, "How do errors and home runs effect the game?".
I have been trying to unravel the mystery of Common Core for several years, and have come to the conclusion it is strictly a tool with which to control the population. The fact that creative writing and literature is going to be slashed to a mere 30% of High School English curriculum, in favor of argumentative writing and textbooks about HVAC is alarming. And that students are being guided to answer and think like lemmings, and not independently is an unacceptable direction in which public schools are headed.
I am a concerned parent who feels that the time for silence has passed, and these laws which are getting passed with no discourse must come to light. The stifling of parental involvement, and open dialogue with teachers is unacceptable.
Thank you for your time, and I truly hope to hear from you regarding this important issue.
I think this is one of the shady things about Common Core. We still think of education at the state level, but this was implemented above states with the curriculum being pushed down on them. But there isn't an obvious "common core" organization you can go against or contact.
However we can hope that state reps will listen and one by one get rid of it.
good luck! and god bless you for being a good parent.
Good for you. Please keep us informed.
So, they're teaching the basics on baseball (something most 8th graders should already know) in math class? I know the meaning of "assume", but I'm going to do it anyway: I assume they'll teach math lessons in Physical Ed (Gym class)?
My rep is VERY proactive regarding CC, among other things. I had received an email from her a few weeks back about a hearing w/the CT Dept. of Ed, and how she wanted people to show up to speak out against common core. She was trying to arrange it so the meeting would be in the evening so parents and teachers could attend. Instead, it was "conveniently" held at noon. :-(
1. The biology teacher taught that dissection was pronounced dih-section, not dye-section.
2. The phys ed teacher put us to work writing out the states and their capitals, when for some reason (weather, maybe?) we could not hold the regular class. Most of us used his dictionary to look up the correct capitals. The lazy kids thought they knew that NYC was the capital of NY, Chicago of Illinois, etc. Coach Freddy (the teacher) of course knew the capitals, and any we got wrong had to be written out ten times.
I never really understood baseball, but I sure know my mathematics. As for geography, my immigrant grandfather could name all 48 states and the contiguous states for each one. Pop quiz: Of the "lower 48" states, which one is contiguous with only one other state?
Somewhere on the Internet you can find examples of 8th-grade graduation exams from around 1900. Try to find a college grad (even you and me) who can pass one of them!
Here's one example of the 8th grade graduation exam - http://www.barefootsworld.net/1895finale...
http://www.girardatlarge.com/wp-content/...
"Grassroots conservatives are fighting to stop Common Core.
Thanks to the hard work of activists like you, Senator Pat Roberts introduced S. 1974. This bill will make it illegal for the federal government to blackmail states into accepting dangerous education schemes like Common Core by threatening other funding.
This is a great opportunity to take control of our children’s education.
Call your Senators and tell them to co-sponsor S. 1974 and stop future attacks on local education!
It’s going to be a hard fight to pass S. 1974. That’s why we need your help today.
Call your Senators. Make sure they co-sponsor this bill.
You and I can make a difference and protect our children. Make the call today.
In Liberty,
Whitney Neal
Director of Grassroots, FreedomWorks"
Van Jones line "upside-down, inside-out" as well as the story of an American teacher, well educated
and professional, who in the mid 60's moved to
Norway to teach English. However, the Dept. of
Ed. would not let her do that; Instead they wanted her to teach physics, which she had not studied and knew next to nothing about. They gave her a book to teach from, and she tried by
reading just a page or two ahead of the students, but they did not want her ,nor did she want them. She quit and has since made her
living from her arts, which she is very good at,
and which the Dept. of Ed. would not let her
teach either. We are slightly behind the Norwegian, but CC is helping us catch up.
Insanity rules.
http://freedomoutpost.com/2014/03/common....
http://www.utahnsagainstcommoncore.com/a...
Above link is a group I belong to in Utah, they have some great articles and videos around common core. If you in Utah join up, if not find or create something like it where you are....
Every state to some degree seeks to create "good citizens".
Every state to some degree seeks to create "independent thinkers free from oppression".
We need both. We need that balance.
Is the Common Core balanced?
Frankly, not in my experience - not from what I have read of it.
I utterly oppose the Federal power grab it represents and see no reason not to oppose it in every legal and ethical way possible.
HOWEVER, baseball isn't even in the Common Core for math The man has mistaken the curriculum standards for the actual curriculum chosen by his district in response.
The baseball framework was probably chosen as a background for discussing the mathematics of hits, runs, and other statistical data within the game, and they are probably trying to be sure the children all have the basic knowledge of the game before getting into the mathematics.
I'm no apologist for the Common Core. It has to go - the Federal government has NO place in our schools. We need to kick the school lunch plan out (used as a club - do as the Feds want or they threaten your lunch program - welfare used as a weapon at it's worst).
But thought I'd point out that a search of the Common Core shows nothing about baseball in the Math section (I didn't check any other section). Truth comes first.
AND be sure not to let up the pressure against the Common Core. We just can't afford false facts to undermine the effort. It's not like it doesn't have plenty of flaws in addition to the fact that it's a Federal grab for power that is specifically restricted in the Constitution.
We'll see how serious they are about it when some of the states say, "No".
http://www.corestandards.org/
This site will create parent accounts so you can view actual curriculum
http://www.sascurriculumpathways.com/
We must learn to use the tools that remain available to us.
Load more comments...