21

Why I am in the Gulch

Posted by richrobinson 9 years ago to The Gulch: General
53 comments | Share | Best of... | Flag

I have given some thought recently about how far I have come over the last few years. I happened to hear a radio ad for the first installment of Atlas Shrugged. I got the DVD and was hooked. I bought the book and started reading it and decided to check out the website I had heard about called galtsgulchonline. My first contact here was LetsShrug. Being a newbie to forums like this I asked her what to do. I was impressed by her kindness but soon I was more impressed by her passion. She truly wanted to make a difference. After an exchange with Shrug and Khalling I knew this was a place I wanted to be. I'm curious how others found this site and what made you stay. The Gulch has come a long way since I joined and I am proud to be a part of it.


Add Comment

FORMATTING HELP

All Comments Hide marked as read Mark all as read

  • 10
    Posted by $ jbrenner 9 years ago
    I saw the first installment of Atlas Shrugged, after having read the book in 2008/2009. When wondering about when the 2nd part would come, I did a web search and stumbled (crash landed) into Galt's Gulch Online. Thanks for allowing this "scab" to stay. I swear by my life and my love of it that I will never live for the sake of another man, nor ask another man to live for mine.

    After writing this, I watched the trailer to AS1. I had forgotten just how much I liked that installment.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by NealS 9 years ago
    I read Atlas Shrugged the first time about 1962, around the time of my first marriage. I was a know it all 20 year old then, tied down to my new home that I had just bought with the savings from pulling weeds, mowing lawn, and my old paper route. I just started my latest job at Rocketdyne as a rocket scientist (actually I was just an Instrumentation Technician), looking forward to our shot at going to the moon. This was to be my lifelong a career, I loved it, and my boss, who was typically mean, loved my work. He always told me he would like to find at least a few more good workers like me and he’d have it made. I was going to stay forever.

    Four Score later, in the fall of 1966, I got an invitation in the mail from Uncle Sam to join the Army. It wasn’t exactly written like that. Rocketdyne told me not to worry, they would get me a deferment, but I’d have to transfer to their new facility near Jackson, Mississippi. I had a fear of hot and humid weather and didn’t particularly like bugs so I decided to take my chances with the Army. Dahh, I guess I still had a few things to learn in my 20’s. I guess I wasn’t aware that Vietnam was so hot, humid, and buggy, with so many snakes, tigers, bees, bugs, but mostly the scorpions. I still shake my underwear out today before putting it on. Sorry, back to the Gulch.

    As I was preparing to start a new temporary career starting off in boot camp, my parents were working on some movie star’s bid for Governor of California. Some of you might remember him, his name was Ronald Reagan. Sometime just before I went to The Nam he actually got elected. My parents were ecstatic. I was happy for them but I was now in Lawton Oklahoma training as an artillery officer to serve my country in some far and distant land. They were so proud of me, especially my dad. He could not serve, Briggs and Stratton wouldn’t let him go to the Big One as he was one of their best machinists. He designed and prototyped new designs for bomb triggers and other things.

    Some years after the service I stumbled on my AS copy and reread it, around the time George H. W. Bush was Vice President and my parent’s friend Ronny was President. My God, remember when Jerry Brown succeeded Ronald Reagan as Governor of California (sorry, that’s another story). I was living in California then and I think that Jerry Brown might have been what prompted me to reread AS again.

    And finally, a few years ago, my third wife bought me a new copy of AS. Reading it again in this century was like reading it for the first time. It was so hard to put down, except for the weight and bulkiness I might have read it without putting it down. Every few chapters I’d put in a marker and go running around the house to find my wife to tell her how parallel something I had just read in the book was to what was going on today in our government. It was like I just heard the same thing on the news yesterday. It shed a new light on Ayn Rand for me. How had she known? How could anyone back in the mid 50’s possibly predict so accurately what kind of a government we would have today? Was it a prediction or just a warning? Will her book make as strong a statement 50 years from now as it does today? Oh, God, thank you for death, it makes us all able to cope.

    I stumbled into the Gulch after making a small contribution to the production of AS movie, and buying some of the paraphernalia. And my wife just loves Dagny’ s bracelet (if you get one, a suggestion is to exchange the latch for a magnetic one). I’m not a social media person at all, but the Gulch has been a Godsend for me. I’m getting old(er), and some of the Agent Orange predictions are starting to take effect on my body. The Gulch makes me forget, the people are wonderful, even those that disagree with me do so in such a civil manner. Sometimes the disagreement even goes way over my head, I love it. Where else might I wish to spend a little of my precious time reminiscing about the past and future of our country? Blogging is something I’d never ever do, I swore to it, and to prove it, OMG I’m over 1500 already. How did that happen?
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by jpellone 9 years ago
      Neal, Love your post. It made me think about my path to here and where I am today.

      Growing up in the 60's and 70's, I didn't care much about politics. I did however wonder why my dad and many others were losing their jobs and the factories around me (northeast Ohio) were closing. I thought it may have been mismanagement of the leaders of the companies. How wrong I was!!!

      I joined the Navy in '77 and didn't give politics much thought until after I retired in '97. I moved to Texas and went to college. I felt so out of place there(in college) because it seemed that no one thought as I did. I joined the college Republicans because they had more in common with me. The straw that broke the camels back was my Texas Politics teacher; the first day all he did was talk about reparations and how bad Bush was. There was about 250 students in that class. I was the only one that stood up and challenged him on anything he said. Well, except one other. A young black girl raised her hand as he was talking about reparations and said "My parents told me that if I wanted anything in my life I had to work for it." His response made me furious!!! He said "you listen to too much Bill O'Reilly!!!" I stood up and said some choice words at him and explained that Bill Cosby has those same beliefs and his response was "Well, it was Bill somebody." I then realized that the left were really LOONS. Luckily, the next class they asked for volunteers to go to a different class as the other teachers class was cancelled. She was an outstanding teacher that did not put her own politics into the class at all. In fact, I found out after the class was over that she was a Democrat but voted for GW Bush.

      About that time AS came out. Didn't even know who AR was. Saw the trailer and thought the movie looked interesting. I went and saw it along with the other 10 or 12 people in the theater and I was hooked... Fairness sounds good but is impossible to implement without devastating results. Kinda like what happened in Ohio while I was growing up. I then started putting it all together and realized just what governing with your heart instead of your brain was a bad thing.

      I went to the first Tea Party rally at the Alamo with Glenn Beck and the Motor City Madman and found many people of all races that thought like me. After the first AS movie I started searching and learning more about AR and found she was very forward thinking. I also ran across The Gulch and joined immediately. I love the discussions with people much smarter than me and thinking like me.

      One last thing Neal, Thank You for your service!!!!
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by teri-amborn 9 years ago
      Thank you. You made me laugh out loud and cry all in one post.
      Isn't personal growth WONDERFUL?
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
      • Posted by NealS 9 years ago
        Teri, Thank you, maybe I'll get started on that book soon. The more I write here and realize I'm leaving out so much in an effort to try to keep it short, the more I realize I've got a lot of stories and a lot to say. The hard part is coming to realization that someone might actually be interested in reading my story.
        Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ DLCarr17 9 years ago
    My path here started strangely through a video game. The game was Bioshock in late 2007. I enjoyed the game and found out that Ayn Rands Atlas Shrugged had played a large roll in the games development. I didn't get around to reading it however until Thanksgiving of 2013. After I started reading I couldn't get my hands on the rest of Ayn Rands work fast enough. I read everything I could get my hands on and through web searches I found out about the Ayn Rand Institute. Learning about the institute lead me to finding Yaron Brook and Don Watkins among others and I started listening to their pod casts, speeches, debates, and their own writings. Somewhere along the way I found out about the Atlas Shrugged movies and through a search for the Blu-ray release date of part 3 I found the gulch. All it took was reading a few threads and comments and I knew I wanted to be at least a small part of this site. That's the short version.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by DanShu 9 years ago
    After reading AS about two years ago I got the first DVD. It had a little add in it with the Gulch online address. I figured it might be interesting so joined up. It is interesting, and I have always enjoyed hearing the opinions of others.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ Thoritsu 9 years ago
    I've long been sick of the two parties, each simply vying for control of other peoples freedoms that make them comfortable. This has bothered me since high school, when I first payed any attention to politics.

    First Libertarianism appealed to me, than after more seeking more information, I found Ayn Rand. Honestly, I came across this site after watching the first Atlas Shrugged, giggling through the whole thing from kindred joy.

    I dug up this site looking for movie information and just love it. I've been educated by the high concentration of brilliant people here, and engaged in many excellent, thought-provoking debates.

    I sought out a couple of people in the Midwest for beers. Now I need to look up some locals.

    Great site.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by ObjectiveAnalyst 8 years, 11 months ago
    Hello richrobinson,
    I have been a part of each Gulch since the first one and naturally moved along with each new version. Having read the book over three decades ago I was hooked, continued reading other Rand material, watching and waiting for an AS movie. I heard about some plans and did a search. That is how I found the first Gulch and immediately started to battle the collectivist trolls!
    You have been a most joyous addition to our band of individualists.
    Regards,
    O.A.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by jimslag 9 years ago
    I read the book back in the 70's and really did not think about it much at the time. I spent the 80's and 90's in the Navy and spent a lot of it on independent duty overseas. I retired in 2001 (Space Odyssey year) and wondered why everything was going the way it was, which is not how I thought it should. When Atlas Shrugged I came out, I thought, wow, I read that book back when. I went to see the movie and was hooked. I searched online and saw a link for the site and checked it out. BAM, I joined and haven't looked back since. I became a producer as soon as I heard about it. I enjoy the outlook of many co-conspirators here. I have bantered with many and corresponded with more. I appreciate the camaraderie with all here and look forward to continuing in the future.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ rainman0720 9 years ago
    I came to know Atlas Shrugged very late in life, probably 7 or 8 years ago. Like you, one exposure to Atlas Shrugged was all it took for me to become hooked.

    The more I listen to this book on CD (or read it), the more I think that today's progressive movement is based on this book.

    So many of the things I see happening today could almost be pulled directly out of Atlas Shrugged.

    I think progressives are using Atlas Shrugged as their playbook, but in their arrogance, they think they can change the ending.

    The entire dystopia* that Ayn Rand protrays must look like heaven on earth to progressives. Since proggies think they know what's best for all of us, and since Rand pretty much laid it out for them, I think they grabbed it and ran with it, honestly believing they could alter the outcome.

    Of course, I am a cynic through and through, so this could all be in my head. But is sure looks and feels right.


    * At least to me, it's a Dystopia.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by woodlema 9 years ago
    I am in the Gulch for pretty much 2 words.
    Personal Responsibility.

    Objectivism for all the talk and philosophy surrounding the various subtleties to me all boils down to that.

    When were are ALL personally responsible, we only act with reason, we only do things in our best self-interest. To me it is all summed up that way, and those were things my Grandfather taught me 45 years ago when I was 6.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Temlakos 9 years ago
    I came to exchange ideas on the nature of government and the economy. You might say I wondered whether this community would become an extension of the Ayn Rand Center, or Institute, or whatever they call it.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ allosaur 9 years ago
    Saw AS1.
    Then I discovered the Gulch and people who pretty much think like I do.
    I like it here where I can both learn and express my dino self.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by bassboat 9 years ago
    It all started for me when I was watching Stossel on Fox. They talking about this Ayn Rand person and Atlas Shrugged. It sounded like it was something I would like so I checked it out at the library. The librarian said it was awful but I got it anyway. I've now read it 6 times plus I have the audio book of it. I wish I had been exposed to it years ago but I wasn't. I don't agree with Ayn on everything but consider this to be a must read for every student.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by waytodude 9 years ago
    I too watched Atlas Shrugged saw that Ayn Rand wrote the book. I'm a big Rush fan (Canadian rock band) the album 2112 was inspired by Rand so that really pushed me into reading Rand ' s work. I was beginning to read Greek philosophy ie Plato which had trouble with it and how I believe life should be. But then after reading Rand the light bulb blew up. Now I'm trying to get my hands everything written on objectivism. I'm here because of the like minded weird people such as myself an outcast in the view of today's society.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ Stormi 9 years ago
    When I discovered Ayn Rand many years ago via a philosophy class in college, it was like coming home.I bought and read everything I could find by her. I had found so few people in the local society who thought the way she did about responsibility, except my dad. I loved hearing Neal Boortz tell radio listeners to read "Atlas Shrugged", but had only found random websites posting articles on objectivism. When I went in search of the DVD of "Atlas Shrugged" pt.1, I found the Gulch. I had to keep returning, one place where the ideas of Rand were ever present. Where promoting personal responsibility did not get you called "cold hearted" as it did in our super altruistic society. Who would not want to be in the Gulch, where reason reigns.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Herb7734 9 years ago
    I was searching for something related to Objectivism on Google when the Gulch popped up. I went there. Been there ever since. Interacting with Gulchers has been one of the joys of my old age.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by term2 9 years ago
    I have to agree that this is a great forum. I read it every day and its very uplifting to be able to interact with intelligent people who have thought about things. There is also a refreshing lack of hidden agendas. I am so tired of having to translate what I hear on the news so as to uncover the hidden agendas. THEN there's the expert on hidden agendas- Obama, and lately Hillary. I pretty much ignore anything those two say
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Mark_Taylor007 9 years ago
    The cast for the first movie was nearly perfect. Especially Hank. By the 3rd installment, the cash was really sub-par and unacceptable. I admire the effort it took to make all 3 parts, but the quality got progressively worse.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by BeenThere 9 years ago
      Understand your post..............would like to add that producing a motion picture (not to mention the incredible scope of the book), much less three motion pictures is a huge endeavor. First, a motion picture requires the skills of almost (if not all) human talents (which is why they fascinate me). Second, acquiring the funds for production and the contracts for actors and all the other skills requires enormous effort, patience, and commitment (so one is not worn down by the irrationality one will encounter). Third, the motion picture industry's hostility toward AR/AS is mountainous!

      I am grateful to John A for making the film, regardless of the "less than what I would have preferred" but I do understand what a huge task he undertook (and it being his first entry into that field); considering those factors, the three films were important, giving the book more exposure.

      While the best format for AS is a mini-series, I have seen on this site where that is a work in progress. I believe John A and his team have learned volumes from their movie experience (one doesn't reach his level of business success without such learning) and a mini-series allows much more time for production development, not to mention a consistency of casting.

      I will only say, "Go, John, go!!!" I will give any support I can (as I believe many in The Gulch will) and I look forward to the product and positive effects of your endeavors.


      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by fotoldy 8 years, 11 months ago
    I read Atlas Shrugged in high school for a book report. My family were all democrats and my dad asked me why would I want to read this nonsense. That made me determined to finish the book and get an A. Ayn Rand ' s philosophy fascinated by Dagne ' s independence was a role model for me. In short, Atlas Shrugged became a sort of bible for me. Rand was still alive at the time and I started receiving her newsletters and I read all her books.

    Over the years, after I met my husband he read AS and the others and recently the movies and then videos came out many of our friends and family have seen the light. Rand ' s philosophy is alive and well in this country. Galt Gulch will grow and thrive.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by 8 years, 11 months ago
      I am always jealous when I find someone who found Rand at a young age. I was in my mid 40s but remind myself it's never too late. Were you able to "convert" any of your family to Rands ideas?
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
      • Posted by fotoldy 8 years, 10 months ago
        No. Dad was a communist and mom was whatever she heard on tv. But dad and i had great discussions. My brother was on my side sorta. He read Rands works and became an anarchist. At least that wasn't liberal. He's a liberal now. You can't win them all.
        Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Comment hidden by post owner or admin, or due to low comment or member score. View Comment
  • Posted by $ MichaelAarethun 9 years ago
    I have been reading Rand since AS was first published. I remember her comment after seeing a VHS of Fountainhead. She would never let AS be filmed. They did a good job though and I wish it could be redone covering the book more fully. But since the announcement came out I have course been following release of the DVD since no theaters where I am. It's far too deep for the popcorn and koolaid crowd. My fear was it woudl become another Starship Troopers made I'm sure to ensure no one read the book. In the USA seeing a movie is considered the equivalent of reading for those that can read.

    One thing led to another ...here I am. I celebrated the 50thy anniversary of the book by giving away a fiftieth copy 49 through 53 have been to Engish readers south of the border.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Owlsrayne 9 years ago
    This is one of the only forums on the internet for intelligent conversation. Also, it's the only place where there is the possiblility in creating a real Gulch.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Comment hidden by post owner or admin, or due to low comment or member score. View Comment
  • Posted by radical 9 years ago
    At the age of 80 I have been able to witness and experience the last 50 years of the Progressive movement in America that started in 1913 with the "ratification" of the 16th Amendment and the passage of the Federal Reserve Act. As previously stated, I went to the Gulch in 1983. If you want to know how, contact Radical.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  

FORMATTING HELP

  • Comment hidden. Undo