Socialism is Certainly Not the Answer BUT...
Posted by SuzanneTaylor 13 years, 1 month ago to Economics
I think too many of us are focused on what the media has to say, the media is owned by someone, we scoff at independent news bytes and blow them off as conspiracy theories, but all of us are feeling the squeeze as more and more of us are forced to pay for more and more that is not necessary. I believe this too be true and I firmly believe that this was hinted at within Atlas Shrugged and too many are hiding it. Yes, the top 20% of the economy will have more, it takes money to run a successful business and to keep it running and competing with other such businesses, but we must still pay the workers a livable wage, if your workers don't eat and can barely afford the shelter over their heads (sometimes with three people crammed into a studio apartment) then what is their incentive to work for us?
http://www.galtsgulchonline.com/posts/e9...
"living wage" is a meaningless term.
I suggest you take a look at the "Wealth Inequality in America Refuted" message thread, and its link.
Now of course everyone would like to live more luxuriously, but that's something that has to be earned, and trying to get it through government legislation will only bring down the total income level of society as a whole.
I'm really getting tired of the whiners/2nd handers/moochers and looters CEO v. janitor comparison. If both are doing their jobs both are working hard, they just have different skill sets. If you want to be paid like a CEO acquire the necessary skills, and start your own business. In other words, but down your free phone, push yourself away from the table in your subsidized home with the subsidized food and get to work.
The fact that wealth dispersion is as great as this video describes is just a point in a field of stars. As stated already, the "Wealth Inequality in America Refuted" video explains nicely to this point with other dismissed criteria.
To the moral of the story, however, I will credit that this Harvard Professor is *starting* to learn about this topic. One of the massive issues we currently have with the system is that the people on the left hand part of this spectrum keep asking for more government handouts - and ironically, keep getting them. The argument that the "cost of living" is increasing, and thus they can no longer afford these "necessities" helps this argument *seem* reasonable.
So, lets agree, in this example, that *inflation* is actually increasing the "cost of living" and thus a raise is necessary to maintain the same standard of living that the employee originally had. The ones on the left argue that they are not getting raises when in all reality the amount they charge their employer to work there (i.e. their "wage" or "cost of employment") IS actually going up. However, instead of seeing this as a wage increase, they are actually seeing it as no increase at best (the increase is being used to pay for the added social benefits being demanded by the government), or a decrease in wages (because the added benefits demanded by the government are greater than the amount they would have received via the "raise" in wages).
For example, if we eliminated the Medicare social benefit each employee would see approximately an additional 2.9% increase in their take home pay (the employer must pay 1.45% to the government AND the employee must automatically distribute 1.45% to the government to fund the Medicare program). Removing Social Security would similarly increase your take home pay by 12.4% (6.2% from each).
"The employee tax rate for social security is 6.2% for 2013. The employer tax rate for social security remains unchanged at 6.2%. The social security wage base limit is $113,700. The 2013 employee tax rate for Medicare is 1.45% (amount withheld) each for the employee and employer (2.9% total). There is no wage base limit for Medicare tax; all covered wages are subject to Medicare tax." (Publication 15 - The IRS looter: http://www.irs.gov/publications/p15/ar02...)
Similarly, there are other taxes that could increase your income if the social benefits were removed (i.e. Unemployment Tax, Income Tax*, the new Affordable Care Act Tax, etc). So, the more benefits that are requested, the less pay that finds it's way into the take home check, thus the more meek the living conditions seem with inflation occurring and the government automatically redistributing your paycheck. This leads the ones on the left to believe they need to blame the ones on the right for not paying them enough even though the argument is illogical.
Secondly, the ones on the right DO have a massive amount of accumulated wealth (very true!). I've been battling myself for some time on this issue, because we may need to discuss the level of productiveness that such "producers" have in our current society. Using 3% of $50 Billion to be productive is hardly enough to claim that we are "producers". Much of this wealth, if used in a productive way (i.e. new business ventures) may actually improve the economy and add more employment positions. Thus, it is my argument that many of these 1%'s, if they are actual "producers", may-should see the benefit to themselves for being more "productive"... however, I digress... many are not "producers" and may only have that wealth because it was transferred to them via a "producer" parent or grandparent OR, if they are a "producer", may not have any decent incentive to put that capital to work.
However, connecting all of this back to the point of the "living wage", I would argue that the "living wage" is increasing (via the social benefits) even though it may appear that the wages are decreasing (or not increasing as much as inflation).
*Income Tax may need to be "broken down" into it's individual pieces to show what % is being attributed to what programs to further disseminate whether these programs are desirable / necessary for continuation.
If you've read this far, I'd like to apologize for my inability to make this "book" shorter...