In Defense of Machiavelli

Posted by Hiraghm 12 years, 4 months ago to Books
5 comments | Share | Best of... | Flag

I've always been a fan of Machiavelli's "The Prince". It had some good lessons and good quotes in it. But Machiavelli's name has become almost a swear word over the centuries.

The following is excerpted from the Editor's Introduction to "That Share of Glory", in "Imperial Stars, Volume 1: The Stars At War".

"Machiavelli's name does not rank in the noble company of scientists. In the common opinion of men, his name itself has become a term of reproach and dishonor...

"Why should this be? If our reference is to the views that Machiavelli in fact held, that he stated plainly, openly, and clearly in his writings, there is in the common opinion no truth at all... It is true that he has taught tyrants, from almost his own days - Thomas Cromwell, for example, the lowborn Chancellor whom Henry VIII brought in to replace Thomas More when More refused to make his conscience a tool of his master's interests, was said to have a copy of Machiavelli always in his pocket; and in our time Mussolini wrote a college thesis on Machiavelli. But knowledge has a disturbing neutrality in this respect. We do not blame the research analyst who has solved the chemical mysteries of a poison because a murderer made use of his treatise...

“We are, I think, and not only from the fate of Machiavelli's reputation, forced to conclude that men do not really want to know about themselves... Perhaps the full disclosure of what we really are and how we act is too violent a medicine.

“In any case, whatever may be the desires of most men, it is most certainly against the interests of the powerful that the truth should be known about political behavior. If the political truths stated by Machiavelli were widely known, the success of tyranny would become much less likely. If men understood as much of the mechanism of rule and privilege as Machiavelli understood, the would no longer be deceived into accepting that rule and privilege, and they would know what steps to take to overcome them.

“Therefore the powerful and their spokesmen – all the 'official' thinkers, the lawyers and philosophers and preachers and demagogues – must defame Machiavelli.
Machiavelli says that rulers lie and break faith; this proves, they say, that he libels human nature. Machiavelli says that ambitious men struggle for power; he is apologizing for the opposition, the enemy, and trying to confuse you about us, who wish to lead you for your own good and welfare. Machiavelli says that you must keep strict watch over officials and subordinate them to the law; he is encouraging subversion and the loss of national unity. Machiavelli says that no man with power is to be trusted; you see that his aim is to smash all your faith and ideals.

Small wonder that the powerful – in public – denounce Machiavelli. The powerful have long practice and much skill in sizing up their opposition. They can recognize an enemy who will never compromise, even when that enemy is so abstract as a body of ideas.”

James Burnham, “The Machiavellians”


Add Comment

FORMATTING HELP

All Comments Hide marked as read Mark all as read

  • Posted by MattFranke 12 years, 4 months ago
    Reading the literature of the powerful is always an enlightening pastime. Know thine enemy. They have told us everything they are doing. It's all hidden in plain site.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by ObjectiveAnalyst 12 years, 4 months ago
    I can appreciate your premise. It has definite merit, and has been argued by others as well. I am quite fond of the Stanford Encyclopedia Of Philosophy. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/machia...
    It is quite handy when you need a quick review of the overall positions of notable philosophers. It is a great time saver when on line. I can find answers faster than searching my books, but for a complete understanding, reading the writings in full context is imperative. I have often found among the writings of some philosophers who I largely disagree with, at least one genuinely brilliant insight. Even the most simple among us are capable of a brilliant thought.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Spinkane 12 years, 4 months ago
    “men do not really want to know about themselves... Perhaps the full disclosure of what we really are and how we act is too violent a medicine. “
    This statement is very true in my experience. With the location of the eyes, fingernails and incisors we are predators, it’s amazing how many people you can find who deny that. How easy it is to get some people to state “ We are not animals!” When you can’t agree on that premise, who we are, everything after jettisons into fantasy. That’s why I posted a poem here, to subtly make that point. I don’t know Mach. but I agree with that.
    When my world gets turned upside down
    and there is no you and me.
    It snows in my one house town.
    That’s the snow globe guarantee.

    When I draw a picture of you
    and I think I’m who I want to be.
    What I thought was yellow is blue,
    and the picture is a mirror of me.

    It seems the yellow brick road
    leads back to reality.
    We receive what we are owed,
    it’s the snow globe guarantee.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Comment hidden by post owner or admin, or due to low comment or member score. View Comment
  • Posted by 12 years, 4 months ago
    "It ought to be remembered that there is nothing more difficult to take in hand, more perilous to conduct, or more uncertain in its success, than to take the lead in the introduction of a new order of things. "

    "Hence it comes that all armed prophets have been victorious, and all unarmed prophets have been destroyed."

    "Among other evils which being unarmed brings you, it causes you to be despised."

    And my favorite:
    "God is not willing to do everything, and thus take away our free will and that share of glory which belongs to us."
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  

FORMATTING HELP

  • Comment hidden. Undo