We have discussed some possibilities for a future Gulch location. For starters, let's assume we will buy an island, rather than build one on "stilts" from a underground reef. Because of the list of islands in a web site listed below ranks islands in reverse order of quality, to make it easier to scroll through options, I have used their numbering system (and added to it).

Freedomforall makes the following recommendation:
14) An option is Guanaja in the Honduras Bay Islands. He has good friends who own a diving resort there. Great people from Texas. See:
http://www.clearwaterparadise.com/
Freedomforall also discussed Bonaire and Curacao down in the far southeastern

First, the EBay possibilities:

13. 55 acre private with several condos and amenities already developed $4 million, Abaco, Bahamas

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Private-Island-F...

12. 5 acre private island off of Nicaraguan coast $100 K with one home, but reserve not met

http://www.ebay.com/itm/BEAUTIFUL-5-ACRE...

11. 3 acres undeveloped private island 10 miles from Daytona Beach, FL $10 K opening bid for down payment

http://www.ebay.com/itm/3-Acre-Private-I...

http://www.islands.com/gallery/top-10-pr...

10. Kastawei Island, Vanuatu: $199,000 - too small for the Gulch
9. Tahifehifa Island, Tonga: $370,205 - too small for the Gulch
8. Pink Pearl Island, Nicaragua: $500,000 - too small for the Gulch
7. Motu Opuou, French Polynesia: $742,886 - too small for the Gulch
6. Pelican Cay, Bahamas: $2,500,000
5. Bannister Caye, Belize: $2,500,000
4. Dumunpalit, Philippines: $3,400,000
3. Portofino Caye, Belize: $4,500,000
2. Manuhangi Atoll, French Polynesia: $8,667,003
1. Saddle Back Cay, Bahamas: $12,995,000

Personally, out of all these I like Option 13 in Abaco on the Bahamas best.

None of the above is an option.
If interested, rank your three favorite choices, with best first.
Brenner example: 13, 3, 12

Write-in votes will be considered.
A summer Gulch will be considered in a thread at some point in the future.