What Would Happen If Humans Disappeared?
Yep...this comes from the left, the environ(mental)ist and the "animals were here first crowd. (sometimes I wonder if they realize that They Too, would not exist).
But...ask yourself, your rationally interested self...what value would the earth serve without mankind? What possible purpose would it serve? Sure, the animals would have a place to live...but so what?
For that matter, what value would existence have without an awareness of it?
[Note: for those that don't know or never thought about it; Animals are, Yes, aware of their environment, but not aware of their own awareness...as such was the case for ancient man as well. But, we did have a strange and powerful curiosity about it all.]
But...ask yourself, your rationally interested self...what value would the earth serve without mankind? What possible purpose would it serve? Sure, the animals would have a place to live...but so what?
For that matter, what value would existence have without an awareness of it?
[Note: for those that don't know or never thought about it; Animals are, Yes, aware of their environment, but not aware of their own awareness...as such was the case for ancient man as well. But, we did have a strange and powerful curiosity about it all.]
Previous comments... You are currently on page 2.
I wanted to add one more thing to tie it all together for you. Everything that has a certain value has a point to it (a purpose if you will, and that purpose is as it relates to the valuer), but the question you have to really search for is without that value or purpose assigned, does the object become devalued and cease existing? My answer, it doesn't because its still in reality regardless if someone is there to observe it.
The hole point, I think, IS objectively subjective?...without awareness, there is no value, no purpose, no objectivity nor subjectivity; nothing good bad or ugly, no rights or wrongs, day or night and it matters not if anything exists.
It's kind of a circular argument but this is the corner the leftest have gotten themselves into...Yes/No?
One might argue that without humans, nature might just destroy itself till there is only one species and that one species would die out too!
Value is a subjective determination: completely valid to you, but perhaps not so much to someone else.
As I implied but didn't state directly above, there does not HAVE to be "a point," and if there is "a point," that point could be different to varying individuals (or any other entity that might be making that judgment). (In this case, the "point" I am referring to is not your "point" that you felt necessary to explain (it wasn't) but this, which I am quoting from your explanation. " otherwise, there would be not point to it.")
And if there's no point to it (as there may not be), then what?
Holding hands regardless of the distance between you both...nice.
As to value...every cell in your body has value...so too, everything in existence must have some value otherwise, there would be not point to it.
However, we could argue the opposite in reference to some creatures in our government...laughing.
I am not here. I don't care.
And..."value" to whom/what?
What about planets that are uninhabited....do they serve a value? Do they have a purpose? Do they need either one? Would they be less "valuable" if we weren't here to observe them in the night sky? What about the ones we can't see?
Here is a condensed very similar to your link something~
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ri9bA...