My final words on the Immigration discussion
Should I have to chose between Objectivism and being American. I am American.
When we as a people, a grouping of individuals with common laws and ideas, begin to lose that commonality then our society is forfeit. Kindness toward those not in our country is an act of charity by individuals and individual institutions, not something that should be done by our government with our tax dollars. Charity/kindness by the government is based on the governments ability to take what is rightfully yours, your money, and give it in some way to someone else - this is theft. "Giving" is not the only way our federal government, whose primary responsability is to defend our country, shows kindness, it also turns a blind eye to murder, rape and theft of property and identity of its people. The federal government of the United States of America, and apparently quite a few people, wish to give our land, our homes, our freedom, our security, our culture, and our wealth away.
How things are "over there" is inconsequential once someone gets here. Once here, legal or otherwise, people should be made to conform to our way. To not conform to our ways, our laws, is a clear indicator that leaving a shithole to get somewhere better isn't their primary concern. Illegal aliens first act in fiding a new, safer home is to voilate our laws.
I have a long list of the things done to me, my family and my friends for simply living in the United States by foreign nationals who just decided to come. If US citizens were to have done many of these they'd be in jail and I'd have some degree of restitution. Instead I've been told countless times by countless people to accept these people - No!
I did not serve my country and suspend my freedom to watch it being given away. I will fight illegal immigration until an illegal or their liberl drone successfully runs me off the road (yes, its been attempted 2x).
Allan J. Ashinoff
When we as a people, a grouping of individuals with common laws and ideas, begin to lose that commonality then our society is forfeit. Kindness toward those not in our country is an act of charity by individuals and individual institutions, not something that should be done by our government with our tax dollars. Charity/kindness by the government is based on the governments ability to take what is rightfully yours, your money, and give it in some way to someone else - this is theft. "Giving" is not the only way our federal government, whose primary responsability is to defend our country, shows kindness, it also turns a blind eye to murder, rape and theft of property and identity of its people. The federal government of the United States of America, and apparently quite a few people, wish to give our land, our homes, our freedom, our security, our culture, and our wealth away.
How things are "over there" is inconsequential once someone gets here. Once here, legal or otherwise, people should be made to conform to our way. To not conform to our ways, our laws, is a clear indicator that leaving a shithole to get somewhere better isn't their primary concern. Illegal aliens first act in fiding a new, safer home is to voilate our laws.
I have a long list of the things done to me, my family and my friends for simply living in the United States by foreign nationals who just decided to come. If US citizens were to have done many of these they'd be in jail and I'd have some degree of restitution. Instead I've been told countless times by countless people to accept these people - No!
I did not serve my country and suspend my freedom to watch it being given away. I will fight illegal immigration until an illegal or their liberl drone successfully runs me off the road (yes, its been attempted 2x).
Allan J. Ashinoff
Previous comments... You are currently on page 2.
Posted by $ khalling 18 minutes ago
"If you cannot cross a border, if innocent, you are not talking about natural rights you are talking totalitarian state."
I take it then, that you don't claim any rights for a sovereign nation to establish any immigration (read: border) laws, whatsoever.
I think that is Pollyanna wishing, to say the least. And the rest of the world would agree, since I don't know a single nation that doesn't control their borders...for all of the right reasons.
We disagree, and not the first time! ;-)
in "illegals" it is still totalitarian. go within the 50 mile zone without a passport. I dare you, US citizen.
Does "your person" have actual GPS coordinates?
Land does...and to mix the two private properties gets us nowhere...although it can be fun to debate over.
Borders exist. So do natural rights (where recognized). But to claim that you have a natural right to go wherever you please, even if you cross a defined border, is no more than chaos. That claim will get you no further than the lockup, unless you are violating the U.S. sovereign border. ;-)
What we are facing today with the natural rights approach to free movement across the Rio Grande, is living proof of how unrealistic that intrinsic philosophical argument really is.
Goes great with a bottle of Marsala...but plays 'hell' with the private property owners north of the border....
Ever been stopped within the 50 mile no man's border in the US? You have no rights as a US citizen in your own country. They can detain you for whatever length of time they choose for whatever reason. I know. IT's happened to my daughter who luckily called her lawyer father. Once they determined she was talking to someone savvy on the law she was released.
That's true only if you live in the wilderness away from people. If you CHOOSE to live/be among other people you are then subject to the rules/laws of that society.
A sovereign state/nation IS private property - illegal aliens have trespassed and, by US law, have committed a crime.
If none...then our immigration laws are not violating anyone's natural rights.
Govt should only use force (this applies to immigration laws) when when someone has initiated force(stealing, fraud is force). traveling is not using force.you don't really want a free society. Immigration issues are due to the welfare state.
Its not a protectionist bent, it more logical. Why form communities/societies if not for a "common" way of living - even if that way mean very few rules and that everyone's desire to exist and flourish as they see fit is respected. This is extremely self-interest oriented since you do surrender certain amounts of self-determination depending on which society you live in. A society (group) cannot function within the confines of its law if people who do not subscribe can saturate the society, what you then have is a degradation of that society and a new society forming. Protecting one's society/culture/country is essential to the continuation of that country.
"Natural rights would not be consistent with the idea that you can make it legal or illegal to emirate or immigrate."
If true, Mouch has the natural right to enter The Gulch.
And the inhabitants of The Gulch could not stop immigration, since that would be in violation of Mouch's rights.
The movie took artistic liberties with this for dramatic affect. :)
You add a protectionist bent. Not much of one, but it is still there. Some things you are placing high value on to protect with force, others might place a high value on stuff you would not. "would not be welcomed..." imagine an Ayn Rand not welcomed because she could not wade through the legalistic mumbo jumbo of US law today. Trust me, AJ, you are breaking laws right and left, you don't even know about-
Doesn't someone in AS say to Hank -what good is a law if no one ever breaks it? I can't find this! who said it? it was in the movie too..hmph. I hate it when I can't find a quote.
That (to me) would have been irrational, if not suicidal to the inhabitants.
Load more comments...