A God talk.

Posted by $ AJAshinoff 13 years, 2 months ago to Philosophy
15 comments | Share | Best of... | Flag

I believe that my strength as a writer is derived from my ability to string together generally unrelated things and events spread over a long periods of time and my ability to put them together so the make sense. This ability served me well in commentary and still does developing plots for my books.

While I have strong Objectivist feelings I cannot subscribe to the no-God aspect of Objectivism. I openly admit that I cannot see, feel, or touch God and that I have major issues with the concept of predestination, fate, and saying thank you 10K times. Still, I cannot find it in myself to conclude that God isn't there. I look at the universe and I look at human cells and I can see a symmetry, an order, or a process that cannot, in my eyes, be random or happenstance. Yes, I I believe in intelligent design. Is that God? in intelligent design. Is that God? Perhaps.

I also have a major trouble with accepting "is" for "is" sake whether that's God or the laws of physics. Space, in this mind, does eventually end. Nothing in this reality or resonance (the only one we know) is limitless, just unimaginably and inconceivably big.

I'm curious how other Objectivists deal with this issue of an unseen authority (aka God).


Add Comment

FORMATTING HELP

All Comments Hide marked as read Mark all as read

  • Posted by Zenphamy 13 years, 2 months ago
    As for myself, I deal with an unseen authority (aka God, or any other name or ism) as I deal with all authority issues - NONE IS ACCEPTED, it is only granted through and after direct observation and reason. I live, I observe (perceive), I question, I conceive, I value, I postulate, I test, I agree/disagree, I act.
    The very simplistic concept of a power or controller outside of myself is so abhorrent to my ability to reason for myself, from that to create value for myself, and find others that are willing or wanting to offer their excess value creation in return for some of my excess value creation; that I can't conceive nor imagine a purpose of awaking in the morning under such an ism,
    Yes, I question. From that it follows that I'm not necessarily an atheist, but more an 'I don't know-ist.' All other humans that have ever existed have only had the same senses and internal existence as myself, so I must from that conclude that they can't know either. That doesn't mean they can't imagine or even believe in their imagination and even write stories about that imagining and what they believe is the basis for a faith in that imagining. But to try to impose their imaginings on me as some type of rule book, recipe book, or road map for me or others to follow throughout their individual travels through existence strikes me as an absolute absurdity and even immorality.
    From that, I don't subscribe to the supposed definition of Objectivism as requiring the addition of Atheism. Nor do I subscribe to the concept that it's necessary to know the answer nor the way to 'deal with this issue' as a requisite in order to approach my existence and life of the mind from an Objectivist viewpoint.
    Space, in this mind, doesn't end nor is it necessary for it to do so and limiting the unknown is, to me, simply a way to deal with the internal fear of not knowing. For myself, I don't fear not knowing, I thrill in it. That admission of not knowing provides me with the purpose of rising in the morning, to possibly resolve another small piece of not knowing into another small piece of knowing.
    How other could 'men of the mind' exist?
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by CircuitGuy 13 years, 2 months ago
    I agree the universe looks engineered to me. Scientifically, though, I know this is the anthropic principle.

    To argue the universe is engineered b/c it rings true would be argument from personal incredulity, i.e. arguing that everything that is real must be something that I could imagine and have ring true.

    I don't see any solid evidence of conscious engineering behind the universe.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by $ 13 years, 2 months ago
      I agree with what you're saying. I just find it hard to overlook the mechanics and scope of things like this. Sure, my mind is grasping for understanding and in its absence could be making sense of things.

      Consider the astronomical odds of man even existing in the universe - all the very remote possibilities that had to line up perfectly to bring about mankind (and that's not even talking about a planet to sustain man, the other animals, or any animal being sentient).

      I always have found this a staggering example of the improbability of our existence.
      http://www.stumbleupon.com/su/1k0CXS/htw...
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
      • Posted by CircuitGuy 13 years, 2 months ago
        I like that power's of 10 presentation.

        If everything weren't just perfect for us, though, we wouldn't be here to comment on it. So only a universe with things just right for intelligence to evolve would have creatures asking how things were just perfect.

        A universe that appeared by chance, though, does not ring true at all to me. If I were to argue that this means it's not true, it would be argument from incredulity. Nevertheless, a universe that developed without an intelligent architect does not ring true to me.
        Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
        • Posted by $ 13 years, 2 months ago
          Even the placement of our planet from our sun is perfect...there is just too many coincidences for me to believe its all random luck of the draw x1000, x10000, x100000. :)

          I also, think that life is not unique to Earth. My next book kinda dances with this subject. Its taking a long while to get my science and facts organized. It should be fun. :)
          Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
          • Posted by CircuitGuy 13 years, 2 months ago
            Anthropic principle. What do you think of that two-word counter-argument? An answer to that question might be more appropriate for your next book, though, not a message.
            Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
            • Posted by $ 13 years, 2 months ago
              Loaded question. :) If my mothballed memory on this is accurate there are many things that make up the Anthropic Principal. If we're talking about the assumption that human life is a condition and we use out limited knowledge about life (based on our own experiences) to define how we search for life in the Universe and beyond then I think it is flawed.

              Surely human life COULD be the basis for existence everywhere. God could have a number of well spaced petri dishes out there cultivating societies for whatever reason's God has (Childhoods End - Arthur Clarke). But until such time we can be sure we have to keep a diverse eye open for any microbe that will validate the belief that life is in fact out there.

              Incidentally, while touching on this subject, my coming book has a different direction. :)
              Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Wonky 13 years, 2 months ago
    Difficult and challenging. I appreciate your courage in posting this.

    My apologies for interjecting this, but I have to make fun of myself or risk taking my posts too seriously. When I "string together generally unrelated things and events spread over a long periods of time", it usually ends up being a word salad. Kudos to you for your talent at coherent writing.

    I love juicy analogies, anecdotes, metaphors, and parables. The "likeness" of different things is always intriguing to me. Take, for instance, the fact that gravity and electromagnetism act inversely proportionally to the square of the distance between matter. It practically begs for a "Unified Field Theory", and many great minds have spent enormous amounts of time seeking such a theory.

    Analogies are helpful in explaining things that are alike, but they are not necessarily objective proof of a relationship between those things. Even so, they can be seductive, beautiful sirens, or fun and uplifting conversation, or even profoundly insightful.

    I bring up analogies because I'm an Athiest man married to a Christian woman, the best way I have found to bridge the gaps is by utilizing analogies. Interestingly, the values that we live by (hard work, productivity, trading value for value, recognizing that we must help ourselves before others in the event that we choose to help others, making and conceding to well formulated rational arguments, etc.), while derived by different means, overlap considerably. My wife respects my translation of "God" as "the essence of man" and I respect her translation of "the essence of man" as "God", and we are forthright about our translations. Neither of us is Altruistic, but we are, at times, generous to a fault. We agree, in principle, that there is no value in helping people who do not want to help themselves and repay the debt (teach a man to fish in exchange for some of the fish he catches), but we do occasionally help people without any expectation of payment.

    In the 20 years we've been together, no precise, shared definition of God has ever been essential to get along or to love one another. A precise, shared definition of a dollar, however, is essential (the same goes for an inch, a pound, a minute, etc.). In essence, therefore, she (Christian) and I (Objectivist Athiest) don't find that a specific definition of God is necessary to our quality of life.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Mark 13 years, 2 months ago
    Great to hear from you. I appreciate the tension that provokes deeper thinking and good conversation. I would love you hear your thoughts about The Soul of Atlas, published this year. The subtitle is "Ayn Rand, Christianity, a Quest for Common Ground." I am the author and I write about the fathers who shaped my life: my Objectivist stepfather and Christian biological father challenged me equally.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by gblaze47 13 years, 2 months ago
    I'm totally with you, Most of my background is in Physics and Molecular biology, many years before I came to Christ. I found the the deeper into the science I went the more it looked like 'confirmation bias' on many levels.
    For instance Dr Duncan MacDougall's experiment to measure the 'weight' of the human soul. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duncan_MacD...
    No one could disprove what he discovered but attacked his methodology as being suspect. This goes along with my belief there is to much 'confirmation bias' going on in science today. If a study doesn't give confirmation to what they believe the outcome should be, it must be wrong.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Comment hidden by post owner or admin, or due to low comment or member score. View Comment
  • Posted by flanap 13 years, 2 months ago
    I have always explained to my siblings in Christ that Ayn Rand came as close to Christianity's objective for thinking in that we should not allow emotion or perception to guide our thinking, but facts.

    The question, and what separates believers in Christ from Objectivists, is what those facts are.

    The Bible is truth and reveals God. That is not perception, but reality, regardless of man's ability, external to the Bible, to rationally conclude that. To what source can you point or refer to that is a higher authority than the Bible to prove it wrong? None.

    AJAshinoff - what you are stating and revealing is that God has placed in His creation design that we cannot ignore and when we suppress the fact, not perception, that nature (nature meaning not manipulated by man to his ends) appears created, it is because it is created.

    Man has since his creation by God sought to push down the fact that he is created and accountable to God in the end. God has so generously, through His love, sought to communicate to us, first directly by various media, then upon the completion of His Word, His plan and purpose for man with revelation of the end of human history as it will rest with Him.

    Some day you will realize that the Intelligent Designer is the God of the Bible. Concerning whether He is the Intelligent Designor, I would say that if nature is designed (and man being part of that nature), then man is designed and the Designor has a purpose and has communicated that purpose directly, then indirectly through men selected for that purpose, to the end being His will.

    I have over and over made the case in this forum, without much rebuttal of any substance, that if you believe that the highest value, to the Objectivist, is man's ability to reason and what he values is what should be most important to him, then I would say that there is absolutely no absolutes in that state since you are not using any external criteria, developed outside of man, to judge those developed values against concerning right or wrong. Some may say this is the C.S. Lewis morality argument for the existance of God and perhaps that was where he was going with it; but I have developed this external to that argument since man cannot function without rules that are interminable and immutable, developed outside of himself.

    Thanks for posting your thoughts...they are some of the more genuine and original I have read this forum in a long time.

    Oh...as a side note, if your reference to predestination is in the context of reformed theology, I am not of the reformed theological camp although I go to a 5 point Calvinist church. The fact is that predestination is simply a destiny planned in advance, which frankly redundant since a destiny is always developed ahead of one heading there. God's destining man for a particular end doesn't mean God makes man go that direction. Same as Abraham was the father of the Jews, but Abraham had to respond to God, else God would have selected someone else. God is much bigger than some predeterministic dictator who cannot handle creature who have limited free will (limited meaning simply there are some things we cannot do like make a A not A at the same time). I have learned that God to the reformed theologians is in a box of decrees where his foreknowledge isn't even necessary.

    I have yet to ever get an answer that made any sense to the question: if God decrees everything and no true free will exists in His creatures, then doesn't He also decree sin? This of course is blasphemous, but they cannot get around it. Additionally, if God is doing it all, then why does He punish me for sinnering as a His child? Why doesn't he force me to be His child in the first place?

    Reformed theology is a tightly packaged system that is frankly heretical and should be thrown out completely since it requires redefining the defined and manipulation of the Bible to fit a system vs the Bible speaking for itself using a literal hermeneutic.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  

FORMATTING HELP

  • Comment hidden. Undo