I agree again with AJ. With the opinion on reducing the power of the state, yes, but control of borders must be one of the last to go. In Australia, it is worse- that advice is given by the government not just red/green volunteers. The earth has millions of poor uneducated people, striving to improve and who want to work. But we do not them in, we allow in the plump who can pay for smugglers and know the ropes for immigration lawyers, then they bring in family members, all often end up on welfare.
Society as defined by practicality. First societies were based on need, individual banding together for safety and surety, they needed rules (laws). I agree the fedgov needs a comeuppance, a reminder that defines who they hell they work for. But those feeding off it need to be weaned and sent packing as well. They violated our law and bypassed the multitude who are waiting lawfully to enter our society.
Well I looked up the definition of society to be sure, but you don't have to have a common law to be part of a society. It's just extremely common. In any case if I have a friend in another country who wants to move into my house, I dislike the idea of the government denying him access because there is a waiting line or he doesn't want to work here. Now I'm not saying they shouldn't screen him, I think that everyone should be screened citizen or not. We should definitely secure the borders to prevent unknown elements from entering or leaving. I'd suggest that we should attack the sponge instead of those feeding off of it. Immigration wouldn't be an issue if they couldn't take anything from you they didn't trade for. Agreed?
I was born and raised in NY. I celebrate ethic diversity as a cornerstone of the American experience and something that strengthens this Nation. I've known people of a wide variety of ethnic backgrounds all of my life (including my time in the Navy where I traveled overseas a bit) and never thought to deny anyone the chance to live in the US and experience the certainty I've always known. That said, we have laws for immigration and they must be obeyed by all who seek to enter.
The Republic which comprises the United States of America is just that - the people of those States empower their local government to act on their behalf. In being part of the larger country each State give the federal government a certain amount of its issued authority to act on its peoples behalf. Power is derived from the people. A governor IS as important or even more important that the President of the United States (or should be).
Objectivist- the individual is paramount. Therefore the bit of control the individual gives up to participate in the society he/she chooses to be in matters. A person, an Objectivist, must have accurate representation to provide value for what authority he/she relinquished as a member of society. A major function of any government is to define and defend private property. A State/Country's private property is its borders. Borders are kept to define where the society's laws can be applied. If we allow people to come here without following our process, our laws, then we essentially scrap everything we trusted the government on every level. Our individual Objectivist "trust or confidence" is not earned and should be revoked.
A society is a grouping of people based on common law. Said laws are the constant measure by which a person can function within a society with confidence. A sovereign nation has a lawful right to its borders as a responsibility to its people. The Constitution is quite clear. Our government, instead of applying existing laws created an unlawful welfare state that is now behaving rabidly and in some cases violently entitled - the ultimate moocher.
You considered leaving America but never did...and then you chase that comment with an attack on khalling's decision to do so. And so what if a lot of people are doing that? If they have the means and the desire then they should leave and take their business and money with them! Leaving the country speaks volumes. Good Grief!
"I occasionally vote Up and rarely vote Down, but typically take credit or blame, either way. " MM, show a comment where you are accused of voting a certain way that you did not. I have up voted every one of your comments on this post and others I wished to discuss. Only if you used argument tactics that were meant to discredit did I ever ding you. As to your last statement, we have not abandoned the US. First of all, the US govt is one of two countries that ensures that cannot happen if we want to retain citizenship. I am a US citizen. Leaving is an historically effective method of getting the attention of the country and politicians.
Rule of law doesn't have to go hand in hand with National sovereignty. A quote, "when you violate the rights of one man you violate the rights of men everywhere," comes to mind.
It is why I do not approve of voting here. I occasionally vote Up and rarely vote Down, but typically take credit or blame, either way.
As for the fact that some here disagree with you, you have to live with that. We all do.
More deeply, allow me to suggest that you should check your premises. Objectivists are not conservatives. Personally, I have considered leaving America, but never did it. However, I understand those who have. You find a lot of consonace with khalling, but you must be aware of the fact that D & K Halling are expatriots who have abandoned the USA to its own demise to save themselves. A lot of people are doing that.
Allan, we have different perspectives on this, I trust because of our different life experiences.
I grew up in Cleveland, Ohio, and learned to speak enough of several languages to get past the parents of my classmates when calling on the phone. In my home, we occasionally received a Hungarian newspaper printed locally, as others were published for the Germans, Poles, and other groups. (In German classes, the teachers made fun of Beobachter und Anzeiger for its bad grammar.) Not in our neighborhood per se, but in others, stores often had signs in foreign languages to cater to their ethnicities. In my neighborhood, we did have a Hungarian language movie house, which later went over to Spanish. Eventually the church I was baptized in was renamed San Miguel. A block or two away was St. Elias, the Lebanese Catholic church and St. Matthew an Evangelisches Luthern Kirche, which, actually, is where I took Bible School Classes in the summer, oddly enough.
We had a cultural division in Cleveland, also, between the old immigrants and the new "DPs" the displaced persons. The newbies did not want to become Americans. They were only hanging out here until the fall of communism and the liberation of the old country, so they could go home. Their children - my classmates and cohort - felt differently, of course.
All you have done is to complain about immigrants, as the second-to-last have always complained about the last to arrive.
The Pennsylvania Dutch called the newbies "Johnny Cheese": Yankees.
In the silent movie "Wings" about pilots in World War I, the Irish recruiting sergeant tells aviation mechanic Arnold Schwimpf, "If you ask me, all you Dutchmen ought to be locked up until this thing is over."
For us to agree - if that is even possible - we need to find a common set of basic assumptions.
One of yours that I do not share is that as the Representative of the People the State owns the Nation. I can see that as an artifact of conservative ideology, but it is not Objectivist. An Objectivist argument would be based on individual rights.
AJ, first, I am sorry for your sister. My good thoughts are headed her way. I live south of the border and I wanted to provide a different perspective. second. I'm with Brewer on this. New Deal -game changer. Land borders are tricky. Especially between 1st world nations and 2nd and 3rd world nations. To ignore this would be irrational. Case in point France's struggles with Muslim immigrant camps and neighborhoods, crime and riot levels. third. Many who head to the states apply the same thinking they have survived generations in their own country doing to the US. Namely, 10 families own most of the wealth in their country. The laws are very old, very onerous, very punitive. Upshot, do not rock a boat. Who is President, who is law enforcement is a stacked game. They have been raised to lay low under the radar, so to speak to get by. Why would they not apply those same tactics when they go to the US? Should they trust the US President? Local law enforcement? The most important driver in a corrupt culture is for good citizens to lay low. You read that as deceit and rightly so, maybe, in our culture. Lately, maybe not. I am not saying some aren't laughing behind our backs. I am not saying criminals are not in the US illegally. There are criminals from other countries in every country, most likely. I am saying, am surrounded by wonderful neighbors, who are very spiritual and family oriented and want a good life. To be honest, many of them have tried to make it in the US only to come back here. Finding a new country if your resources are meager is a difficult thing to do. Try to keep in mind the culture of corruption in other countries (heck, you see it in your own) and imagine how people respond. Finally, it is easy for many who do not live in communities that are pulled down by illegal invasions to cry racism! xenophobia! Hospitals, crime rates, school systems are war zones in border areas. It is polly anna talk to suggest bring your tired, your poor, your hungry without a plan in today's US, especially in a welfare state which we now are. This is not our grandparent's America.
The issue isn't immigration. Its people flooding into the country whenever they wish and hiding in plain sight. They live outside the law and use the system to line their pockets. When they do something horrendous (like get into an accident and almost kill someone (my sister)) they are slapped on the hand by sympathetic Hispanic police officers and then flee the country before anything can happen to them.
I have issue with unlawful immigration. If people cannot abide by our laws then they do not belong in our society.
Last I checked Mexico isn't at war. As for the financial woes, that's their governments responsibility to fix - they've had ample support from the US and the world bank AND an influx in business. Still their quality of life goes down - not our problem.
Please remember I live on the border with Mexico and have seen this problem first hand and felt its impact in my family(theft, murder, attempted murder, maiming, threats of violence, gunfire, mail fraud, etc).
Analogy You have a home. You go out for a weekend trip only to come home and find a family living in your house. You tell them to leave. They refuse. You call the cops. The cops say they don't have to leave. These people take up space in your home, use your resources (food, water, electric, etc.), and even send their kids off to school with your children on the school bus that stops in front of your house. They use your car. They tie up your telephone. They watch your television. They use your credit card to buy things. They take whatever money they can find in your home and send it to the rest of their family living elsewhere.
A Soverign nation has the right to limit who and how many people come into the country. Our ancestors came here legally, with permission AND took great pride in becoming American citizens. ENTIRE neighborhoods near where I live have Spanish only signs on all the stores. There is no desire to become American, only to sponge off the system.
No, every single illegal and their children who are under 18 should be deported. There are ample people legitimately trying to enter this country who have waited far too long to get here. I will agree with you the technology of the immigration process need be streamlined for those legitimately trying to enter the US.
So, the people who fled Hungary after the failure of the 1956 revolt, they are criminals to be prosecuted? The refugees from the civil war in Syria should be shot by Turkish militias before they can cross the border? The Boat People of Vietnam?
Anyone who is dissatisfied with their life someplace else should be welcomed here. America prospers when they do.
The radical capitalist solution is to privatize immigration and get the government out of it.
When my grandparents came here - and likely yours, too - passports did not exist. Your grandparents and mine just showed up and here they were.
What changed, was, indeed, the law, and the law is wrong. According to US Military protocol, no flag flies higher than the American flag, except the Chaplain's flag when services are being held. That shows that our government is subject to a Higher Moral Law. The secular, mundane laws on immigration are wrong and it is moral to evade them.
It doesn't matter to me...he or she is part of the problem with this country. If we cannot determine who is allowed into our society then we cease to have a society.
To the lemming point taker, consider: A society is a collection of people who have come into agreement to live under a set of laws/rules they can agree on. The land they occupy is the dominion of their laws and their culture. If a person enters the country illegally their first act in this society if to violate the law. Hiding in plain sight they deceive with their identity and lie about who they are. THEY DO NOT NEED HELP LYING OR DECEIVING.
With the opinion on reducing the power of the state, yes, but control of borders must be one of the last to go.
In Australia, it is worse- that advice is given by the government not just red/green volunteers.
The earth has millions of poor uneducated people, striving to improve and who want to work. But we do not them in, we allow in the plump who can pay for smugglers and know the ropes for immigration lawyers, then they bring in family members, all often end up on welfare.
Now I'm not saying they shouldn't screen him, I think that everyone should be screened citizen or not. We should definitely secure the borders to prevent unknown elements from entering or leaving.
I'd suggest that we should attack the sponge instead of those feeding off of it. Immigration wouldn't be an issue if they couldn't take anything from you they didn't trade for. Agreed?
The Republic which comprises the United States of America is just that - the people of those States empower their local government to act on their behalf. In being part of the larger country each State give the federal government a certain amount of its issued authority to act on its peoples behalf. Power is derived from the people. A governor IS as important or even more important that the President of the United States (or should be).
Objectivist- the individual is paramount. Therefore the bit of control the individual gives up to participate in the society he/she chooses to be in matters. A person, an Objectivist, must have accurate representation to provide value for what authority he/she relinquished as a member of society. A major function of any government is to define and defend private property. A State/Country's private property is its borders. Borders are kept to define where the society's laws can be applied. If we allow people to come here without following our process, our laws, then we essentially scrap everything we trusted the government on every level. Our individual Objectivist "trust or confidence" is not earned and should be revoked.
Its not the first time that I'd feel like a stranger in my own land.
As for the fact that some here disagree with you, you have to live with that. We all do.
More deeply, allow me to suggest that you should check your premises. Objectivists are not conservatives. Personally, I have considered leaving America, but never did it. However, I understand those who have. You find a lot of consonace with khalling, but you must be aware of the fact that D & K Halling are expatriots who have abandoned the USA to its own demise to save themselves. A lot of people are doing that.
I grew up in Cleveland, Ohio, and learned to speak enough of several languages to get past the parents of my classmates when calling on the phone. In my home, we occasionally received a Hungarian newspaper printed locally, as others were published for the Germans, Poles, and other groups. (In German classes, the teachers made fun of Beobachter und Anzeiger for its bad grammar.) Not in our neighborhood per se, but in others, stores often had signs in foreign languages to cater to their ethnicities. In my neighborhood, we did have a Hungarian language movie house, which later went over to Spanish. Eventually the church I was baptized in was renamed San Miguel. A block or two away was St. Elias, the Lebanese Catholic church and St. Matthew an Evangelisches Luthern Kirche, which, actually, is where I took Bible School Classes in the summer, oddly enough.
We had a cultural division in Cleveland, also, between the old immigrants and the new "DPs" the displaced persons. The newbies did not want to become Americans. They were only hanging out here until the fall of communism and the liberation of the old country, so they could go home. Their children - my classmates and cohort - felt differently, of course.
All you have done is to complain about immigrants, as the second-to-last have always complained about the last to arrive.
The Pennsylvania Dutch called the newbies "Johnny Cheese": Yankees.
In the silent movie "Wings" about pilots in World War I, the Irish recruiting sergeant tells aviation mechanic Arnold Schwimpf, "If you ask me, all you Dutchmen ought to be locked up until this thing is over."
For us to agree - if that is even possible - we need to find a common set of basic assumptions.
One of yours that I do not share is that as the Representative of the People the State owns the Nation. I can see that as an artifact of conservative ideology, but it is not Objectivist. An Objectivist argument would be based on individual rights.
I live south of the border and I wanted to provide a different perspective. second. I'm with Brewer on this. New Deal -game changer. Land borders are tricky. Especially between 1st world nations and 2nd and 3rd world nations. To ignore this would be irrational. Case in point France's struggles with Muslim immigrant camps and neighborhoods, crime and riot levels. third. Many who head to the states apply the same thinking they have survived generations in their own country doing to the US. Namely, 10 families own most of the wealth in their country. The laws are very old, very onerous, very punitive. Upshot, do not rock a boat. Who is President, who is law enforcement is a stacked game. They have been raised to lay low under the radar, so to speak to get by. Why would they not apply those same tactics when they go to the US? Should they trust the US President? Local law enforcement? The most important driver in a corrupt culture is for good citizens to lay low. You read that as deceit and rightly so, maybe, in our culture. Lately, maybe not. I am not saying some aren't laughing behind our backs. I am not saying criminals are not in the US illegally. There are criminals from other countries in every country, most likely. I am saying, am surrounded by wonderful neighbors, who are very spiritual and family oriented and want a good life. To be honest, many of them have tried to make it in the US only to come back here. Finding a new country if your resources are meager is a difficult thing to do. Try to keep in mind the culture of corruption in other countries (heck, you see it in your own) and imagine how people respond. Finally, it is easy for many who do not live in communities that are pulled down by illegal invasions to cry racism! xenophobia! Hospitals, crime rates, school systems are war zones in border areas. It is polly anna talk to suggest bring your tired, your poor, your hungry without a plan in today's US, especially in a welfare state which we now are. This is not our grandparent's America.
I have issue with unlawful immigration. If people cannot abide by our laws then they do not belong in our society.
Please remember I live on the border with Mexico and have seen this problem first hand and felt its impact in my family(theft, murder, attempted murder, maiming, threats of violence, gunfire, mail fraud, etc).
Analogy
You have a home. You go out for a weekend trip only to come home and find a family living in your house. You tell them to leave. They refuse. You call the cops. The cops say they don't have to leave. These people take up space in your home, use your resources (food, water, electric, etc.), and even send their kids off to school with your children on the school bus that stops in front of your house. They use your car. They tie up your telephone. They watch your television. They use your credit card to buy things. They take whatever money they can find in your home and send it to the rest of their family living elsewhere.
A Soverign nation has the right to limit who and how many people come into the country. Our ancestors came here legally, with permission AND took great pride in becoming American citizens. ENTIRE neighborhoods near where I live have Spanish only signs on all the stores. There is no desire to become American, only to sponge off the system.
No, every single illegal and their children who are under 18 should be deported. There are ample people legitimately trying to enter this country who have waited far too long to get here. I will agree with you the technology of the immigration process need be streamlined for those legitimately trying to enter the US.
Even so WE determine who and how many.
Welcome to Arizona.
Anyone who is dissatisfied with their life someplace else should be welcomed here. America prospers when they do.
The radical capitalist solution is to privatize immigration and get the government out of it.
When my grandparents came here - and likely yours, too - passports did not exist. Your grandparents and mine just showed up and here they were.
What changed, was, indeed, the law, and the law is wrong. According to US Military protocol, no flag flies higher than the American flag, except the Chaplain's flag when services are being held. That shows that our government is subject to a Higher Moral Law. The secular, mundane laws on immigration are wrong and it is moral to evade them.
To the lemming point taker, consider: A society is a collection of people who have come into agreement to live under a set of laws/rules they can agree on. The land they occupy is the dominion of their laws and their culture. If a person enters the country illegally their first act in this society if to violate the law. Hiding in plain sight they deceive with their identity and lie about who they are. THEY DO NOT NEED HELP LYING OR DECEIVING.
Take another point.