Is innocent until proven guilty too much to give?

Posted by $ AJAshinoff 13 years, 3 months ago to Culture
12 comments | Share | Best of... | Flag

I had a very dull but slightly interesting time serving jury duty last thrusday. Sat through the entire morning reading my kindle waiting to be called. I ended up called to a panel at about 1:15 and was lead to a courtoom with 49 other people.

The defendant was a young black male roughly between 20-25 years old. His neck and arm were littered with tattoo's. He also had two tear drops tattoo's beside his left eye.

This man was accused of assault and robbery of another man who was in a hotel room with a woman. It was stated that the woman knew the defendant and helped the defendant and another man target the man assaulted and robbed.

I was recused from jury duty for financial reasons (self-employed and had jobs requiring my attention).

Before I was recused the judge read us all a list of questiona and made several statements about hwo we, as jurors, are supposed to approach this civic responability. One that stuck in my throat was the ability to look at this man without any preconceived notions of his guilt of innocence. Yes, I could be objective and fair as the facts of the case are presented to make a judgement. However, I would be lying to say that I immediately did not look at this man and presume a degree of guilt. My reasons: 1) the police wouldn't arrest and bring to trial a man by accident. Sure a mistake could have been made but I would think its pretty rare. 2) the posture of the guy as he slumped in his seat like king shit of the ghetto and, perhaps most imporatnatly 3) the tear drop tattoo's on his cheek next to his eye.

For those who don't know, the tear drops beside the eye, I've been told, represent people this man has killed - not a nice guy.

Would you be able to start this guy with a clean slate?


Add Comment

FORMATTING HELP

All Comments Hide marked as read Mark all as read

  • Posted by LetsShrug 13 years, 3 months ago
    I too would've noticed all 3 points (especially the tear drops) and figured he was more likely guilty than innocent, but I also know I would be fair and honest with the evidence presented. It's not about him having a clean slate, it's about whether or not he committed the crime he's being accused of and if they prove it beyond a reasonable doubt.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by j_IR1776wg 13 years, 3 months ago
    "I was recused from jury duty for financial reasons (self-employed and had jobs requiring my attention). "

    What about the other jurors?
    So only the "little people" Serve on jury duty?
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Rozar 13 years, 3 months ago
    I don't think there is anything wrong with judging someone by the way they look. The human brain is wired to see patterns, even some that aren't really there, but these patterns have the potential to save our lives. But the thing to remember is that you're not part of this persons culture, it's possible he got the tattoos because he needed to fit in with his peers or risk being abused for the rest of his youth. If I saw that man I'd do what I could to keep my distance from him until I had a better insight to his real character. But there is nothing wrong with innocent until proven guilty. You have to take a look at the facts and let them decide.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ rockymountainpirate 13 years, 3 months ago
    I have been in a similar situation as an investigator. Federal RICO case. I had to review the video of a murder and listen to hours of recorded interrogation by fed & local cops. The suspect was the gang elder at 21, because he hadn't yet died of all the times he'd been shot. My conclusion after many hours of listening, watching, repeating listening and watching. This guy is guilty of murder, just not THIS murder. That's where I think you have to go, the facts of the case in front of you only.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ 13 years, 3 months ago
    "more likely guilty than innocent" this is exactly what bothered me. I'm a strict constitutionalist. I vehemently believe in the Constitution as the bedrock of American society. I honestly thought that I could be blind to what's in front of me when in a jury situation - until I was confronted with one.

    "I would trust my ability to sift facts from fiction.." I have no doubt in my ability to do the same. The issue I had is with initial innocence until proven guilty. I cannot say with 100% certainty that his demeanor, his markings and what those markings meant, and the fact that he, at one point, proudly had those markings put on his body, didn't reduce my 100% intial presumption of innocence to say 75% or 50%. That bugged me.

    I can honestly say though that if he were white or hispanic and had the same tattoos and the same demeanor I would have felt the same way.

    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Rocky_Road 13 years, 3 months ago
    Not my slate.

    The key question would be how you would answer his defense attorney as to whether, or not, you could sit in the jury box without any prejudices against his client?

    I would trust my ability to sift facts from fiction, and claim that I could give him a pass before hearing the evidence.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by CircuitGuy 13 years, 3 months ago
    #1: The police might have accused him b/c they needed a certain number of arrests. Someone else may have planted seeds in their mind or out-and-out asked them to accuse him w/o evidence.
    #2: I could not ignore if I got the sense he thought he was king $hit based on his posture. That would prejudice me against him.
    #3: I'm not knowledgeable about teardrop tattoos, so that wouldn't affect me. If I found out they do me he's saying he has killed people, that would seriously prejudice me against him.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ MikeMarotta 13 years, 3 months ago
    (Having some interface problems here. This might be a duplicate post. (Also, just saw the duplicates and deleted them; might take a couple of minutes...))

    Having just finished "Shadows Live Under Seashells" I am surprised that you accept the Administration so readily. Maybe it is something in your drinking water (:-).

    In 2007 I completed an associate's degree with high honors in criminal justice. In 2008, I graduated summa cum laude with a bachelor of science in criminology administration. I earned my master of arts in social science in 2010 with core studies in criminology.

    Based on the numbers for wrongful convictions of murder and sexual assault overturned with DNA evidence largely with help from the Innocence project, extrapolating to all crimes, it is an easy guess that right now 84,000 FACTUALLY innocent people are sitting in prison.

    The police arrest innocent people all the time. The have to clear cases, make arrests, look busy. If they catch someone at one crime, they will offer plea bargains in which the accused confesses to other crimes as well. The accused is legally innocent and/or factually innocent of those other crimes.

    In about 85% of cases, the victim and the perpetrator know each other. What blows up into an arrest began much earlier with an escalating series of confrontations over minutes, hours, or even years. The "victim" is often just the last person hurt before the police are called.

    On one of the Objectivist boards a "libertarian realist" (read "racist") challenged the readers. You are walking down a dark alley. Who are you going to be more afraid of, a young black man or an old white woman. The easy answer was "the young black man." My reply was to ask why he would not be afraid of YOU? What are you doing in the alley? What is an old white woman doing in an alley? She could easily be impaired, homeless, erratic. The kid could be coming form the library for all you know. And for myself, I would not be in alley in a strange neighborhood unless I were prepared for an encounter.

    A thousand years ago, some of us were in the woods one night at a city park, padding about lord knows why when we heard voices in the distance. We froze, afraid. The guy who was most outside the box turned to us and said with scorn, "And why would they not be afraid of our voices?"

    My point is that we all give in to our fears and prejudices too easily.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  

FORMATTING HELP

  • Comment hidden. Undo