So lets eliminate the police, the military and the government. Lets hope that everyone is as responsible and thoughtful as you and I are with their conduct?
That was total crap! The officer never told the guy why he was being pulled over, or detained, and later said that the kid was innocent and knew his constitutional rights! I'm glad the guy resisted, politely the whole time, never was agitated, or rude or otherwise verbally antagonized the cop. That dog was led to the door and window. Oh, I am chilled after seeing that. So much for the whole no unlawful search and seizures!
The driver was trying to provoke a negative response and he succeeded. Unfortunately, most police are not trained to respond positively to people who in their opinion are acting "smartass." The officer is spending his holiday on a DUI stop and most likely wants to detain as few cars as possible because he doesn't want to be bothered or do the paperwork. It becomes a pissing contest and most cops are not going to let this guy get the upper hand. You don't have to be a great student of human nature to understand what is happening. If you use the Constitution as a battering ram, be prepared to put up with greater retribution.
Let's turn this around. Take the wanna-be lawyer out of this.
Let's say that "Juan" pulls up to the officer. Juan is not drunk, doesn't smell like alcohol, rolls down his window, but doesn't speak English very well.
Officer asks him if he has been drinking, but Juan doesn't understand the question and hands him his driver's license issued in Sonora, MX. Truck he is driving has California plates.
So... impeding my privacy is okay when there is NO cause for suspicion and it's for my own safety? (Driving on a holiday is not cause for suspicion. I drive EVERY day.)
He was not being a jerk and he was not being hostile! He was exercising his rights. "Normal operation"... really?? This seems 'normal' to you? It' seems 'hostile' to me.
General warrants are specifically outlawed by the Constitution and violate innocent until proven guilty. It is inherently a collectivist idea based on fear and control. It's based on a statistical likelihood, which is the hallmark of tyranny. Tyranny is a REAL threat. Tyranny has killed over 200 million in the last century.
I grew up in a jerkwater northern Minnesota Iron Range town with 3 grocery stores, 32 bars, and 3 indian reservations. I know what it looks like when 50% of the people on the road are too drunk to crawl, let alone drive.
I'm assuming you are a youngster that doesn't remember what it looked like in the 70's & 80's before the drunk driving laws came into effect. It was pretty bad.
I do not doubt it. People are sick and tired of being treated as criminals before proven innocent. This man was subjected to more scrutiny than illegal aliens. He might have been charged with disobeying an officer. Officers do not have the right to demand obedience from everyone. They must prove probable cause and get a warrant from an independent judiciary before searching the vehicle. but the Constitution has been trashed. Freedom to travel is a fundamental right and the initial reason for the Commerce Clause. This is the problem I have with Conservatives. You don not seem to be for freedom. and by limited government , you only mean fiscal. You don't want a welfare state, but you're ok with a police state. That's how it seems. where do you draw the line, AJ?
the principle is the same. Preemptive action. Your firearm could harm me. There was no evidence the driver pulled over at the check-point was drunk as a skunk travelling at 90 mph. Quit presenting a false case. He was randomly pulled over at a check-point.
do you understand natural rights? you do not have the right to monitor everyone's action due to the threat you think they will do something wrong. It is called innocent until proven guilty, and is the basis of a free society. I hear communist China is big into your theory of making sure everyone is doing the "right" thing at all times. "Those who will willingly trade a little liberty for a little security, get neither and deserve neither."
Not exactly true. The "cause" was a holiday notorious for drinking and accidents. "Checking" drivers is just a temporary inconvenience. Those who fail sobriety check taken off the road before they can endanger others.
I suspect this was some kind of training video. I posted a reply to someone else where I found an article from 2011 or 2012 that used the same exact video to make its discussion.
I'm not sure why you're giving me props. A checkpoint is a temporary inconvenience for a specific thing. We live and function in a society. There are portions of society who are not very responsible for their behavior. My being delayed 5-10 minutes, to me, out-weighs the trouble of catching one drunk driver who may very well kill someone else because their are too stubborn to admit to themselves that they couldn't drive.
How is innocent until proven guilty trampled when checkpoints are telegraphed on the web and on TV well before they are established?
Life is full of inherent risk. To grant the govt broad authority in the name of safety has given you ....the TSA, Homeland Security and local police driving MRAPs. Thank you for supporting that
Actually there are so many loopholes in entrapment almost never found by courts anymore. But, it should be the right of every citizen -even celebrated -to test that the government functions within its limits. If more people did that maybe we wouldn 't be facing such blatant ignoring of our rights.
Previous comments... You are currently on page 4.
Let's say that "Juan" pulls up to the officer. Juan is not drunk, doesn't smell like alcohol, rolls down his window, but doesn't speak English very well.
Officer asks him if he has been drinking, but Juan doesn't understand the question and hands him his driver's license issued in Sonora, MX. Truck he is driving has California plates.
What should the officer do?
Checkpoints stop everyone, which is constitutional. "Random" checks are profiling, which is not.
Just because you don't like it, doesn't mean it isn't the law of the land.
Do you have a drinking problem? You seem a little over defensive about a perfectly avoidable crime.
I'm assuming you are a youngster that doesn't remember what it looked like in the 70's & 80's before the drunk driving laws came into effect. It was pretty bad.
"Those who will willingly trade a little liberty for a little security, get neither and deserve neither."
July 4th weekend is the deadliest time on the road
http://www.foxbusiness.com/personal-fina...
How is innocent until proven guilty trampled when checkpoints are telegraphed on the web and on TV well before they are established?
And no, I live in the west, a "democrat" here is far more conservative than a republican on the east coast.
Load more comments...