Solving the National Language Problem KISS works it's miracle.
First of all the overwhelming majority speak English and the bulk of the documents, laws etc. are in English and English is the world for economics, banking, aircraft operations, ship piloting and maritime operations etc.
So divide the country into groups
1. Citizens and long time residents who speak a. English b. English and one other language. c. No English but one or more other languages.
2. Residents coming into the couontry on a work permit, immigration program something of that nature.
English number one, Spanish Number two the rest are negligible but valuable.
Methods of attacking the problem. Public schools, public schools with night classes, private schools, enlightened schools such as Berlitz Total Immersion. All the rest are stone age lump them together.
Who? Fact of life it doesn't take a language major to teacha language. It does take someone fluent in a particular langauge.
Illiterates need not apply.
The rest will sort itself out and initially perhaps with a little funding for a year or two .
Next the goals.
Everyone speaks two languages with no exceptions except those over 80 or here temporarily.
TheGovernment will not hire anyone nor accept in to the military ayone who isn't bi-lingual. That's the stick and the carrot.
Next Rule. No citizenship without complete fluency in English and one other language.
No one passes 8th grade without some foreign language training, 12th grade without at least a level two fluency a foriegn language and Level three proficiency in English. Any university degree with out a level five in English and level four in at least one foreign language.
Public schools will not be allowed to teach any subject whatsoever until the new student has gone through the English language course. Loss of credentials and public funding is the punishment. Doing their job for a change is the reward.
Now thinking I've short changed the Latinos guess which language is a. most prevalent in the western hemsiphere and b. easiest to learn. SPANISH! hint hint.
So here's Johnny Dimwit who can't get in the Army without a foreign langage and geater than valley girl grasp of what passes for English. Does he choolse Portuguese? Maybe, italian Maybe,French Maybe Russian No Chinese No. Mongolian Hell no.
But the other students will and probably some of them speak a foreign language coming into the country, English in preparation or upon arrival and then do a third and many will have three or four from the get go.
The homies have to learn English as a foreign language and back to Spanish. as the easiest one.
the unfair part but that's not my problem is the original citizens will be behind the eight ball But not draftable? No. The Army takes them they go to language school period. No pass discharged.
the other ha ha unfair part is the foreign students will zoom to the top of the pack.
The advantage is we reduce the national language need to what it truly IS Mostly English with a helluva lot of Spanish.
what do you think they will teach in Mexico or Canada? Same thing they teach now Spanish and English or Canadian and English.
That's a fracking joke.
Berlitz schools take one week for easy languages up to Russian and twoweeks for exceptionally difficult language using total immersion. The concept is simpile. Monday morning you walk in a fully furnished apartment and the teachers start rotating in. Only the subject langugae is allowed. By Saturday evening 2,000 word vocabulary comprehension speaking, reading and writing.
Where do you get the instructors? Language Departments of any college and all those educated people immigrating in country. Another blow for Spanish as the second choice.
by the way....in the westeren hemisphere HALF the world there are three major languages . Spanish, English, Portuguese.
In the other continents they number from a hundred or so to as many as a hundred iin one country. Count your blessings it's an easy fix and a great melting pot and that's the real problem. Those who want diversity to divide and control will be against it. those who want to honor the ethnic cultures and backgrounds of the world will enjoy the lerning experience of the North American Culture. If we can find where we put it.
So divide the country into groups
1. Citizens and long time residents who speak a. English b. English and one other language. c. No English but one or more other languages.
2. Residents coming into the couontry on a work permit, immigration program something of that nature.
English number one, Spanish Number two the rest are negligible but valuable.
Methods of attacking the problem. Public schools, public schools with night classes, private schools, enlightened schools such as Berlitz Total Immersion. All the rest are stone age lump them together.
Who? Fact of life it doesn't take a language major to teacha language. It does take someone fluent in a particular langauge.
Illiterates need not apply.
The rest will sort itself out and initially perhaps with a little funding for a year or two .
Next the goals.
Everyone speaks two languages with no exceptions except those over 80 or here temporarily.
TheGovernment will not hire anyone nor accept in to the military ayone who isn't bi-lingual. That's the stick and the carrot.
Next Rule. No citizenship without complete fluency in English and one other language.
No one passes 8th grade without some foreign language training, 12th grade without at least a level two fluency a foriegn language and Level three proficiency in English. Any university degree with out a level five in English and level four in at least one foreign language.
Public schools will not be allowed to teach any subject whatsoever until the new student has gone through the English language course. Loss of credentials and public funding is the punishment. Doing their job for a change is the reward.
Now thinking I've short changed the Latinos guess which language is a. most prevalent in the western hemsiphere and b. easiest to learn. SPANISH! hint hint.
So here's Johnny Dimwit who can't get in the Army without a foreign langage and geater than valley girl grasp of what passes for English. Does he choolse Portuguese? Maybe, italian Maybe,French Maybe Russian No Chinese No. Mongolian Hell no.
But the other students will and probably some of them speak a foreign language coming into the country, English in preparation or upon arrival and then do a third and many will have three or four from the get go.
The homies have to learn English as a foreign language and back to Spanish. as the easiest one.
the unfair part but that's not my problem is the original citizens will be behind the eight ball But not draftable? No. The Army takes them they go to language school period. No pass discharged.
the other ha ha unfair part is the foreign students will zoom to the top of the pack.
The advantage is we reduce the national language need to what it truly IS Mostly English with a helluva lot of Spanish.
what do you think they will teach in Mexico or Canada? Same thing they teach now Spanish and English or Canadian and English.
That's a fracking joke.
Berlitz schools take one week for easy languages up to Russian and twoweeks for exceptionally difficult language using total immersion. The concept is simpile. Monday morning you walk in a fully furnished apartment and the teachers start rotating in. Only the subject langugae is allowed. By Saturday evening 2,000 word vocabulary comprehension speaking, reading and writing.
Where do you get the instructors? Language Departments of any college and all those educated people immigrating in country. Another blow for Spanish as the second choice.
by the way....in the westeren hemisphere HALF the world there are three major languages . Spanish, English, Portuguese.
In the other continents they number from a hundred or so to as many as a hundred iin one country. Count your blessings it's an easy fix and a great melting pot and that's the real problem. Those who want diversity to divide and control will be against it. those who want to honor the ethnic cultures and backgrounds of the world will enjoy the lerning experience of the North American Culture. If we can find where we put it.
Previous comments... You are currently on page 2.
The way solved that is refusing to answer up to anything but English.When i went to anothere couontry it was a point of pride to be able to speak with the natives in their language. Jack in the Crack in San Diego I did my reverse dumb gringo act and order only in English. And was thanked for helping them learn some more.
One. Spending money on schools that don't teach and students who don't learn is a waste and time. This gets the leeches off the back of the taxpayers. Wasting time and money I am certain it does exactly the opposite. Let's quit wasting money and if the schools insist on continuing then put the money to use somewhere else.
Requirement? Only if you want government money or government jobs. There is no real penalty for self imposing stupidity. Only for the new people if they want citzenship. It's already a requirement anyway.
The proposition? 60 plus percent of the population with 25% of the population even if by only providing the opportunity. The rest of the population moved here already bi- or tri-lingual and are aleady qualified.that should scare the blue jeans off the couch potatoes . Are you going to sing ethe same song in 2040 t 2050 when Spanish is projected to be the majority language? Try Google there were too man cites and sources to list them all.
How could possibly be more waste ful than the Education Department under Obama? Well you could be working for Obamacare.
Official takes a vote or procalamation of government. Other than the requirement for all documents to be in English I fail to see any evidence of official. You first sentence is something you made up? Now why would you do something like that? What treaty by what name and where's the source and cite? Treaty with who? That is a contact between nations. PR is not a nation. Guam and Samoa speak Chamorro and the Phillippines chose to make English and official language along with Tagalog.
Your last sentence is currently in use. Sort of leaves you figuring out how to get to first base when it's under your feet.
What exemptions would be automatically provided?
What exemptions would be considered upon application?
Rather depends on the people operating the government at the time. Thinking of religion and government service, Quakers and George Washington they sat down together and figured out what would make two opposing positions work. Then there is the fascist way as you mentioned. But not being a leftist it doesn' t much appeal to me.
At first glance to me the punishment is self imposed by the end of the sentence of refusal. Self limitation to be a second or third rater comes to mind. Not my problem. The problem belongs to the refuser. So does the guilt and the punishment. Moochers No :Looters no but certainly a class apart. How about Barbies.
Argentine is distinctive because of the y and ll sound and because of voseo (use of the word vos) Other countries like El Salvador have voseo, but I really notice it in Argentines.
That's cool that someone could tell you were foreign but couldn't tell your native language.
But people learn other languages for their own reasons without a government plan. I don't get all the fuss. Whenever I travel I get a basic phrase book to listen on my phone. It doesn't take a gov't plan to know that's a good idea.
I realize that in today's world we have to be careful to not hurt their feelings. So the old treaties get interpreted to say things they never intended.
Based on this post and the domination of a few individuals, I am leaving this site.
Learning Spanish makes sense for residents of states with a significant Hispanic population, but learning any other language should be situation-dependent.
Load more comments...