Does California law currently allow adoptive parents to be listed as mother or father on the birth certificate? For example, suppose we have a heterosexual couple in which the man is sterile, but his wife is not, and they decide to have a child using a sperm donor. In this situation, who would be listed as the father on the birth certificate? The wife's husband, or the man who provided the sperm? If we allow the wife's husband to be listed as the father, even though the child is not genetically his, then could we not also do the same in this situation? The article even says that the space for the father can be left blank, which indicates that the purpose of the birth certificate is not necessarily intended to track genetic lineage. In other words, it shouldn't matter whether the parents listed are actually the genetic parents of the child or not.
Sorry, listing two men or two women on the BIRTH certificate is WRONG. It is impossible for a man or woman to have a child without the other's participation (directly or indirectly through someone else). Two men will never create a child between them. Two women will never create life between them. Always an egg or sperm is needed in same sex couples to make life happen.
Think of the kid instead of selfishly thinking of one's self. This is a shamefully narcissistic attempt to desensitize society starting with a helpless child.
I do not think you are actually correct. Dolly was cloned from a somatic cell. I would hypothesize that two women having a child that is genetically theirs will happen soon, and that two men will have a child...say...within the next decade. They may have to have an egg-donor for the extranuclear material - to provide mitochondria, but the nuclear DNA would be theirs. As with Dolly, the cells in question do not even have to be ova and spermatocytes, they could be somatic cells. It is even plausible for a man to carry an embryo to term and have it delivered by Caesarian.
I notice you conveniently neglected to address the questions I raised. Does California law allow for a birth certificate to list the name of an adoptive parent in place of a genetic one? If so, then how is this any different?
I am not in CA, I do not know if their certificate lists adoptive parents.
This is Common Core.
It is situations like this that evoke my angst. If you're gay there are some things you cannot have. The RIGHT to be listed as a BIRTH parent on a newborns certificate (Unless you actually took part in the birth) is something either nature or a choice has denied. Does this mean homosexuals shouldn't adopt? No. But don't make sh*t up just to make you feel good at an innocents expense.
In not in CA, its not my fight. If it comes here I fight this tooth and nail.
Homosexuals shouldn't adopt. Neither should schizophrenics.
This whole battle of insanity is the result of allowing the perverts (progressives) to blow out of all rational proportion one word of the DoI: equal.
When the Founding Fathers used equal in the DoI, they were referring to social class, nothing else. And yet the progressives are using it reductio ad absurdum, except they're not trying to show how ridiculous universal equality is, but to use universal equality as a tool to destroy existing cultures to pave the way for their socialist hell.
If one projects the course of these absurdities into the future, there *will* come a time when the progressives will argue for the equal rights of trees (after all, we're alive and they're alive, therefore we're "equal").
A man wanting a woman is NOT the same as a man wanting a man, even though both are sexual 'wants'. It takes incredible mental gymnastics to equate homosexual sexual desire with the natural mating instincts of healthy men and women.
To paraphrase Robert A. Heinlein; is man a mammalian species or not?
Now Maph, in his insanity, will try to point to exceptions in order to pretend that, in fact, there is no "natural" mating instinct among mammals. And of course once I point out the nature and function of the mammalian reproductive organs and practices, he'll try to point to sterility or other instances which don't result in offspring, as if every time a woman has a period, she's turned into an equivalent sexual pervert because her body once again failed to get pregnant.
As I'll interminably have to keep pointing out, a male, or female, who wishes to assume the role of the opposite sex, a male, or female, romantically and/or sexually attracted to members of the same sex, or children, or animals, or inanimate objects has a problem. The problem lies within him/her, NOT with society. Whether it's because of mental/emotional trauma, or a wiring mistake in his/her brain, or because of genetic mistakes made during gestation, the problem isn't society's intolerance.
Refusal to call a tail a leg isn't intolerance; one can tolerate an insanity without embracing and thereby accepting it.
Its an analogy. I mentioned common core because it contains and thrusts upon young minds revisionist history, just like this is trying to revise what should be natural for any human born - a accurate birth certificate. To write in that two men or two women are the natural parents of any child is an absolute lie (even if one did in fact carry the child or donate the sperm). There is absolutely NO NEED except vanity or political correctness to place to same sex parents on anyone's birth certificate.
Think of the kid instead of selfishly thinking of one's self. This is a shamefully narcissistic attempt to desensitize society starting with a helpless child.
Jan
It's symbolic of his struggle with reality...
Oh, and by the way, never say "never."
http://abcnews.go.com/Health/Technology/...
This is Common Core.
It is situations like this that evoke my angst. If you're gay there are some things you cannot have. The RIGHT to be listed as a BIRTH parent on a newborns certificate (Unless you actually took part in the birth) is something either nature or a choice has denied. Does this mean homosexuals shouldn't adopt? No. But don't make sh*t up just to make you feel good at an innocents expense.
In not in CA, its not my fight. If it comes here I fight this tooth and nail.
This whole battle of insanity is the result of allowing the perverts (progressives) to blow out of all rational proportion one word of the DoI: equal.
When the Founding Fathers used equal in the DoI, they were referring to social class, nothing else. And yet the progressives are using it reductio ad absurdum, except they're not trying to show how ridiculous universal equality is, but to use universal equality as a tool to destroy existing cultures to pave the way for their socialist hell.
If one projects the course of these absurdities into the future, there *will* come a time when the progressives will argue for the equal rights of trees (after all, we're alive and they're alive, therefore we're "equal").
A man wanting a woman is NOT the same as a man wanting a man, even though both are sexual 'wants'. It takes incredible mental gymnastics to equate homosexual sexual desire with the natural mating instincts of healthy men and women.
To paraphrase Robert A. Heinlein; is man a mammalian species or not?
Now Maph, in his insanity, will try to point to exceptions in order to pretend that, in fact, there is no "natural" mating instinct among mammals. And of course once I point out the nature and function of the mammalian reproductive organs and practices, he'll try to point to sterility or other instances which don't result in offspring, as if every time a woman has a period, she's turned into an equivalent sexual pervert because her body once again failed to get pregnant.
As I'll interminably have to keep pointing out, a male, or female, who wishes to assume the role of the opposite sex, a male, or female, romantically and/or sexually attracted to members of the same sex, or children, or animals, or inanimate objects has a problem. The problem lies within him/her, NOT with society. Whether it's because of mental/emotional trauma, or a wiring mistake in his/her brain, or because of genetic mistakes made during gestation, the problem isn't society's intolerance.
Refusal to call a tail a leg isn't intolerance; one can tolerate an insanity without embracing and thereby accepting it.
The rest of what I said is dependent upon whether or not adoptive parents can be legally listed on a birth certificate.