The problem with any such study is that every individual is different. Of my 3 children, physical punishment was necessary and effective with one, the other two (females by the way) were more effectively disciplined with "time out".
Kittyhawk. You are correct in your conclusion that dogs and humans are different species, and react differently to punishment, physical or otherwise. I would never encourage physical punishment for a dog. As Cesar has shown many times over, the focus of the unwanted behavior needs to be shifted, thus, training via rewards and affection. If that approach is tried with an unruly child, its called permissive parenting. I'd venture a guess that the student in the video had never been disciplined, effectively, thus his child-like behavior of tantrums continues into early adulthood. Like I said, reality and society will now have to correct his lack of early training.
So, one side is supposed to "live and let live" while the other works to restrict freedoms, slander folks (or at least call them "sinful) and work the legislators to enact their desires.
Just sit back and take it. Do you feel no frustration?
Someone holding and expressing an opinion that you don't like is not initiating force against you. They are not "way out of bounds" or attacking you by merely thinking differently than you or others, and saying so. The alternative to freedom of speech and freedom of expression is to have some kind of "thought police" who punish and censor unpopular beliefs -- which would be a grave threat to freedom. At some point, your own "unpopular beliefs" are sure to get you in trouble under such a system. It's better to live and let live rather than regarding differing opinions as "attacks," and to grant all the freedom to express his/her own viewpoint even if others disagree.
I love the Cesar reference. I think he has a lot of wisdom for dealing with problem pets -- and problem people. But dogs and humans are different species, and I've seen no facts (only anecdotal assertions) demonstrating that physical punishment of children encourages long term morality or self-control. Hitting children does have a very short term effect (10 minutes) on discouraging unwanted behavior, but only as long as they think the punisher is watching. I'd venture a guess that someone that out-of-control had in fact been physically disciplined, and that it caused or contributed to his problems.
Here's an interesting article on "spanking" and physical discipline. Scroll down to the Research section, which begins, "In 2012, the Canadian Medical Journal Association (CMJA) published an analysis of over 80 studies documenting the effects of corporal punishment on children. Not one, not a single one, found any positive long-term effect and the list detailing the short and long-term consequences would concern anyone invested in public health." Read more at http://www.philly.com/philly/blogs/birth...
Why do some people want to run the lives of other people?
The kid freaked out because a fundamental freedom of his (self pleasuring or being gay) is being attacked.
Granted his expression was over the top, but can't folks around here understand that someone who wants to tell others not to jerk off is way out of bounds?
Why do you justify his childish behavior on those two? Maybe he was freaked out because his fundamental freedom to steal or to prevaricate was "attacked"? Maybe, being a leftist militant homosexual who plays with himself, he LIKES lying to the people he steals from?
May I restate the sign in a fashion you might be able to understand?
"Actions have consequences".
The sign didn't tell anyone NOT to do anything; the sign said that those actions will have consequences on judgment day. If you're not a Christian, it's a meaningless sign. If you are a Christian, you still have a choice to quit masturbating, lying, thieving and sodomizing or go to hell. The sign leaves it up to you to make 'an informed choice' as certain people like to say.
That pious bastard is well within his rights to peacefully display his convictions (I'm sure he get got permission, maybe even paid something, to be on that campus too) just as leftists and atheists regularly do regularly on college campus' and in public - yet, no pious bastards go berserk despite their nauseating canned rhetoric. Nut-boy comes near me or any of mine in a harmful way (I"m local to him) and he gets put down after his first growl. Everyone here in Phoenix should know his name. Jackasses like him, crazy or not, are a danger and its a public service to let everyone know (while he gets help).
No, AJ, this guy is seriously disturbed. More humility, shame and shunning could well push him over the edge. They'll may well post his name after he comes back and shoot that pious bastard.
Yah, perhaps so. Today the Kool-Aid is so strong, it's not like anything l used to make some roughly 60 years ago. Today the Kool-Aid can tear apart families. My wife is now torn apart from her three sisters and even her dad.
I can attest to that. You'd be shocked at the hate mail I've received over the years as well as the anger confront simply for standing on the side of the road (without even a sign) to counter-protest.
He is a product of the times, the key phrase was "Its offensive" to justify his actions. What was really freaky, beside his feral screams, was his bleating once he stayed back. I wish they would post the kids name..a dose of humility, shame, and shunning would do him well.
I hate to see it. I fear he is a product of the times... Absolutely. I hope he gets some help. We must all learn to master our passions or they will master us.
is not the same thing
as publicly voicing an opinion.
"works to restrict freedoms" is what government regulation does.
I would never encourage physical punishment for a dog. As Cesar has shown many times over, the focus of the unwanted behavior needs to be shifted, thus, training via rewards and affection.
If that approach is tried with an unruly child, its called permissive parenting. I'd venture a guess that the student in the video had never been disciplined, effectively, thus his child-like behavior of tantrums continues into early adulthood. Like I said, reality and society will now have to correct his lack of early training.
Just sit back and take it. Do you feel no frustration?
Here's an interesting article on "spanking" and physical discipline. Scroll down to the Research section, which begins, "In 2012, the Canadian Medical Journal Association (CMJA) published an analysis of over 80 studies documenting the effects of corporal punishment on children. Not one, not a single one, found any positive long-term effect and the list detailing the short and long-term consequences would concern anyone invested in public health."
Read more at http://www.philly.com/philly/blogs/birth...
The kid freaked out because a fundamental freedom of his (self pleasuring or being gay) is being attacked.
Granted his expression was over the top, but can't folks around here understand that someone who wants to tell others not to jerk off is way out of bounds?
May I restate the sign in a fashion you might be able to understand?
"Actions have consequences".
The sign didn't tell anyone NOT to do anything; the sign said that those actions will have consequences on judgment day. If you're not a Christian, it's a meaningless sign. If you are a Christian, you still have a choice to quit masturbating, lying, thieving and sodomizing or go to hell. The sign leaves it up to you to make 'an informed choice' as certain people like to say.
Remember this one?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WwuP7ILX3...
Enjoy!
O.A.
Load more comments...