The "God is Dead" Problem - Nietzsche to Marx to Rand
I've seen posts from time to time which express a desire for more philosophical content in the Gulch and not just news clips on the antics of the Ruling Class.
I just had a realization I would like to share.
Rand also might have stated this explicitly, but it's been a while since I've read her essays, so...
I believe what we are seeing from the Left today is their solution to Nietzsche observation that "God is Dead."
Many people quote this and do so out of context. Nietzsche didn't just say that "God is dead", but that *we* killed him. Despite those who might quote him out of context, he did not necessarily look at this as a "good thing", but instead as the crux of an impending deep societal problem. He was, in a poetic fashion, trying to point out: since a major portion of society has moved beyond looking to religion as relevant to their daily lives, they have also unknowingly removed the cornerstone of their society's accepted morals and values. What then?
He was right to question this: as each society modernizes they face this similar crisis.
I believe what we are seeing in the US and the world today (and also in the recent past) is the Left attempting to fill Nietzsche's predicted absence of moral cornerstone with the "ethics" of Marx.
It is why they rail against religion.
It is also why they demonize, marginalize, and purge non-Marxists with religious terms and tactics; e.g. guilt, sin, shame, and evil.
It is also why so much of Neo-Marxism relies on faith, e.g. "Forward!"
It is also why the Left tries to smear Objectivism as a cult.
The Left realizes on some level, that Objectivism also seeks to provide a moral cornerstone, one which is the opposite of Marxism.
So, if these are the stakes, we must make sure that we don't make the Left's mistake and appeal to urges of religion.
Reason must not become faith.
Your comments are welcome.
I just had a realization I would like to share.
Rand also might have stated this explicitly, but it's been a while since I've read her essays, so...
I believe what we are seeing from the Left today is their solution to Nietzsche observation that "God is Dead."
Many people quote this and do so out of context. Nietzsche didn't just say that "God is dead", but that *we* killed him. Despite those who might quote him out of context, he did not necessarily look at this as a "good thing", but instead as the crux of an impending deep societal problem. He was, in a poetic fashion, trying to point out: since a major portion of society has moved beyond looking to religion as relevant to their daily lives, they have also unknowingly removed the cornerstone of their society's accepted morals and values. What then?
He was right to question this: as each society modernizes they face this similar crisis.
I believe what we are seeing in the US and the world today (and also in the recent past) is the Left attempting to fill Nietzsche's predicted absence of moral cornerstone with the "ethics" of Marx.
It is why they rail against religion.
It is also why they demonize, marginalize, and purge non-Marxists with religious terms and tactics; e.g. guilt, sin, shame, and evil.
It is also why so much of Neo-Marxism relies on faith, e.g. "Forward!"
It is also why the Left tries to smear Objectivism as a cult.
The Left realizes on some level, that Objectivism also seeks to provide a moral cornerstone, one which is the opposite of Marxism.
So, if these are the stakes, we must make sure that we don't make the Left's mistake and appeal to urges of religion.
Reason must not become faith.
Your comments are welcome.
1. Follow up on the suggestion from Eudaimonia discussing, or present a negative case, that Objectivism in based on on reason.
2. An elaboration of your stance, perhaps with examples of- What bad stuff Ayn Rand did to you, or if you want to not be in it as an individual- the bad personal behavior of Ayn Rand that invalidates Objectivism.
Please start one.
Please start one.
What a philosophy purports and what its adherents actually do are two different things.
No one has mentioned that there are many on the right who call Objectivism a cult centered on the persona and opinions of Ayn Rand rather than reason.
It is ironic that the Left calls Objectivism, a philosophy that purports to be based on reason and so opens itself up to all reasonable critiques, a cult. It is the Left that is a cult, not because it abandons religion but because of its religious, evidence-denying faith in the most deadly institution in history--government. The left has all the hallmarks of cultism--tribalism, emotionalism, ritualistic behavior, brutal supression of opposing points of view, and denunciation and violence directed towards non-believers.
Just some quick thoughts on the matter, thank you for sharing yours :)