Am I a ... looter?!

Posted by $ jbrenner 11 years, 11 months ago to The Gulch: General
39 comments | Share | Best of... | Flag


I routinely buy used lab equipment items on EBay and LabX, repair them, and use them for research and teaching at Florida Tech. I routinely make significant improvements on existing technologies by using such old lab equipment as a starting point. Unlike Galt, I have not invented “out of seamless cloth”, meaning that I read the open and patent literature and build off of ideas that others have demonstrated. Yet my ideas and inventions are certainly substantial enough improvements that they are worthy of their own patents. Does this make me a looter? I certainly don’t think so, and I don’t feel the least bit guilty about being a vulture when it comes to other people’s soon-to-be-discarded lab equipment. Most of it is not even supported by their manufacturers anymore.

I have been a professor for almost 16 years at Florida Tech in chemical engineering, materials science and engineering, and as of this year, biomedical engineering. Florida Tech is a private, non-tenure-granting university. The faculty here either prefer it that way, or at least realize that, if they work up to their own high standards, the tenure system would be irrelevant anyway. Besides perhaps Hillsdale College, the closest one will find to the Patrick Henry University is Florida Institute of Technology, also known as Florida Tech. I have found my ideal Shrug job.

Florida Tech has about 3000 on campus students and about the same number at our graduate sites at about ten military bases and space center sites (with apologies to true Rand followers). It is primarily an engineering college, with excellent colleges of science and psychology, and solid programs in business and aviation for future Galts, D'Anconias, Taggarts, Danneskjoelds, Reardens, etc. Florida Tech just made it into Tier 1 (the top 150 universities in the U.S.). Florida Tech is the youngest university in Tier 1, is the fastest growing university in the U.S. in Tier 1 (about 30% in the last two years overall and doubled enrollment in my departments in that time), and is the 3rd fastest growing university in the U.S. overall. There are better places to go to graduate school, but I would put our undergrads up against anyone's.

My primary focus has been developing a nanotechnology minor program that has more credits of lab than any others I have seen. I have funded that program and my research with about $100 K from my own pocket, purchasing items on EBay and LabX, and either getting them working myself or having students do it with me. I was able to afford to take this professorship with a slightly lower than average salary because of my investments I made in the 1990s during the dot.com boom. I am willing to take the slightly lower salary because I am more or less autonomous and not persecuted for not bringing in government grants like I would be elsewhere. I avoid government grants more than any faculty member you will meet (although I have not been perfect in this regard). All such government grants were before I read Atlas Shrugged. Since I read the book, I have either self-funded or worked with industrial partners. At Florida Tech, if I bring in research contracts and can't publish for propietary reasons, that is acceptable (unlike the publish or perish elsewhere). In addition to the traditional research grants and contracts, we have a branch called Florida Tech Consulting for which you can pay only a 15% overhead rate for my (and perhaps my group's services) while keeping the intellectual property (IP) for your company.

At the risk of seeming un-Galt-like, having put $100 K into my university (primarily my own research group's work) myself, I do not apologize for asking for equipment or financial donations to support future Galts. Whereas some people donate to “charity”, I put that portion of my “charity” into my own research group’s enterprise, which is definitely Galt-like. Equipment donations are solicited in the areas of chemical, biomedical, mechanical, aerospace, electrical, and materials engineering, particularly nanotechnology and materials characterization equipment, in EXCHANGE for a) a tax deduction (so as to not feed the looters), b) the training of future Galts, and c) usage of all the materials synthesis and characterization facilities that I control on an as-needed, prompt basis (whether by you or by one of my students). We also do materials characterization on a per sample (or batch) basis for a reasonable fee.

I see myself as like Quentin Daniels, John Galt's assistant from the Utah Institute of Technology. I have been a partner in two startup companies, including one started in someone's two story garage to build a plasma arc reactor similar to Mr. Fusion from the Back to the Future movies for the DeLorean. The equivalent to Mr. Fusion was invented by Dr. Albin Czernichowski, born in the 50's in Poland and emigrated to France after Poland was liberated. He is as close to John Galt as I likely will ever meet. My job was to build the process upstream and downstream of his reactor. The other company I helped start up (as a minor partner and VP for Sensor Development) made an alternate to the EPT pregnancy test kit before we got swallowed up by EPT. One of those positions would have been my life’s work in a Galtish world, but my current position as professor is my “shrug job”, even though I work as hard and smart as anyone I know.

I've spent time on just about every side of the energy business from solar to oil to hydrogen to biofuels, specializing in applications of porous materials and nanoparticles such as a) catalysis for crude oil upgrading; b) hydrogen storage and purification (with apologies because part of that job was to supply tritium for nuclear bombs before I read Atlas Shrugged); b) Au and CdSe nanoparticles for biomedical imaging; c) tissue scaffolding generated from 1) electrospinning (the conventional way); 2) 3D printing; and even 3) a modified cotton candy maker; and finally d) biosensors for detecting whether a woman is pregnant (before being bought out by EPT to stay off the market) and recently for detecting biomarkers of Alzheimer's disease and shortly for detecting specific types of cancer cells.

If your kids are looking for this era's Patrick Henry University, e-mail me or call me at Florida Tech, where for a reasonable price at a private university, I will be glad to mentor future John Galts in nanotechnology, the field John Galt would have been in now had Atlas Shrugged been written today.

If you want on my e-mail list that advertises chemical, biomedical, aerospace, and mechanical engineering jobs posted on LinkedIn or in the east central Florida area, as well as nanotech, biomedical engineering, materials science, and 3D printing news, shoot me an e-mail and expect e-mail from jbrenner@fit.edu.

If you or your son/daughter chooses to come to Florida Tech (also known as Florida Institute of Technology, or FIT), please notify me for $1000 off of your tuition per year by my referral.

Educating future Galts,
Prof. Jim Brenner
Florida Tech Chemical and
Biomedical Engineering Departments
Chair, Nanotechnology Minor Program
150 West University Blvd.
256 Olin Engineering Bldg.
Melbourne, FL 32901
jbrenner@fit.edu, jb012767@aol.com
http://my.fit.edu/~jbrenner
321-749-3437




Add Comment

FORMATTING HELP

All Comments Hide marked as read Mark all as read

  • Posted by $ MikeMarotta 11 years, 11 months ago
    Thanks, Jim! You surely are not a looter. Your essay identifies the problems with much intellectual property law. Objectivists have debated these for decades, trying to establish a sound basis for them and then a just implementation of those principles. See my post here in the Gulch on "Confusion in a Muddle."
    http://www.galtsgulchonline.com/posts/af...
    and also "Objective Intellectual Property Rights" here
    http://www.galtsgulchonline.com/posts/11...

    More to the point, I cannot imagine anyone here accusing of you being a looter. In Roark's "Courtroom Speech" Rand identified the fact that we inherit the products of the minds of others and then build on them from our own thinking. If I saw Henry Ford riding about in his homemade car and then figured that I could build one, too, the product of that effort is my own. The problem here in The Gulch is that not everyone has a consistent or deep understanding of Objectivism.

    The fallacy might be called "innocence by association." I believe X. I enjoyed _Atlas Shrugged_. Therefore X is consistent with Objectivism. Among the many problems are attempting to find philosophical principles in fiction. Rand was clear in her writing, but not everyone is clear in their reading. _Atlas_ was dramatic fiction. Galt was drawn as having invented _de novo_ but clearly he learned a lot of physics first and then was given a laboratory in hopes that he could use it.




    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by $ 11 years, 11 months ago
      Thanks, Mike. Prior to becoming a professor and long before I read AS and the Fountainehead, I could see myself turning into a Robert Stadler. I have been consistent with AS since reading it. However, I now have a past that I am no longer proud of like I used to be.

      Ironically I had read We the Living as a teenager.
      I got the obvious about the perils of communism, but at the time, I didn't understand its full impact on America. Perhaps that is because when Reagan was president, we were not yet a socialist/Communist country. I was 2 months too young to vote for Reagan in 1984, and thus I have gone my whole life without someone to vote for president who actually had a chance of winning.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by ObjectiveAnalyst 11 years, 11 months ago
    Hello jbrenner,
    You are no looter. There are many passages in Rand's work where it is clear many of us are doing what we can in a world not of our own making. As you have discovered, it is about making changes in the right direction as you recognize them. We can only do what is within our power. I very much enjoyed reading your story. Keep up the good work.
    Regards,
    O.A.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by $ 11 years, 11 months ago
      Well, at least I am no longer a looter. I would consider myself one before reading AS. I have read many informative comments from you, too, O.A.

      You are, of course, correct in what you said.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Comment hidden by post owner or admin, or due to low comment or member score. View Comment
  • Posted by Robbie53024 11 years, 11 months ago
    I'm not sure why you would even ask the question. Looting is taking something not owed, and generally by force - either your own or via government action. You are doing none of these things. If you provide value (as defined by the willing and voluntary actions of your customers - be they students or clients) then you cannot be looting.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by $ 11 years, 11 months ago
      Let's just say that I worked in government labs for long enough before reading Atlas Shrugged, including with a radioactive isotope of hydrogen for our nation's nuclear stockpile, that I still feel unclean. Someone offered me absolution earlier. I felt like I was in a teleconfessional.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by j_IR1776wg 11 years, 11 months ago
    As for being a looter, the only legitimate functions of our government are a police force, a military force, and a system of courts. Anything beyond these i.e. Department of Education, by definition is property theft by government from individuals for transfer to other individuals. This makes any of us who take that money are looters. I am collecting a pension from NJ from my time teaching IT. Ergo, I am a looter and so are you.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by $ MikeMarotta 11 years, 11 months ago
      Give up that unearned guilt! If you are in a mixed economy, you have to accept the context. It would be perfectly moral to work for the government at something that private suppliers would do in a laissez-faire economy, such as music teacher or forest ranger. It remains immoral to work for the government at something that no one should do, such as tax collector... and yet, I knew a libertarian in a state tax agency who said, "Better me than someone who would actually enforce the laws..."
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
      • Posted by $ 11 years, 11 months ago
        It may not seem like it, but I am capable of giving up unearned guilt quite easily. The problem for me is that I earned this guilt (albeit pre-Atlas Shrugged) fair and square. I was a government scientist for 4 years before I got into a job that I was morally (in the objectivist sense) OK with! It's not like a boat anchor, but more like a scar. You know it's there.
        Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
        • Posted by Zenphamy 11 years, 11 months ago
          Scars are a sign of success in life - you're still alive and you escaped. As you learned your science and then how to apply it, you've also learned Objectivism and then how to apply that. I just hope that you're able to pass some of that along to students so that they might not have to carry the same scars.

          Good luck with the non-government grants and research and thank you for taking your Objectivism so much to heart.
          Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
          • Posted by $ 11 years, 11 months ago
            Thanks. That's pretty accurate. I have passed along such knowledge, and they DO appreciate it. I wouldn't be surprised if people think that I have a huge guilt complex after posting "Am I ... a looter"? I don't feel guilt at all. Feelings are for looters and moochers, or as Worf the Klingon once said, "Humans maybe". I do realize that I made some mistakes in my past prior to reading Atlas Shrugged. Now it's time to get back to grading papers for a bunch of future producers (who are trading me money for knowledge ... or in some cases, their parents are). I really have landed in my own little Galtish paradise. Tomorrow is our last day of interviewing 19 really sharp faculty candidates for six positions in biomedical, mechanical, and aerospace engineering. The new Patrick Henry University (Florida Tech) is growing faster than a weed!
            Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by $ 11 years, 11 months ago
      At this point, I can legitimately say that I was a looter, but have not been so in several years unless you argue that my students' loans pay for my salary. I work for a private, non-tenure-granting university. We do not get pensions or have unions.

      I have taken no government handouts (research dollars) in several years, since I read Atlas Shrugged.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
      • Posted by j_IR1776wg 11 years, 11 months ago
        Jim I did not know that our government and unions would allow any school to exist free of their control. This is indeed heartening. I withdraw my identification of looter as it concerns you.
        Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
        • Posted by $ 11 years, 11 months ago
          Not only is Florida Tech not tenure granting and non-unionized, but suggestions regarding unionization have been shot down by > 80:20 margins a couple of times in our faculty senate. We like being non-union.
          Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
        • Posted by $ 11 years, 11 months ago
          Florida Tech is a great place to work. We just reached the top 200 in the world and are the youngest school to be so ranked. I couldn't ask for a better shrug job, but I had better start grading some exams lest I blow my cover as having shrugged. I am actually hiding in plain sight.
          Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by j_IR1776wg 11 years, 11 months ago
    Jim have you kept up with the research done in Ohio on getting heat out of coal without combustion? Did the pilot plant actually start up in 2013? http://www.osu.edu/features/2013/ohio-st...
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by $ 11 years, 11 months ago
      I am unaware if the DOE Alabama plant took off. A similar plant in Bartow, FL and an addon to an existing clean coal plant in Orlando, FL were part of the Obama stimulus package and never opened. How fitting. That was when I got out of the energy business and went into nanobiotech.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by $ 11 years, 11 months ago
      I was unaware of Ohio State's work. They use a plasma arc (or torch) to ionize the coal. We used a plasma arc to convert a variety of hydrocarbon feedstocks into syngas (a mixture of CO and hydrogen) and ultimately chemicals. Making syngas was a breakeven business until the shale boom; now natural gas prices make what I did with Florida Syngas a moneyloser. Making chemicals from the syngas we could make a 20% profit. When TARP happened, we sold our business to Topline Energy Systems. That was the unofficial start of my shrug. The guy who invented the plasma arc reactor (Albin Czernichowski) was as close to John Galt as I will ever likely know. I designed the preprocessing of the fuel and all the rest of the technology other than the plasma arc reactor, so that we could make it into a profitable business. Hence, I call myself Quentin Daniels, Galt's assistant.

      This one hits close enough to home that it stings a little still.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  

FORMATTING HELP

  • Comment hidden. Undo