lol... I didn't mean this commercial was pushing electric cars I just meant in general they're hyped up too much for what they really are. I liked the commercial...just not the plug bit. That kind of put a damper on the whole thing for me. Like they can't just have a purely good commercial they have to throw in a little enviro-crap too. A hint of liberalism on the sneak. Speakin' of which, where's my bumper sticker?
Yes, my methodology was a bit flawed. It's an adaptation of the methodology I used in buying the Cobalt over the Toyota Prius I saw on the same lot with similar mileage. Unfortunately the new to new comparison cannot be done as GM canceled the Cobalt in favor of the new Cruze. I was speaking just of my situation. Were I to do a modern comparison it would be the new Leaf vs. the $11,900 Versa.
I admit though, being a moderate hypermiler I get 42.7 avg mpg out of a car only rated at 37 HWY, so I be stacking the deck a little bit in my favor.
Pushed? Is sales that's what sale is = pushing a product (any product). The whole idea that they have a viable electric luxury vehicle was the entire point of the message that underscored that Americans work hard to get the best and/or most cool stuff. I wasn't really trying to discuss the merits of electric vehicles. I was trying more to show how a commercial CAN have a positive American message (unlike the Chevy Tahoe leftist claptrap).
Your point is valid were one comparing new Leaf to new Cobalt. Since you got a cobalt with 30K of wear already on it, it would have been fairer to bring in a 30K Leaf for comparison. Going over to autos.yahoo.com, I see 2011 Leafs around 28K miles for around $15000, meaning the Leaf starts to come out ahead in year 5 based on your "recharges through good thoughts" scenario. A review of the Chevy Cobalt market on the same Yahoo site leads me to believe you really got a smoking good deal on your Cobalt, and you already mentioned you acquired it at an atypical time. I've run the numbers on the Leaf myself, versus my VW Jetta TDI (diesel - 48MPG). I'm not disagreeing with your overall conclusion - just picking on the methodology. I do think the Leaf could make sense for someone who sticks around in the city, assuming they buy it USED. I've never come up with an analysis where the Leaf is a smart buy NEW.
And that's my point... we don't have all that going for electric cars as of yet so why are they being pushed as if they do. And yes...the 'message' was great....right up until he pulled the plug. :)
I like to see American ingenuity, but…. Electric car? It’s more like overgrown electric shaver. For me electric cars are not a fiscally sound deal. I’ll break it down using my personal car and a “good” EV, the Nissan Leaf. 2008 Chevy Cobalt XFE 5 Speed My personal MPG AVG: 42.7 (Yes, I am a moderate hypermiler. It’s a hobby.) Purchase price $7500 with 30,000 miles. I bought it in 09 when they were almost giving away cars. Vs. 2014 Nissan Leaf Base price: $29,830 before whatever the government decides to “give you” I drive right at 20,000 miles a year, so figure $4.00 a gallon for gas at 42.7 mpg. That is $1873.53 a year, plus my $7500 initial purchase. For figuring sake we will say the Leaf is FREE to operate, recharging from sunshine, good thoughts, and Care Bear Stares. 20,000 miles: Cobalt $9.73.53.00 purchase and gas. Leaf: $29,830 purchase 40,000 miles: Cobalt $11,247.06. Leaf: $29,830 60,000 miles: Cobalt $13,120.59. Leaf: $29,830 80,000 miles: Cobalt $14,994.12. Leaf: $29,830 100,000 miles: Cobalt $16,867.65. Leaf: $29,830 120,000 miles: Cobalt $18,741.18. Leaf: $29,830 140,000 miles: Cobalt $20,614.71. Leaf: $29,830 160,000 miles: Cobalt $22,488.24. Leaf: $29,830 180,000 miles: Cobalt $24,361.77. Leaf: $29,830 200,000 miles: Cobalt $26,235.30. Leaf: $29,830
So, I would have to keep this Leaf for over 10 years before it would even begin to possibly save money over my $7500 car, even assuming the Leaf is $0 to operate. Yeah, I’ll pass.
if the solution caused to produce the car and batteries does not exceed the equivalent amount from a gas powered ride over it's life. I'm not sure about the numbers on the amount of pollutants and, frankly I'm not convinced about the whole "man caused disaster" thing either. Is there climate change? perhaps. Was it all caused by man? nooo. One volcano spews a lot more CO2 than my truck, even pulling my camper.
Can man change the path of climate change? no. I don't care how many electric cars we drive as long as most of the world burns wood, oil and coal for heat and electric power. Our output of pollutants per person is much better than it was 40 years ago and that's a good thing. In Mexico, Philippines, India and most of the world everybody else pollutes like it's 1760. Ban cars here, it will NOT change that dynamic as a whole world.
It's like the Volt, with a small gas engine used to put juice into the battery if needed. And yes, it plugs in, if that wasn't clear enough from the ad.
Might also be nice if electric cars actually pollute less cradle to grave (compared to internal combustion) and if the electrical demand doesn't require spending a trillion on infrastructure.
There nothing wrong with electric vehicles. If anyone can make a good electric car that doesn't lack power and can be recharged anywhere quickly and cheaply I have no issue with electric vehicles. The message, Americans work and we read the rewards of our labor - that's what I got out of it.
I liked the commercial...just not the plug bit. That kind of put a damper on the whole thing for me. Like they can't just have a purely good commercial they have to throw in a little enviro-crap too. A hint of liberalism on the sneak. Speakin' of which, where's my bumper sticker?
I admit though, being a moderate hypermiler I get 42.7 avg mpg out of a car only rated at 37 HWY, so I be stacking the deck a little bit in my favor.
http://www.galtsgulchonline.com/posts/36...
And yes...the 'message' was great....right up until he pulled the plug. :)
Electric car? It’s more like overgrown electric shaver. For me electric cars are not a fiscally sound deal. I’ll break it down using my personal car and a “good” EV, the Nissan Leaf.
2008 Chevy Cobalt XFE 5 Speed
My personal MPG AVG: 42.7 (Yes, I am a moderate hypermiler. It’s a hobby.)
Purchase price $7500 with 30,000 miles. I bought it in 09 when they were almost giving away cars.
Vs.
2014 Nissan Leaf
Base price: $29,830 before whatever the government decides to “give you”
I drive right at 20,000 miles a year, so figure $4.00 a gallon for gas at 42.7 mpg. That is $1873.53 a year, plus my $7500 initial purchase.
For figuring sake we will say the Leaf is FREE to operate, recharging from sunshine, good thoughts, and Care Bear Stares.
20,000 miles: Cobalt $9.73.53.00 purchase and gas. Leaf: $29,830 purchase
40,000 miles: Cobalt $11,247.06. Leaf: $29,830
60,000 miles: Cobalt $13,120.59. Leaf: $29,830
80,000 miles: Cobalt $14,994.12. Leaf: $29,830
100,000 miles: Cobalt $16,867.65. Leaf: $29,830
120,000 miles: Cobalt $18,741.18. Leaf: $29,830
140,000 miles: Cobalt $20,614.71. Leaf: $29,830
160,000 miles: Cobalt $22,488.24. Leaf: $29,830
180,000 miles: Cobalt $24,361.77. Leaf: $29,830
200,000 miles: Cobalt $26,235.30. Leaf: $29,830
So, I would have to keep this Leaf for over 10 years before it would even begin to possibly save money over my $7500 car, even assuming the Leaf is $0 to operate. Yeah, I’ll pass.
Can man change the path of climate change? no. I don't care how many electric cars we drive as long as most of the world burns wood, oil and coal for heat and electric power. Our output of pollutants per person is much better than it was 40 years ago and that's a good thing. In Mexico, Philippines, India and most of the world everybody else pollutes like it's 1760. Ban cars here, it will NOT change that dynamic as a whole world.
It's like the Volt, with a small gas engine used to put juice into the battery if needed. And yes, it plugs in, if that wasn't clear enough from the ad.