Progressivism in a nutshell - NAUSEATING
This commercial makes me want to slap the progressive little brat. Yeah, charge them more than what you agreed on because you see they are doing well. Not only wouldn't I pay her the additional $20, I would never call the little thief again.
SOURCE URL: http://youtu.be/DfqKMSRMzq4
:)
The girl was used as a tool in this commercial and the message, to me, was clear: if you have more you should be made to pay more. The little girls extortionism fits nicely in todays LEFTIST society where you eat the rich with a mindset of entitlement. Chevy used her as a Moocher poster child.
"From each according to their ability (Parent),
To each according to their need (girl)."
I ask you: why should MY tax money (the GM bailout) be used to pitch counter-American leftist drivel such as this?
To me the only proper thing to do if this commercials SOCIAL statement chafes you - as it does me- is not buy this vehicle or, if you're so driven (pun intended) any GM vehicle. This is a passive market driven statement back to the manufacturer. My presenting this here is just to show people that GM is peddling their OWS/The rich need to be progressively hit harder because they can afford it, social agenda.
http://www.fool.com/investing/general/20...
"Legally speaking, GM has already repaid the $49.5 billion loan it got from the U.S. government to fund its bankruptcy restructuring in 2009. GM gave the U.S. Treasury a mix of cash and stock, as agreed. There's nothing more that GM is required to do under the terms of those loans. It's a done deal.
But here's why some folks continue to complain: The amount that has been returned to the U.S. Treasury so far is much less than that $49.5 billion.
The government has been recovering more every month, as it sells off its holdings of GM stock. But as I'll explain, the government probably doesn't have enough stock left to fully pay off the debt."
What you state is technically true but not entirely true at all.
This is something written and acted. It has nothing to do with this specific actress or any specific representation of teenagers. It is what the writers feel is ethical and appropriate.
The technocrat hiding in the wool of a progressive, i.e. Gore, Kerry, Clinton (both of them), Pelossi, Obama, on and on, will only see that there just needs to be more state control and less individual liberty and rights for the common good (the enriching of their pockets). Your comments strike me as the epitome of Progressive Statist politospeak that has gotten this country to the dire point we find ourselves in.
But the rest of your response isn't in the same planetary system. Like when the heck did the movement ever die in order to do a rebirth?
For what purpose? Today's discussion of progressives are pretty much confined to the more radical members of the Democratic Party, the left overs from the Weathermen, statist/collectivist/socialist, etc.
Please explain the progressive tax rate and how that sentiment DOESN"T factor into the message of this commercial (which was the point of the post)?
Progressive tax is a graduated tax based on income. The wealthier pay more.
Today's progressives, at least the co-opted very public ones, like OWS and many of the left currently in power, believe that the wealthy should shoulder more of the burden in every aspect of things simply because they have more. aka You didn't do that alone....lets take those profits and...etc..
The line is pretty clear with the inference I was hoping you'd make..I'd also put a pointer arrow at the end of that line directing you to the exact same message in that commercial.
1. Tax the corporations more!
2. The poor can never get ahead, we should give them more. they can't even afford an ID to vote
3. we deserve free healthcare, free college, free houses for some, free transportation, free daycare, free contraceptives....I'll keep thinking-the list is longer
4.men are inherently evil-therefore we must have lots and lots of regulations and laws to keep them in line
5.the children! o the children!
how do you counter these arguments with You own Yourself. They look at you as if you have two heads. In fairness so do many conservatives..
All I did to oppose the bailing was to continue to work and badger my Congressmen via phone and email daily to make my voice known. Does this qualify as doing something for you? (note the inference there)
While I do not know a single self-made millionaire personally, I cannot speak to what was in their hearts or their ethic when they earned their money. Can you?
I think you romanticize the notion of progressivism, particularly in its current form.
Could you also please support your inference that progressives respond to logical arguments?
They had obviously agreed on $40 beforehand but the budding entrepreneur was negotiating for more based on her client.
She needs a lesson in business ethics but I don't see her actions as particularly "progressive".
I've seen shady ethics on every side of the political spectrum.
I don't put that kind of conduct past anybody except Obj's - and I'm keeping half-an-eye on y'all too! Ha!
Like Robbie said, this is the result of the Government Motors -- they're pandering to their bosses. This is the way business is done in India and, now, in the USA.
GE became huge on shady gov't deals. Pan Am tried to get the feds to nationalize air travel so THEY could be the only airline.
Half of AR's bad guys were businessmen - half a century ago. What's new about it?
I'd have reminded the little sh!t that we'd agreed on $40, then handed her $35. When she balked I claim payment for the ride. When she whined again I'd give her the other $5 then, with an arched eye, point out that's how it feels when one party changes the deal.
That's a lesson in business ethics for a kid.
As for this being "progressive" - well, that was my point. Being "progressive" doesn't make you dishonest and being "conservative" sure as hell doesn't make you honest.
I trust other OBJ's because I know we all take ethics seriously. But otherwise, I take people one at a time.
Some of my best friends are liberal democrats and they are neither stupid nor malicious.
And I've known some "hard-nosed" business guys who'd have tried that kind of shenanigan if they thought they could get away with it.
You guys are so harsh on progressives these days - and I'm right there with you, they are going to destroy the greatest nation in history - that you claim every bad thing is theirs.
A sharper sense of reason sees a more nuanced world.
Why is she looking at the interior like that? Why is she touching it? Why is she suddenly motivated to ask for more?
Not because of "oh you people are rich, I resent that and I'm going to soak you." No.
She wants the car, and everything more it implies. She admires the well-to-do family. She is on our side, not on the side of the "needies." She is a budding capitalist.
I am astounded that only a few of the comments so far get even close to the meaning of this commercial.
By the way, contrary to other posts in this thread, I do not see the woman giving her the extra $20. The scene cuts to an exterior of the car, and hopefully the mom is taking advantage of the learning moment to 1) give the girl positives for claiming more worth; 2) teaching her that she has to supply new additional value to earn it.
2) I always thought “Progressivism” was the title that Liberals anointed themselves with under the delusion that changing society to their viewpoint would be “Progress.” – Well you could say that the parade of children following the Pied Piper toward the cliff was progressing torwards that goal. LOL
It also insinuates a normal cost of $40, which was assumed by both involved in the trade. This is not directly in the add, but the posture and attitude of both state that while not discussed $40 was the expected cost/reward but because you must be rich you should pay me more than most people do.
That said the baby sitter would have every right to negotiate a hire price for any reason, even if its its just because she thinks the mother will pay it. The right time to do it is before the service has been rendered. If she simply assumed she would get paid, but did not negotiate the price before hand, the mother could pay her nothing and be 100% correct in doing so.
Looking at this as a negotiation at this point is kinda like taking a birth control pill after you think you may be pregnant. Its simply was not the right time to negotiate a price, the goods were delivered and if you did not all ready have an agreement, no mater what the mom does the babysitter would have to accept it.
So either the agreed price was $40, purposeful or assumed. Or the babysitter offered service without knowing what she would get. Either way this would be the wrong time to negotiate or a breach of there previous agreement. Either is not capitalism. Its breaking an agreement.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1o__uF80e...
For those who believe in this left/right thing, you can add, "and then that add would be really [leftwing/rightwing] b/c they're the ones who believe in having affairs with the babysitter!"
Damn it, maybe I should be on "gullible gulch".
A similar ad from Ford would have had the little girl asking when she could babysit for them again as she was saving up to be able to afford that kind of car for herself.
Still, I am a GM buyer, have been since my first '57 Chevy was given to me by my Dad - if I got an after school job to support the gas, repairs and insurance. Since then, it has been Firebirds, Camaros, Chevelle Malibu SS, Blazer and Corvettes. I don't care they moved to China with the money and Obama was too stupid to know it was in the works. They are a business, and as long as they make cars I like, I will buy them. So Obama and the union scammed some retirees and us taxpayers, GM went on with making money. Taxpayers elected the economic moron and unions went with what they always do - looking out for themselves.
We can blame GM, but the real blame goes to the stupid voters, the Prez and the power hungry unions. Meanwhile, the ad stinks, must have been written by a 9 year old.
GM....the camels' back is broken. My wife and I are buying Fords now.
I won't get into the wannabe-yuppie soccermom-wagen syndrome. I used to see it with the Denali's and the Expeditions as well... "Look at me, I have such a fine motorcar, you must look at my grand touring SUV and know I'm ms. Uberwealth"... kind of reminds me of the old Grey Poupon ads where the VW would pull up to the Rolls Royce...
But the biggest lesson - the "push" the ad was also going for - was how much smarter and more shrewd the younger future Tahoe Buying Generation is compared to the old fogie mom driving hers. See, I can hold you hostage, and that's a GOOD thing. And when I have MY tahoe and MY squalling brats, I won't be the fool you are...
How could this anti-Normal-American attitude have come to be inserted in our culture, and celebrated ?
Answers here:
http://my.brainshark.com/Willing-Accompl...
The only question remains, what will we do about it?
kent@kentclizbe.com
I'm startled by all of the 'progressive/liberal/moocher' labels that knee-jerked out of so many of you!
The obvious message of the commercial is 'i'm going to try to get more out of this exchange because your car/SUV is communicating "wealth" to me' but virtually none of you mentioned that we don't know what the mom and the babysitter "eventually" settled on.
I could postulate that the babysitter had taken a 'negotiating skills' class, but mom never did and really should have taken one. Or that dad should have driven the kid home and done the negotiating, potentially saving his own family $20 in the process.
Some decades ago, when I lived in Silicon Valley, I couldn't help but notice that gasoline prices in San Francisco were always about a dollar higher than in Cupertino/Santa Clara. Sure, a lot of that was local tax differences, but it was also quite a bit of 'what the market would bear.'
Touchy nerves in many of you, no? Sure looks it.
Otherwise you've reopened negotiations and you've put yourself on your own slippery slope, with only yourself to blame.
It's subtle, but makes all the difference. If my gardener or mechanic quotes me a price and I agree to it, they'd better have a WONDERFUL reason to come back and try to adjust the price.
Example: I have a whole-house generator outside my garage, and it failed to do its self-test "exercise" so I called for service. Turns out I have a service contract and the maintenance guy didn't come out last month for the 6-month interval. So, $150 for a new battery and some unknown amount for a failed battery charger was their estimate.
But they've got some skin in the game for not having held up their part of the contract by not showing up for routine regular maintenance. So odds are, I'm going to 'negotiate' a lower charge for their work. That's negotiating.
A wonderful friend taught me about negotiating some time before he passed away. And then I took the company's Negotiating Skills course. Between them, I've saved thousands of dollars for myself and my family.
Like the mom in the commercial should have 'invested in.'
To each according to their need, from each according to their ability.
Her eyes and nod said it all, she sized them up and tried to get more than what they'd initially agreed on based on how she perceived they were doing financially.