Why do humans have to be owned?
Posted by j_IR1776wg 9 years, 9 months ago to Philosophy
A recurring post here in the Gulch for the past several years asks whether the government owns you of if you own you.
Why do humans have to be owned at all?
My whole life I've been told that:
1) god own me.
2) my parents own me.
3) government owns me.
4) I own me.
But I've never read any proof or justification of why exactly is ownership of humans necessary?
In logic, the offering of a limited number of choices as if they were the only choices is a fallacy known as bifurcation. Is this what we are being offered?
Is ownership of humans necessary?
Why do humans have to be owned at all?
My whole life I've been told that:
1) god own me.
2) my parents own me.
3) government owns me.
4) I own me.
But I've never read any proof or justification of why exactly is ownership of humans necessary?
In logic, the offering of a limited number of choices as if they were the only choices is a fallacy known as bifurcation. Is this what we are being offered?
Is ownership of humans necessary?
Previous comments... You are currently on page 4.
Can you define Man? (Metaphysics). How does Man learn and deal with information? (epistemology). How does he deal with other humans? (ethics) How does he organize his relationship with other humans? (politics). How does he express beauty? (art). Answer those and you'll not only answer your "ownership" question, but it will put your big toe into the vast pool of what it is to be a human.
That is precisely how Marx, Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Castro, Obama, Chavez, et alia looked at people i.e. as animals to be controlled and destroyed as it pleased them to do so.
Ones body is the vessel to carry one through life. Clearly slavery is wrong, so another person should not own a person. I would expand this to include the government. It could be argued that parents own a child until maturity, but clearly not into adulthood, or even further, after the parents' death. God owns me leads to what god and is there a god. What if you (like me) don't believe in one at all?
This comes down to who makes decisions about a person, and that is the person. Therefore, a person owns themselves, because they make all the decisions regarding there self, and "yes" ownership is required because they must also maintain themselves and feed themselves, or they can waste themselves and die. No other entity can do this ethically without cause.
I don't even see a foothold for another proper view.
Someone who stole from someone and was proven would have to repay the debt and also serve as slave for a number of years as a form of punishment.
Jews has slavery of all sorts, and every 7 years the "Jubilee" year all slaves were summarily set free, although some sold themselves right back into slavery for another 7 years.
Slavery in ancient times could be both good and bad depending on the circumstances.
These days people who make statements like that are looked upon as deluded fools as if the statement was ""We The People" own the government." The "supposed" left out.
I can just see the Great And Powerful O looking down his nose at me with that huge toothy grin of his.
Fine, when do I get audited?
In a sense, just every cell in your body is solely responsible for it's own survival, that community of cells plus an individual identity of mind is in fact 'Self Interest'...rationally speaking.
I suspect that some people like having a "stable" job. I have heard people say they want to be told where to go to work, to have a somewhat-stable paycheck, and not to have to worry about anything beyond one job function. Someone told me, "I like being a cog." I don't think there's anything wrong with that. Some business (hopefully) makes a profit from the "cog" and the "cog" gets to go home to his family and not worry about running the business.
To say "I own myself" means it is my responsibility to provide for myself, to maintain good health, to not harm others, to keep the product of my efforts, etc.
We use "owner" as a shorthand for that whole concept, not really meaning a possession.
After all how would logic analysis handle the statement "I own myself, and I am myself"
Of course you can do that to yourself. People worldwide do that every day to themselves. Stupidly so IMO, and many because they aren't taught by their parents or shown by society that they do own themselves.
Here in the US, the poor and disadvantaged own you, the NSA owns you, your community owns you, society owns you, the state owns you, etc. They all place demands upon you that you must satisfy or go to jail or die. If you think not, try not paying your taxes, let your grass grow too tall, park your car on the street-sit up on the hood and drink a beer, try to burn the oil from your last oil change, try to carry $5,000 of your own money in your pocket, on and on.
Load more comments...