All Comments

  • Posted by $ Susanne 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    Shift-function-? on an apple keyboard. The inverted !.. is a lower case i (Old trick!!) iAyiii!

    Oh, the question I asked was...
    " Why? Is there something bad about knowing foreign nationals? Yiiiii!!!" - Knowing a LOT of people in more than a few countries in multiple directions, I guess I could be an official "Unperson". Or at least not your typical Yanqui. ;-)

    Muchas gracias... Molto Grazie... Vielen Dank... or Spasibo (Cпасибо)!
    スザンヌ

    Reply | Permalink  
  • Comment hidden due to member score or comment score too low. View Comment
  • Posted by Robbie53024 12 years, 9 months ago
    Not only would they not have envisioned the welfare state, they would have been sickened by such a notion.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by ObjectiveAnalyst 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    Other significant points: When the constitution was written the founders never envisioned the welfare state and the country needed more people to tame the wilderness. No one was coming here without expecting to support themselves. It was a much harder life. Taxes were not levied for redistribution. The founders had no reason or concern for making distinctions between citizens or persons since it is clear they would never have approved of the redistribution state or statist environment we now live in. This is anathema to the founding way of viewing what they created and a prime example of how original intent has been subverted. We are not the better for it...
    Reply | Permalink  
    • Robbie53024 replied 12 years, 9 months ago
  • Posted by khalling 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    me too! on my kindle I have auto correct-which when I remember-I turn off. but everytime I go back in it is "on" again. annoying in the extreme. I am a forgiving reader when I am reading rational thinking
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Comment hidden due to member score or comment score too low. View Comment
  • Posted by Robbie53024 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    I swear sometimes what I type isn't what shows up in the post. LOL
    I'm always going back after the post shows up and editing small typos.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by Rozar 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    "When I am wrong, and am shown to be wrong, I will — after all — profit: if the wrongness can be demonstrated, and not simply asserted as if I were to be commanded to accept it on faith."

    Is the Best thing if heard another person say haha.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ blarman 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    I appreciate the citings and your caveats thereof.

    I would note, however, that Plyer vs Doe, while a decision, is in my book a revisionist ruling, as it was used to enforce the granting of welfare regardless of legal status, implying that once someone enters the United States they are entitled to all welfare provisions any other US citizen can apply for regardless of legal status. While I agree to a degree that protection from the State should be afforded to anyone within the nation LEGALLY, I believe that (and this is not inconsistent with the denial of rights to convicted felons you have noted) those who have not entered the country legally forfeit their claim to such benefits - a belief I realize runs contrary to this decision.

    I would also argue that the Framers of the 14th Amendment did NOT have in mind the extension of welfare benefits to non-citizens - only protections. The primary purpose was to eliminate state/municipality laws that prohibited services, etc. based on skin color, race, religion, etc., but I can not believe they meant it to include foreigners in the country illegally. Does not that strike you as a contradiction - that they would enjoy the rights yet would remain immune from the responsibilities of non-conformance? This seemeth to me to a great contradiction.

    You are welcome to disagree.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ Susanne 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    What I was speaking to was the laws of some states mandating producing legal, valid identification to a peace officer upon demand. No reasonable suspicion required - if they ask for it, you produce it, or go to the pokey to get identified. I lived in such a state (Nv) for years (this was about 3 decades ago, BTW); my family had roots there long before I was a twinkle. ;-) Had nothing to do with "visitor status" or border issues - it was the rules, and you followed them.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by ObjectiveAnalyst 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    It is eroded a little more everyday... Even with the shortcomings Original Intent is ignored. This living document crud is a path to serfdom... :( Like I articulated, attack the root causes and we won't need anyone to be asked for their papers. There seems no other option that doesn't diminish liberty. Sure some illegals will always get through, but we can absorb a small number. Let us do a better job controlling and documenting who gets in. We have heard of too many cases where the border patrol has been hamstrung and the repeat offenders aren't deterred. Three strikes and they should be detained and busting rocks for thirty days before deportation... Sure, we can't ask for papers on the street but we can at the schools, welfare offices, employment interviews and voting stations...
    Reply | Permalink  
    • Robbie53024 replied 12 years, 9 months ago
  • Comment hidden due to member score or comment score too low. View Comment
  • Posted by Robbie53024 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    Agreed. I'm in favor of tweaking the wording of the Constitution/Amendments to make things more clear/definitive. But the same issue arises when it comes to showing "papers." Is that for everybody or just "illegals?" And how do you distinguish one from the other? If we want to go the route to being required to have papers, then we have given up a significant level of liberty.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Comment hidden due to member score or comment score too low. View Comment
  • Posted by Robbie53024 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    No. Most illegal immigration occurs due to the living standards of the people in their home country. They want a better life. Once here, many get seduced into the welfare state, primarily by those that seek to profit from it.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by ObjectiveAnalyst 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    Understood. I feel that it was a mistake taken advantage of when the founders chose the word person/s where they should have specified citizen more often... the court cases demonstrate the weakness and exploited them. The solution is to stop it in the first place so we don't need a Gestapo... "Papers please"... Having said that: I see no reason why if I am to be subjected to these inquiries that others can evade same... Yes, I could resist as long as their is no probable cause, as has been demonstrated by others, but something must be done. I prefer to attack the root of the problem. The demonstrated incompetence of our border control and magnet policies... Why live in poverty when you can come here and government largess can provide a better life than is afforded you where you came from. Around the world people no longer have the spirit of 76, not even here. Let them discover it and improve their own nations from within.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Comment hidden due to member score or comment score too low. View Comment
  • Posted by Robbie53024 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    Do not let the fact that the term "illegal aliens" does not appear in the U.S. Constitution lead you to believe that its rights and freedoms do not apply to them. The courts have held otherwise.

    Often described as a "living document," the Constitution has repeatedly been interpreted by the U.S. Supreme Court, federal appeals courts and Congress in order to address the ever-changing needs and demands of the people. While many argue that "We the People of the United States," refers only to legal citizens, the Supreme Court has consistently disagreed.

    Yick Wo v. Hopkins (1886)
    In Yick Wo v. Hopkins, a case involving the rights of Chinese immigrants, the Court ruled that the 14th Amendment's statement, "Nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws," applied to all persons "without regard to any differences of race, of color, or of nationality," and to "an alien, who has entered the country, and has become subject in all respects to its jurisdiction, and a part of its population, although alleged to be illegally here." (Kaoru Yamataya v. Fisher, 189 U.S. 86 (1903) )

    Wong Wing v. U.S. (1896)
    Citing Yick Wo v. Hopkins, the Court, in the case of Wong Wing v. US, further applied the citizenship-blind nature of the Constitution to the 5th and 6th amendments, stating ". . . it must be concluded that all persons within the territory of the United States are entitled to the protection guaranteed by those amendments, and that even aliens shall not be held to answer for a capital or other infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a grand jury, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law."

    Plyler v. Doe (1982)
    In Plyler v. Doe, the Supreme Court struck down a Texas law prohibiting enrollment of illegal aliens in public school. In its decision, the Court held, "The illegal aliens who are plaintiffs in these cases challenging the statute may claim the benefit of the Equal Protection Clause, which provides that no State shall 'deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.' Whatever his status under the immigration laws, an alien is a 'person' in any ordinary sense of that term… The undocumented status of these children vel non does not establish a sufficient rational basis for denying them benefits that the State affords other residents."

    It's All About Equal Protection
    When the Supreme Court decides cases dealing with First Amendment rights, it typically draws guidance from the 14th Amendment's principal of "equal protection under the law." In essence, the "equal protection" clause extends First Amendment protection to anyone and everyone covered by the 5th and 14th Amendments. Through its consistent rulings that the 5th and 14th Amendments apply equally to illegal aliens, they also enjoy First Amendment rights.

    In rejecting the argument that the "equal" protections of the 14th Amendment are limited to U.S. citizens, the Supreme Court has referred to language used by the Congressional Committee that drafted the amendment:

    "The last two clauses of the first section of the amendment disable a State from depriving not merely a citizen of the United States, but any person, whoever he may be, of life, liberty, or property without due process of law, or from denying to him the equal protection of the laws of the State. This abolishes all class legislation in the States and does away with the injustice of subjecting one caste of persons to a code not applicable to another. . . . It [the 14th Amendment] will, if adopted by the States, forever disable every one of them from passing laws trenching upon those fundamental rights and privileges which pertain to citizens of the United States, and to all persons who may happen to be within their jurisdiction."

    While illegal aliens do not enjoy all of the rights granted to citizens by the Constitution, specifically the rights to vote or possess firearms, these rights can also be denied to U.S. citizens convicted of felonies. In final analysis, the courts have ruled that, while they are within the borders of the United States, illegal aliens are granted the same fundamental, undeniable constitutional rights granted to all Americans.

    Do you need more?
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ blarman 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    I agree.

    I think it would be very easy to eliminate illegal "immigration" simply by eliminating the welfare state. Take away the monetary incentive of free money and those still wishing to enter the US would be doing so for other reasons.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Comment hidden due to member score or comment score too low. View Comment
  • Posted by Robbie53024 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    Precisely. An American citizen of Mexican ancestry whose family has lived in the southwest for generations is unlikely to look any differently from an illegal Mexican who just crossed the border illegally that very morning. You cannot tell by looks, nor that they primarily/only speak Spanish. So, as I've stated numerous times in this thread - identify the probable cause and I am all for detaining/searching/deporting. What I am not for is the wholesale rounding up and denial of Constitutional rights of some of our fellow citizens as advocated in this thread by several posters.
    And since we also have illegal immigrants from eastern Europe, the Middle East, Africa, and SE Asia (and other worldwide locations), does that give the government the right to stop anyone and "demand their papers?"
    This isn't a rant against you, OA, as I know you are more rational than that.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ blarman 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    I have read it, and note that it specifically references the people "of this nation" - implying citizenship. While there are some natural rights enjoyed by all people and specifically recognized by the Constitution, one should not construe this to mean that Constitutional protections are afforded to extra-nationals. Their individual embassies or consuls are free to object, but as we do not have jurisdiction over a foreign national, it is similarly absurd that they gain the Constitutional protections afforded, does it not?

    If you disagree, I would also ask you to cite a Supreme Court case that deigned to grant the rights of the Constitution - such as Fourth Amendment protections - to non-citizens. I would point out that even challenges to the Patriot Act were only successful in reference to US Citizens - and that regardless of their nation of residence. All others were deemed to be affairs of international relations and therefore outside the jurisdiction of US courts.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Comment hidden due to member score or comment score too low. View Comment
  • Posted by Robbie53024 12 years, 9 months ago in reply to this comment.
    Law enforcement can ask, but you are under no obligation to provide same.
    I'm well aware of the levels of probable cause. Should you exhibit any of them, then expect to be searched and any potential illegal materials seized.
    Reply | Permalink  

  • Comment hidden. Undo