- Hot
- New
- Categories...
- Producer's Lounge
- Producer's Vault
- The Gulch: Live! (New)
- Ask the Gulch!
- Going Galt
- Books
- Business
- Classifieds
- Culture
- Economics
- Education
- Entertainment
- Government
- History
- Humor
- Legislation
- Movies
- News
- Philosophy
- Pics
- Politics
- Science
- Technology
- Video
- The Gulch: Best of
- The Gulch: Bugs
- The Gulch: Feature Requests
- The Gulch: Featured Producers
- The Gulch: General
- The Gulch: Introductions
- The Gulch: Local
- The Gulch: Promotions
- Marketplace
- Members
- Store
- More...
Such a statement is emblematic of the arrogance and unwillingness of such individuals to truly follow the laws of the nation. It's simply treason and should be prosecuted as such.
A burglar should be given the contents of a house. Why hold up a jewelry store and endanger peoples lives? Just give the thief jewels whenever he demands them.The true crime committed by illegal aliens is not only that they entered the country illegally, but they did it to get a better opportunity in life, and as a result, they stole that opportunity from a person waiting years to enter legally. I'll save my sympathy for those who entered the right way.
I have no problem if they return to their home country and apply to enter the country legally. I would even grant the retro active status, once they are here legally. I would also never, ever grant citizenship to any illegal who committed a felony level crime while in the unites States.
Neither do I, so long as they are never actually allowed back into the country while breathing.
I agree completely with that statement right up to the word "country".
First, they're trying to get the unearned, by sneaking into the country.
Second, even assuming the false stereotype of "hard workers" were true... this is not what Rand and AS celebrated.
What was it Galt took away from the world? He announced it in his speech. He didn't take the back away from the world. He didn't even take the productive.... "men's minds".
"I have stopped your motor. I have deprived your world of man's mind.
"Men do not live by the mind, you say? I have withdrawn those who do. The mind is impotent, you say?
I have withdrawn those whose mind isn't. There are values higher than the mind, you say? I have withdrawn those for whom there aren't."
These invaders have not exactly been "men of the mind". Even were they the "honest, hard-working" men the romanticizers proclaim, the jobs they do, the positions they fill are not of the mind. It does not take mental agility to swing a shovel, or a hammer. Yes, it takes years to train a craftsman... in the trade someone else's mind has discovered... but it doesn't take years to train a poor craftsman, if one is willing to sacrifice quality for price. And that is a "sacrifice" this country has been making for decades now; ever since the first gas crisis.
Indeed, the job Galt took at Taggart Transcontinental he took precisely because it did not grant the benefit of his mind.
It sounds to me like he wants them to “come out of the shadows” so that they can be better monitored like the rest of us.
An article I wrote some time ago outlining the idea
http://www.humanevents.com/2006/05/17/12...
I see the thought process and do not disagree with the bulk of your statements in your article, but it should only go so far as optional services. I do not think monitoring schools and hospital records without an individual specific warrant based on probable cause is constitutional.
Verifying that the IDs provided are valid is not a violation of the fourth amendment.
What they do have are consular rights - the right to gain representation from representatives of their home nation.
The First Amendment is protecting " the right of the people", it doesn't say "citizens" where it obviously could have, and where it does in other sections.
If you disagree, I would also ask you to cite a Supreme Court case that deigned to grant the rights of the Constitution - such as Fourth Amendment protections - to non-citizens. I would point out that even challenges to the Patriot Act were only successful in reference to US Citizens - and that regardless of their nation of residence. All others were deemed to be affairs of international relations and therefore outside the jurisdiction of US courts.
Often described as a "living document," the Constitution has repeatedly been interpreted by the U.S. Supreme Court, federal appeals courts and Congress in order to address the ever-changing needs and demands of the people. While many argue that "We the People of the United States," refers only to legal citizens, the Supreme Court has consistently disagreed.
Yick Wo v. Hopkins (1886)
In Yick Wo v. Hopkins, a case involving the rights of Chinese immigrants, the Court ruled that the 14th Amendment's statement, "Nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws," applied to all persons "without regard to any differences of race, of color, or of nationality," and to "an alien, who has entered the country, and has become subject in all respects to its jurisdiction, and a part of its population, although alleged to be illegally here." (Kaoru Yamataya v. Fisher, 189 U.S. 86 (1903) )
Wong Wing v. U.S. (1896)
Citing Yick Wo v. Hopkins, the Court, in the case of Wong Wing v. US, further applied the citizenship-blind nature of the Constitution to the 5th and 6th amendments, stating ". . . it must be concluded that all persons within the territory of the United States are entitled to the protection guaranteed by those amendments, and that even aliens shall not be held to answer for a capital or other infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a grand jury, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law."
Plyler v. Doe (1982)
In Plyler v. Doe, the Supreme Court struck down a Texas law prohibiting enrollment of illegal aliens in public school. In its decision, the Court held, "The illegal aliens who are plaintiffs in these cases challenging the statute may claim the benefit of the Equal Protection Clause, which provides that no State shall 'deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.' Whatever his status under the immigration laws, an alien is a 'person' in any ordinary sense of that term… The undocumented status of these children vel non does not establish a sufficient rational basis for denying them benefits that the State affords other residents."
It's All About Equal Protection
When the Supreme Court decides cases dealing with First Amendment rights, it typically draws guidance from the 14th Amendment's principal of "equal protection under the law." In essence, the "equal protection" clause extends First Amendment protection to anyone and everyone covered by the 5th and 14th Amendments. Through its consistent rulings that the 5th and 14th Amendments apply equally to illegal aliens, they also enjoy First Amendment rights.
In rejecting the argument that the "equal" protections of the 14th Amendment are limited to U.S. citizens, the Supreme Court has referred to language used by the Congressional Committee that drafted the amendment:
"The last two clauses of the first section of the amendment disable a State from depriving not merely a citizen of the United States, but any person, whoever he may be, of life, liberty, or property without due process of law, or from denying to him the equal protection of the laws of the State. This abolishes all class legislation in the States and does away with the injustice of subjecting one caste of persons to a code not applicable to another. . . . It [the 14th Amendment] will, if adopted by the States, forever disable every one of them from passing laws trenching upon those fundamental rights and privileges which pertain to citizens of the United States, and to all persons who may happen to be within their jurisdiction."
While illegal aliens do not enjoy all of the rights granted to citizens by the Constitution, specifically the rights to vote or possess firearms, these rights can also be denied to U.S. citizens convicted of felonies. In final analysis, the courts have ruled that, while they are within the borders of the United States, illegal aliens are granted the same fundamental, undeniable constitutional rights granted to all Americans.
Do you need more?
I would note, however, that Plyer vs Doe, while a decision, is in my book a revisionist ruling, as it was used to enforce the granting of welfare regardless of legal status, implying that once someone enters the United States they are entitled to all welfare provisions any other US citizen can apply for regardless of legal status. While I agree to a degree that protection from the State should be afforded to anyone within the nation LEGALLY, I believe that (and this is not inconsistent with the denial of rights to convicted felons you have noted) those who have not entered the country legally forfeit their claim to such benefits - a belief I realize runs contrary to this decision.
I would also argue that the Framers of the 14th Amendment did NOT have in mind the extension of welfare benefits to non-citizens - only protections. The primary purpose was to eliminate state/municipality laws that prohibited services, etc. based on skin color, race, religion, etc., but I can not believe they meant it to include foreigners in the country illegally. Does not that strike you as a contradiction - that they would enjoy the rights yet would remain immune from the responsibilities of non-conformance? This seemeth to me to a great contradiction.
You are welcome to disagree.
Or. ... We could, you know, just get rid of free education, welfare, free medical care, and other wealth redistribution programs.
down question mark. :)
Oh, the question I asked was...
" Why? Is there something bad about knowing foreign nationals? Yiiiii!!!" - Knowing a LOT of people in more than a few countries in multiple directions, I guess I could be an official "Unperson". Or at least not your typical Yanqui. ;-)
Muchas gracias... Molto Grazie... Vielen Dank... or Spasibo (Cпасибо)!
スザンヌ
For a quick look at the levels of "probable cause", check out this quick guide:
http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2014/01/...
Note that some jurisdictions (especially in border states) do include mandatory ID provisions, so consult your local laws or an attorney for more.
My personal belief is that one can be both skeptical and polite at the same time. There are most definitely the bad apples of the police force that make many look bad, but I would rather assume that the officer I was dealing with was honorable than otherwise.
I'm well aware of the levels of probable cause. Should you exhibit any of them, then expect to be searched and any potential illegal materials seized.
http://usgovinfo.about.com/od/rightsandf...
The problem is that once you have broken an immigration law, unless caught in the act you carry no definitively obvious signs...
And since we also have illegal immigrants from eastern Europe, the Middle East, Africa, and SE Asia (and other worldwide locations), does that give the government the right to stop anyone and "demand their papers?"
This isn't a rant against you, OA, as I know you are more rational than that.
The Constitution is rather particular on how it defined various classes of people. In the sections on who could serve as President, for example, it defines some particulars due to the fact that at the time there were newly minted US citizens who had been born in a "foreign" nation - literally an English territory, as the land that was to become the US was prior to the DofI.
I'll grant you that there is a difference between the 1st Amendment right to peaceably gather and the ability to receive government payments. That is a separate issue and should be dealt with as the current law specifies.
Keep in mind I agree with what you are saying about monitoring government benefit programs, but I draw the law when it comes to invading my privacy. I have not always had that outlook. Honestly some of it has developed during the time I have spent here, but that’s my story and I’m sticking to it.
Having interacted with thousands of them over the years, on construction sites ranging up and down the Mississippi basin, familiarity has indeed bred contempt. My hatred is born anew each time I put ketchup on a sandwich and have to worry about my mouth being scalded, or have to turn a product on a store shelf around in order to read the English description.
Where do you think the "thick accent" comes from? You think native born to the 5th generation teach their kids to speak broken English, or no English at all?
I tire of the hyphenated Americans... I was brought up believing the melting pot was a good thing... that aspiring to be an "American" period, was a good thing... Sad, don't you think? I believe in judging the content of one's character... and we wonder why divisiveness has become so corrosive... people set themselves apart.
O.A.
To me, I want government - especially the federal government - out of my pocketbook. I would like nothing more than the total elimination of any and ALL Federal welfare programs from food stamps to CHIP to unemployment to No Child Left Behind - ALL OF IT. Privatize Social Security and eliminate the Federal Government's interventions in the healthcare market (including all derivatives of Medicare). With a pared-back Federal Government, we'd be able to pay off our debt and lower taxes while encouraging personal independence.
If these people were sneaking across the border wearing olive drab uniforms and carrying AK-47s and handgrenades, they'd be no more dangerous to America than they are now, but at least law enforcement would shoot their asses rather than bend over backwards to accommodate them.
Overall I agree that those who came here illegally should be immediately sent back with no questions or quarter given. I have only seen two cases that gave me pause to this, and those where two people who had been brought here at such a young age one did not even speak Spanish and the other barely did even though they were born in Mexico. I would have a hard time sending an adult to Mexico that had been here since they were 2 or 3 years old.
So many things get wrapped up in some sort of "homeland security patriotism" that the neocons (I know many) don't realize they are being duped, while the hard left just folds their arms and smiles knowingly, happy to see the collapse of a once-great nation. Why do so few see this? And, frankly, I no longer feel safe voicing my opinion on this kind of thing on public forums. I am rapidly going Galt with my opinions...
Use the blue "Submit Post" button... top right.
Respectfully,
O.A.
Isn't it amazing how liberals choose to justify their ever-changing positions?!? They want and need everyone else to be law-abiding citizens to prevent the total breakdown of society, but they themselves don't want to be "burdened" by those very laws.
Is rational speech. The stuff in between those phrases is Jabbering patois.
In case you needed an example.
Do you expect anyone to believe that the following lengthy stretch of prose — your own — is mere meaningless "jabber" on your part?
" ... (i.e. anyone who has NOT applied for American citizenship or for a Green Card), who refuses to use the English language (the common language of all Americans!) regularly, jabbering in their native patois whenever they choose so that they can to claim "No habla Engles!", refuses to obey traffic laws and who don't have a valid driver's license (AND fails to insure their vehicles!), is allowed to vote, is awarded food stamps, votes without restriction, probably pays little or NO income tax, receives benefits in order to obtain adequate shelter, AND expects to be coddled and treated like an ordinary citizen ... "
When you go after the wrong person, you really should acknowledge that to the person so attacked. Just the polite thing to do.
And, oh by the way, some of your posts have misspellings (which I suspect are the outcome of auto spell check, so it probably shouldn't be a course of criticism to others who may be suffering the same problem). Just sayin'.
When I am wrong, and am shown to be wrong, I will — after all — profit: if the wrongness can be demonstrated, and not simply asserted as if I were to be commanded to accept it on faith.
Therefore:
/1/
Which words did I misspell in yesterday's messages, or today's?
/2/Please defend your belief that what I perceive as language is instead "jabbering patois."
/2.1/ Can you please teach me why I should adopt that belief and reject my own perceptions?
/2.2/ What criterion would you have me adopt, for determining what to classify as language, and what to classify instead as "jabbering" or "patois"?
/2.3/ On what grounds should I adopt that criterion? What demonstrates that the criterion you use (whatever it may be) is correct and necessary?
Is the Best thing if heard another person say haha.
Have a good day.
But it certainly isn't by being you editor.
I'm always going back after the post shows up and editing small typos.
I don't think I've seen you around here either. Are you new?
Whether or not a club is Objectivist, or calls itself that, matters less to me than whether it is a club in which I may learn something.
In any case, things rarely get harsh around here, but it happens from time to time.
Have a good night I'm heading out.
But nothing knew. EVERYTHING that collectivists, democrats, liberals, progressives, communists, socialists espouse is predicated on theft.
I've commonly referred to this as the 'pussification' of America. It is a widespread mental disorder affecting all people in the country on one level or another; some of us are just recovering faster than others.
Common symptoms are spinelessness, cowardice, lack of personal opinion, going along to get along, mindlessness, inability to stand your ground, and boredom.
Common Treatments are thinking for yourself, killing your TV, eating healthy, disregarding the meaningless chitter-chatter of all who seek to control, and reading Atlas Shrugged.
Full recovery is dependent on ones ability to drop all the unnecessary baggage they have been toting around, and dedication to the principles of life and liberty. It is beneficial for one to surround themselves with people of equal or higher values so as to prevent stagnation of the mind.
Beware long term contact with those suffering from an acute case of 'pussifacation", as it can be contagious. First signs of contamination can include pity, a feeling of helplessness or despair, and rolling in the emotional muck of misery with other lower forms of humans, deprived of a sense of self.
Untreated, 'pussification' could lead too premature death; but most likely will lead to a long, unexciting, unproductive, empty life that was a total waste.
"I remember a time when men were men and pussies were flowers"
And thanks, use it freely. :-)
There is actually a reason for turning a blind eye to illegals and giving them freebies. These are the kinds of people they want in large numbers...they will not fight a tyrannical government. Don't bite the hand that feeds you. It's those of us who are responsible and independent they have to fear...so we are forever the target of their abuses, whether it's the IRS, or obamacare, gun confiscation...they know where are buttons are and they will put us in a vise at every turn. Look how they talk about the TEA party. It's ALL part of their agenda to break us down. If you're a moocher then your bought and paid for... with OUR stolen money. What a major cluster.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3eyJIbSgd...
1. Friedman was unabashed in his derision of the welfare state. Having watched many of his other statements, his comments are subtly poking fun at the absurdity of the welfare situation in the first place.
2. Friedman correctly points out the differences between allowing immigration pre-1914 and now being the existence of a welfare state.
3. This is an old video - probably late 1970's/early 1980's. At that time things were just heating up into the first major amnesty bill but the welfare state was just beginning to heat up. Welfare programs and expenditures have gone up astronomically in the last 30 years and many states now include illegals on welfare roles, vastly increasing the attractiveness of illegal immigration.
4. Violence in Mexico is also at an all-time high in comparison to the publishing of this video. This means that life in Mexico is increasingly unattractive and ANYWHERE else is attractive. Given it's geographical proximity AND the opportunities presented, the US represents a VERY attractive alternative. Team that with their socialist government and rampant corruption and it is fairly easy to see the allure of even illegal participation in the US.
In short, even though I don't support illegal activity of any kind, I can sympathize with the Mexican nationals attempting to gain entry and access to the United States. If there were no welfare state, I don't think I'd have any problem with them coming - as long as they conformed to the laws of the United States, learned English, and applied for citizenship lawfully.
That said, our immigration policy is absurd. It remains blind to the reality that these people are going to enter the country in any case - so raise the quotas and document them.
And lastly, there should be a period of time where these new immigrants are prohibited from receiving government payouts. They should not be immigrating merely to receive payouts, rather to contribute to the economic prosperity of the nation. If they cannot do that, then they should be sent packing.
Oh, and a post script: The children of immigrants born in the US should not be automatically granted citizenship until their parents have gained citizenship status.
I think it would be very easy to eliminate illegal "immigration" simply by eliminating the welfare state. Take away the monetary incentive of free money and those still wishing to enter the US would be doing so for other reasons.
I'm watching the Godfather right now... "free immigration" got us the Italian Mafia, Russian Mafia and crooked Irish cops and rampant disease.
The horrific sweatshops of the 19th and 20th centuries were made possible by "free immigration", by short-circuiting the law of supply and demand for labor.
Freedman is full of shit, and probably never sweated to earn a dollar in his life.
He also ignores the reality that in the 19th century and earlier the continent was largely unsettled, inhabited by hunter-gatherers, relatively small in number, occupying huge areas. That's not the case today.