as the saying goes from a movie "you can't take the truth"! so the answer is no.

As far as I am concerned, they would be welcome here in the (virtual) Gulch, as long as they abide by the basic rules. Basically, be respectful.

As far as whether they would be welcome in the (literary) Galt's Gulch as described in AS, I think that is an excellent question, and one that occurred to me as well. I think there could be some personal conflicts between the Oath, and some of the teachings of Christianity.

Great discussion starter! I look forward to seeing what others have to say, and will probably be back with some input when I have some time to ponder.

Thanks j.

true. Truth is a good thing. Too bad truth is denied or twisted in today's culture.

Can they take the Oath? Faith is a construct that denies A is A.

Forcing your values (right or wrong) on another? That sounds remarkably like what we all want to get away from.