A spear in the heart
I watched American Sniper with my son today. Touching movie. Discussing the movie on the way home my son explained that he doesn't "wave the flag like you do." To make a long drawn out conversation short...
Thank you Mr. Paul, apparently my son is a dupe and I am an animal (my words, not his).
Thank you Mr. Paul, apparently my son is a dupe and I am an animal (my words, not his).
Previous comments... You are currently on page 2.
What Paul and Rand said is that funding -- both for charity and wars -- should be voluntary. This rests on the conviction that the person who earned the money is the best (and the only morally justified) person to decide how it should be spent. I'm sure you'd agree this rule should apply to YOUR money. Yet, unless you're a hypocrite, the rule must apply to others, too.
You say you disagree with voluntary funding, which means you believe money should be forcibly taken from all to fund the cause you favor: war. You must fear that the justifications offered for war would not be sufficient to convince enough people to fund it and/or volunteer to fight in it, if they were actually given a choice. So instead of viewing your fellow man as an end in himself, you see him as a means to your end. This is the rationale of dictators and mafiosos, and very much anti-freedom..
Are you going out and robbing people and sending the stolen money in to the government? If not, why not? If taking money by force to fund the military is acceptable, why use the IRS and the government as your middleman? If you have the moral right to steal my money to fund war, you might as well do it directly. In my view, theft is wrong, whether you do it directly or advocate for the government to do it for you.
I apologize if you feel offended by my assessment but its my right to gather information, process it, come to my own conclusions and then call things as I see them without regard for other peoples feelings.
The following are some of my reasons for thinking Paul's military stance would be preferable. Just as the Democrats should not have a right to pick my pocket for welfare and social programs, the Republicans should not have a right to pick my pocket to go fight boogeymen all over the world. I should have a say in both. In other words, if charity should be voluntarily funded, so should the military. No one should have the right to forcibly take my money from me to support whatever pet cause they think is important, when I disagree. It's philosophically inconsistent and hypocritical to say you know how other people's money should be spent, but the other side doesn't.
Given the many examples of the government's corruption and waste that are frequent topics of conversation here in the Gulch, would you claim that we can nonetheless trust our government when they say another country is "bad" or a threat, and we should expend our money and blood attacking them? I don't trust that the government's chief motive is to protect the people. Have you heard of Operation Northwoods? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_N... At least a segment of our government wants war badly enough to intentionally attack the very people they are sworn to protect. They're willing to stage false flag attacks and blame a scape goat to justify war.
Ayn Rand wrote that the police and courts should be voluntarily funded. She and Ron Paul are in agreement about many things philosophically. Hopefully no one here would classify her as a "dupe," "illiterate," and "naive."
I am more than a little disappointed to learn that my son doesn't value this country as much as I do. Like Ron Paul, he is naive in his thinking on this matter AND will end up seeing his idealism decimated by the reality of the coming all-out culture war.
I do not want to open a pissing match with the Paulites and Libertarians on this site. This is why I kept things vague.
Even so, I am sorely disappointed, and even hurt to a degree, by my sons perspective.
That is what I thought and how I remembered it also. However, I did a search and found it was in question... C'est la vie...
Regards,
O.A.
I think that was Winston Churchill.
We must take the joy we can find.
I can't imagine the suffering you must have endured. My problems are minor when compared to yours.
From one father to another, I hope you find peace and happiness with your son.
I have heard it said that, “If you are not a liberal at twenty I would say you had no heart. If you are not a conservative by 40 I would say you had no brain.” Unattributed, I believe it is a paraphrase...
It was first said by Francois Guisot, a French monarchist statesman:
“Not to be a republican at twenty is proof of want of heart; to be one at thirty is proof of want of head.”
(Said in reference to whether France should be a republic or a monarchy.)
It was later adapted by French Premier Georges Clemenceau:
“Not to be a socialist at twenty is proof of want of heart; to be one at thirty is proof of want of head.”
In any case the America the younger generations see is not the one we knew. Still I wonder how much of the rest of the world he has seen and how much history revisionism he has been exposed to? How old was he on 9-11? Has he been exposed to places like Haiti or other really impoverished nations, or the brutality of places under Sharia?
There may yet be time. Patience and guidance on your part may yet change his perception.
Though I was never a Liberal in the modern sense of the word, I do remember how much the following quote from Twain struck me as accurate later in life.
“When I was a boy of 14, my father was so ignorant I could hardly stand to have the old man around. But when I got to be 21, I was astonished at how much the old man had learned in seven years.” Mark Twain
The exact ages are not critical, but the premise is often true.
Your son is lucky. You are still around for him, and can expose him to different perspectives.
Best wishes,
O.A.
it really picked up steam when my generation became teachers, i graduated high school in 1959. i saw how my sister who became a teacher functioned. she would probably be angry if she read this as i never told her what i thought.
then of course the government decided that the students weren't doing well so they stepped in further than they already were and as things work with government intervention things got worse. all who think that things in general will get better in the usa are sadly mistaken. education wise we are a 3rd world country or worse. at least in the third world country the youth know how to survive even though they are basically illiterate. here the youth do not know what to do, accept ask for everything. depresses me to write in this subject.
I know it was a "war movie", but the one part that left me wanting more detail was the end, where Kyle abruptly from combat psychosis to a perfectly well adjusted guy. Not sure if Eastwood was trying to trim minutes or what, but documenting his recovery - even if all of 15 minutes of screen time - would have done a service, both to movie continuity and to the viewers to help them understand that process.
All in all - I give it 4.9 stars. :-)
This country killing soldiers by playing cowboys and Indians in Vietnam and the (not quite for my reason) protests against that war gradually transformed me into a lib. Of course my youth got all caught in the counter-culture movement unique to that time. (There's another one (a plain ole' culture movement?) via Internet and Facebook unique to this time).
I was heart-broken when Robert Kennedy was assassinated. I was itching to vote for his run for president since he was against the war.
I was drafted, placed in the Marines, listened to all the indoctrination at Parris Island and still remained a lib.
When our troops abandoned Vietnam to its fate, I was again a civilian. I hated all that useless loss but I was all "I told you so."
Then Jimmy Carter came along. I voted for him. Just those four years completely turned my thinking around.
I voted for Ronald Reagan twice for both his terms.
I hoped just four years of Obama would turn this country around. Maybe I should have taken the 8 years of "Teflon Man" Clinton more into account.
Load more comments...