Reality: Healthcare

Posted by $ AJAshinoff 13 years ago to Culture
37 comments | Share | Best of... | Flag

Today I had to visit my wife's place of employment to have biometrics and blood work done for the new health insurance policy they implemented. As a responsible husband and father I cannot be without healthcare coverage. While the line for the blood work was too long I was able to complete the biometric portion, In this portion I can see the noose tightening.

I am not a skinny man but I'm not huge either. After taking my blood pressure (which was perfectly fine) the woman took my BMI (body mass index). She tells me that I'm at 33% body fat. Okay, then proceeds to tell me "We'd like to get you in this range" pointing to the column where <21% is listed..

The wording, the presumption in what she said is stupefying. The actual notion that she/they have ANY authority to tell me how to conduct my life is a step into the noose. Yes, I voluntarily took that step today. Again, as a responsible husband and father I cannot afford to have anything happen to me that would financially ruin my wife or my children's future. This was the first and only step I will take toward this looming totalitarian audacity. When they begin to dictate what I should be doing and how I should be eating (they no doubt will), is when I start getting into trouble and my life starts to drastically change.


All Comments

  • Posted by $ 13 years ago in reply to this comment.
    You seem to love the subjectivism. Lazy? Stupid? By who's terms? idiotic questions? I'd say $6 for a single Tylenol capsule entitles them to respond to those questions professionally. Whether they take money directly from us or an insurance provider we pay for coverage THEY are the employee and WE are the employer.

    I deal with customers all day. I answer 100-200 IT related questions a day, often repetitive and often to the same people...I never TELL them how to use their computers (I often suggest) NOR am I anything but professional and polite toward their needs.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ 13 years ago in reply to this comment.
    Err...I used to use my seatbelt well before it was mandated. Who needed the law? The state to make money.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ 13 years ago in reply to this comment.
    "Perhaps if you were healthy enough"

    By who's measure? Yours? Theirs? Who really gives a damn what either you or they think of my condition. My condition is exclusively my business and none of your or anyone else's concern. As for what I eat...that to is non-ya-business. You assumption about my eating habits is the danger in this "universal healthcare" law. Her presumption to tell me where she/they would like me is entirely wrong on a variety of levels. She should have said something like "We've found that people of this BFI live healthier lives. You should consider...."

    As for my "forum fame" I don't need it nor to I work for it. Its not my motivating factor.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by TNieman7 13 years ago in reply to this comment.
    The only way anyone will talk down to you after k-12 is if you allow them to. Stand up for yourself in those situations. I do agree it is not necessary and should be pointed out when too pushy; though, it is still based on facts that the general public are too stupid and lazy to find out for themselves. These professionals are probably so used to being bombarded with idiotic questions that their job becomes a monotonous repetitive and habitual state of advice.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by LetsShrug 13 years ago in reply to this comment.
    What? Their position of power comes from education or work experience... ?! UM..I don't care how "educated" you are...You don't talk down to me and you don't assume you have authority over me. Unwanted advice...is UNWANTED...THAT is the point. Intrusive, assuming, pushy.... it's wrong and it should be pointed out when someone does it.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by TNieman7 13 years ago in reply to this comment.
    Isn't that just called "running a business?" I wonder if you get on a roller coaster without allowing the harnesses to latch you down. Ignorance is bliss here. ^^^^ >>>>>
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by TNieman7 13 years ago in reply to this comment.
    Perhaps their position of power comes from education and/or work experience? Controversially, they might actually have more knowledge on the subject matter than you do. Advice is given, not forced. If you take it that way then clench your cheeks and stop bending over.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by TNieman7 13 years ago
    Did I just read a man's story about ranting over why he is to lazy to make lifestyle changes?
    The fact that you quoted her as saying "We'd LIKE to get you in this range" is by no means dictating you or even pressuring you into any situation.
    I would leave the word "totalitarian" in context that is fitting and replace that whole last paragraph with descriptions about your short fuse and and how yould rather find some 'forum fame' than actually be the responsible husband or father.

    Perhaps if you were healthy enough you could just use a catastrophic insurance and say to hell with health insurance.
    Food for thought, there is nothing about "health insurance" in the constitution; people were just a little more particular about getting the super sized fries and dollar large dr. peppers with their burgers once upon a time.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by TNieman7 13 years ago in reply to this comment.
    Your rehabilitation story doesn't hold water in this situation. I've undergone a good amount of reconstruction and replacement surgeries myself and therapists/techs aren't trying to be your boss; these people just know how lazy and lacking of motivation some patients they get can be and so adapt a 'drill sergeant' mentality. Also, considering that the majority of p.t. related professionals I have personally dealt with lead very active and self-motivated lifestyles, the general populous may not be familiar with that level of drive and aptitude. Half the idiocy on this page doesn't matter, but don't speak poorly about our educated, dedicated, and talented p.t.'s because they have helped more than you will know.

    Hope the hip is feeling good old chap!
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by lrbeggs 13 years ago
    BMI yields only general information at best. I am constantly told I have a dangerously low BMI! I am a petite woman, weigh what I did in high school, 5'1 103. NOT GOING TO PASS OUT from anemia or malnutrition any time soon. Incorrectly using unreliable metrics is dangerous. Gotta get back to my tacos and cervesa.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by Stormi 13 years ago
    Progressive has a pony in the race. They are huge contributors to the Obama campaigns. They support "progressive" causes with their money.
    When my Libertarian daughter found out, she dropped them. They were one of the companies behind Fox's dropping Beck.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ 13 years ago in reply to this comment.
    I worry entirely about my family and its future. I've dedicated decades of my life to keeping this country as free as it could be (commentary, radio, two books). I've seen this train coming for longer than I can remember. After having written my first novel, I never expected it to arrive so soon. I'm thinking 2-5 years at most.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by ObjectiveAnalyst 13 years ago in reply to this comment.
    Quite right. You could be much heavier at your given height with a muscular build and it should not show up as a problem in BMI measurements since that is a purported measurement of fat ratio.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ 13 years ago in reply to this comment.
    First, I honestly don't care about the thousands of others. Sure, I would hope they have coverage of some sort which suits their need but its not my obligation or my issue.

    Second, Should I get into an accident the cost could be catastrophic to my entire family. We've had really good coverage through my wife's hospital for years (I've been self-employed for more than a decade). It would be irresponsible to put them in a position to shoulder such a burden should something happen.
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Comment hidden due to member score or comment score too low. View Comment
  • Posted by Hiraghm 13 years ago in reply to this comment.
    I may agree with what NPR says in that article, but I'd sooner cite Wikipedia for veracity than NPR.


    Btw, my favorite part of the P&T video starts at 26:40 (roughly). TYVM!
    Reply | Permalink  
  • Comment hidden due to member score or comment score too low. View Comment
  • Posted by Hiraghm 13 years ago
    "As a responsible husband and father I cannot be without healthcare coverage."

    I don't see the connection here. Are you saying that for thousands of years husbands and fathers were irresponsible?

    I'm infuriated by the State Farm, Geico and Progressive commercials that condemn drivers who don't behave in ways the companies dictate. The "rate suckers" commercial implies that driving how you please is some kind of offense, and that you're not charged based upon your own policy, but upon some kind of "average" policy rate. The little spy device that Progressive (how aptly named) wants to stick in your car to monitor your driving, with the great reward of getting rational insurance rates.

    Imagine going into a casino, and having to let the dealer look at your cards before he'll take your bet.

    Insurance is (supposed to be) legalized gambling. The worst kind, because you're betting against yourself. You're betting that you're going to have an expensive illness, and the insurance company is gambling that you won't, at least not for a long time.
    Reply | Permalink  

  • Comment hidden. Undo