Open Discussion: Asimov’s Robots, Empire, and Foundation Series
I think there are some ridiculously close parallels in what Asimov wrote and what most of the ideas we're seeing today. It occurred to me that there are too many similarities with the unorthodox ideas prevalent in society today for it to be coincidentally. If possible, I'd like to discuss this with others who have read all 8 books to see if my recollection is correct.
Previous comments... You are currently on page 2.
Anyway, you've named three of my favourite series, and I would enjoy discussing other parallels.
the AI would do nothing as almost all possible actions lead to breaking one of the Laws
unless we go with the Zero Law as in I Robot
Puppeteers
did not like AI as they did not want to build their own replacements, but ended up doing so, one that rebelled
books on CD for the car...
one of Nicen's other short stories (Tales from a Tavern or something like that) had an Alien give an AI design to a human
they built it, it worked
but after a time it went silent
another aliens said the first was a joker as the AIS never worked for long
they would suffer sensory deprivation, minds working so fast and not enough input
If you want to see society with sexual mores lifted read Robert Heinlein.
(My favorite is Footfall co-written with Jerry Pournelle.)
At a lecture where Dijkstra was showing his methods for proving a piece of programming code to be correct, someone asked, "What do you think of artificial intelligence?" He answered, "I leave that to the Artificial Intelligentsia."
One fine day Isaac Asimov phoned Marvin Minsky. Minsky answered his phone there in the AI lab at MIT, "Marvin Minsky, Artificial Intelligence." Isaac said, "Isaac Asimov, the Real Thing." True? Yes, the story was confirmed by both of them.
Why do we see parallels between science fiction and "modern" real life? I think it's from the sf method of story generation: Ask, "What if ...?" Started with Mary Shelley, in my opinion, but you could suggest Swift or Bergerac or even some of the ancients as the "first" sf writers..
On the assumption, probably incorrect, that some of you have not heard of Larry Niven, you'll have missed seeing the overflowing "What if" in his story "All the Myriad Ways." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_the...
Closer to home, a well-known writer asked, "What if the men of the mind were to go on strike?"
OMG We would not get a moments peace. It could be a great piece of science fiction to write how those "screamers" are located and "removed" from the hive so the hive can survive.
I read the Foundation series but there was too much sheer speculation for me and the notion that a set of formulas could accurately predict major human events...? Yeah, that one's a bridge too far for me.
I've done the "galactic timeline" version, after I gathered the books for my collection. First, of course, I read them in random order as I came across them.
Some of the Robot novels give some insight into what we can expect with AI. How does the machine decide what constitutes "harm" to a human? Does that include hurt feelings from being told the truth? What are the criteria for deciding what is "misinformation"?
i wonder what that would bring to us
such tech is a 3 edged sword
what the programmers intended
what the politicians intended
what the AI wants
Load more comments...