Peikoff on Abortion Rights
I thought this would be interesting to discuss.
My opinion is that we do not have the right to legislate complicated moral issues. Do you own your body?
My opinion is that we do not have the right to legislate complicated moral issues. Do you own your body?
Previous comments... You are currently on page 4.
When you establish a precedent of dehumanizing those at the margins, who's next for arbitrary termination? The old, the crippled? The non-sheep?
no one would even suggest you can't slowly cut off inches only at a time of tape worm so they can't reproduce in your body if yu cut them off too soon. eeeehhhhh.
I'm going to have a nightmare tonight.
we can discuss human life vs not human life. that potential life has value is a separate argument.
you do not have a right to decide that someone else has to sacrifice their life because YOU think they should do something. this is the same argument used for every social welfare argument, and will lead to the same disastrous consequences
Abortion is more often than not wrong because human life is a value. Yes, a fetus is not an actual human life, but it is the first stage of development in a new human life. That is a value.
Now, if carrying the child to term harms the woman's life, that is a valid reason for an abortion. I can't possibly know every context of every individual and how carrying a child harms her life, which is why it's her choice. It's no different from how individuals are left to decide what harms their lives on their own because only an individual can truly knows what harms/helps her/his own life.
Load more comments...